Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: The Pokémon Company, and Nintendo. via Wikipedia

The past few years have seen Nintendo, the gaming giant behind such consoles as the Nintendo Switch and games like Super Mario, becoming more and more controversial for their litigious action, such as their ongoing legal skirmishes with Pocketpair, the game developers behind “Palworld.” This September, Nintendo was successful in patenting the game mechanics found within their Pokémon franchise.

Last week, on Sept. 2nd, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) granted approval to U.S. Patent No. 12,403,397, which was filed by Nintendo and its subsidiary, The Pokémon Company, back in 2023. In brief, the patent covers the fundamental gameplay mechanic of summoning a character and letting it fight another, according to the text of the patent itself. On Sept. 10, the USPTO granted Nintendo and The Pokémon Company another patent, No. 12,409,387 which, according to the text of the document in question, covers “smooth switching of riding objects,” as game mechanics, and was filed last year.

These legal moves to patent gameplay mechanics have left the public and game developers worried about the future. Nintendo’s detractors biggest claim is that the terms of both patents are too broad, and could, in theory, allow Nintendo a legal recourse to sue game developers for whatever they would consider as patent infringement. While Nintendo is probably not going to go to legal war with its direct competitors in the games industry such as Square Enix, such wide sweeping patents could be used to stifle competition from smaller game developers, such as Pocketpair.

One such vocal critic was Michael Douse, Larian Studios’ Director of Publishing, the studio behind the 2023’s Game of the Year, “Baldur’s Gate 3.” In a post he published on X (formally Twitter) that has since been deleted, Mr. Douse stated: “These types of patents are too often used in bad faith.”

Moreover, legal professionals are also troubled by the actions taken by Nintendo. In an interview with PC Gamer Magazine this week, videogame patent lawyer, Kirk Sigmon, was skeptical of the patents. According to Issy van der Velde, writing for the website GamesRadar: “’I have no earthly idea how the [patent] Examiner could, in good faith, allow this application so quickly,’ video game patent lawyer Kirk Sigmon says to our friends over at PC Gamer. ‘This allowance should not have happened, full stop.”

Nintendo’s success in the United States with getting its patent over flying mechanics in patent no. 12,409,387 may have something to do with the company’s lawyers suddenly rewording the text of the patent back in late July. This kind of alteration to a patent is legally acceptable according to U.S. patent laws, so long as it doesn’t introduce “new matter,” which if introduced, would violate 35 U.S. Code § 132 clause a, which explicitly states: “No amendment shall introduce new matter into the disclosure of the invention.”

The reasons for why Nintendo suddenly changed the wording of the patent in question is unclear, but it may be because Nintendo was worried its patent application wouldn’t be accepted. According to Florian Mueller, an IP Consultant writing for GamesFray on July 16: “Litigants don’t change a patent in the middle of an infringement case unless they feel the patent is at a fairly high risk of being deemed invalid in its original form…The way Nintendo has worded its new claims here is — to put it bluntly — weird, and doesn’t appear likely to solve Nintendo’s problems in this dispute.”

Despite the backlash against Nintendo’s patents being granted, the company’s actions have repeatedly raised the same question: why? Why try so much to have both patents granted? Until a statement has been released by Nintendo, we can only speculate, however two explanations seem to be present. The first, is that Nintendo is trying to patent these gameplay mechanics because they are very specific to the Pokémon franchise, and therefore Intellectual Property (I.P.) According to Brent Koepp writing for Vice.com: “Looking at the actual patent itself, it seems to be very specific to Pokémon’s auto-battle mechanic that we saw in games like Pokémon Legends: Arceus. We saw a similar system in Pokémon Scarlet and Violet with the “Pokémon Let’s Go” battle mode.”

Another possible explanation is due to the success of Palworld, and its Chinese developer, Pocketpair, partnering with Sony Music Entertainment and Aniplex as part of a joint-venture, Palworld Entertainment Inc. Sony has been a direct competitor of Nintendo for years, ever since the release of its first gaming console in 1995, PlayStation, and even before then as a result of a failed partnership over hardware for the Super Nintendo in 1989. On top of that, critical and popular reception of Pokémon has been shaky within recent years, with 2022’s Pokémon Violet and Pokémon Scarlet, receiving approximately average review scores, such 71 and 72 on Metacritic.

Whether or not Nintendo’s intentions are perfectly valid or an underhanded trick to stifle its direct competition remains to be seen, but with both patents being granted, it could, at least in theory, allow Nintendo a disquieting amount of broad legal ammunition.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *