Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Netflix via IMDB

**Due to being a true crime documentary, there will be spoilers in this review as I want to accurately discuss a real-life event.

TW: Mentions of suicide, stalking, sexual assault, cyber-bullying and harassment

When she was 13-years-old, Lauryn Licari began receiving anonymous texts consisting of death threats, sexual harassment and insults concerning her appearance and relationship. By the time the FBI had caught her stalker, Lauryn had received hundreds of thousands of messages. What no one expected was that the woman comforting Lauryn every day was the stalker.

On Aug. 29, Netflix released a new documentary that left viewers shocked, horrified and wanting to know more. “Unknown Number: The High School Catfish” (2025) takes place in Beal City, Michigan, and follows the relationship of high schoolers Owen McKenny and Lauryn Licari. Shortly before a Halloween party, Lauryn and Owen received numerous texts stating Owen would be attending the party and that he would hook up with the stalker. Lauryn and Owen ignored these messages, until eleven months later when the stalker began messaging again.

When the texts returned, they began including personal information such as nicknames, what they were wearing, their performances in sports games and what classes they were attending. These texts began coming in at 30-to-50 times a day, and consisted of increasingly violent, sexual and hurtful words each time. The school and local police became involved, interviewing numerous students in the school and holding frequent meetings with Owen, Lauren and their parents. The texts seemed to target Lauryn much more harshly, as they mentioned their romantic and sexual interest in Owen every day. Exhausted, Owen and Lauryn chose to give the stalker what they wanted in hopes of the messages ending and broke up. Unfortunately, this only made the texts more aggressive, sending Lauren death threats, messages suggesting suicide and body-shaming.

After a full year of receiving these messages, the FBI was brought onto the case. They discovered the numbers were coming from an app which disguises phone numbers and changes them consistently, so that they cannot be blocked. The FBI got a search warrant for the app and located the number connected to the stalker: Lauryn’s mother, Kendra Licari. Kendra had been an active and supportive mother to Lauryn since she was born, volunteering for her basketball team or working at the book fair. So, when the news of her being the culprit came to light, the families of Lauryn and Owen as well as the Beal City community were shocked.

The question every viewer is wondering is: why? In the documentary, Kendra explained her reasoning, saying Lauryn was getting close to the age she was when she was sexually assaulted, and out of fear, felt the need to control Lauren to “protect” her. But how could anonymously sending your daughter death threats for over a year protect her? And how does that correlate to being sexually assaulted? A cousin of Kendra’s claimed she did it for attention, as she was always someone who felt the need to be the topic of conversation and was feeling lonely after losing her job and facing challenges in her marriage. But the answer that I think was the most compelling was that Kendra — in her bad mental state — wanted to feel needed. She looked forward to her daughter coming home needing her mother to comfort her, reassure her and make her feel safe. Kendra created a reality in which she became necessary.

You can agree or disagree with any of these theories, as Lauryn herself has even said she has no idea what made her mother do this other than her poor mental state. The most shocking part of this documentary to many viewers was that Lauryn chose to stay in contact with her mom. The documentary ended with Lauryn looking into the camera and stating, “I love her more than anything.”

Overall, I believe the documentary was excellently made. It allowed each person in the case to speak on behalf of their experience and share the reasoning for their actions. Every detail shared, including the specific examples of texts, are real. But what I appreciated most was the lack of judgement towards Lauryn’s decision to stay in contact with her mother. Many viewers have agreed that Lauryn’s decision is dangerous, but, at the end of the day, it is her decision and a reaction to a very traumatic situation that directly correlates with the woman she has always depended on. If you are comfortable with the topics discussed in this case, I highly suggest watching it, just make sure you have a good hour afterwards to wallow in your disbelief. 

 


Kate McCracken is a first–year English major. 3002742@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *