Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Carlo Constintine

“[It’s] very clearly all about oil,” said Dr. Tia Malkin-Fontecchio, leading off the political science department’s teach-in on Venezuela this past Wednesday, Feb. 4. The West Chester University history professor, who also serves as the Director of Latin American and Latinx Studies, led with an abridged history of the often unstable relations between the United States and Venezuela. 

Dr. Malkin-Fontecchio noted that the political dialogue surrounding the South American nation has noticeably shifted in recent years. During the Obama administration, the White House’s qualms with Venezuela chiefly concerned the grave human rights abuses carried out by Nicolas Maduro’s authoritarian regime. Following Donald Trump’s 2025 return to the Oval Office, however, one resource has taken precedence over all else: oil. 

Specifically, President Trump has lambasted the Maduro government for what he sees as a grand theft of American property. In 2007, former Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez banned American exporters such as ExxonMobil from operating in the country. This was the culmination of a decades-long nationalization of Venezuelan oil by the country’s government, a process that left U.S. corporations greatly displeased. 

In the wake of Chavez’s decree, billions of dollars in American oil extraction infrastructure were left behind. Dr. Malkin-Fontecchio argued that this was at the core of Trump’s justification and motivation for the recent military campaign in Venezuela. She stated that it was not carried out on behalf of the taxpayer, but rather at the exclusive behest of U.S. oil conglomerates. 

Dr. Linda Stevenson of the political science department took the stage next, imparting upon the students the true scale and toll of U.S. intervention in Latin America. By some counts, she said, there have been 41 interventions, nearly all of them resulting in regional instability and hardship. Oftentimes, these operations result in brutal dictatorships that are fostered and propped up by the Pentagon. To illustrate the nature of these relationships, Dr. Stevenson cited former President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s sentiment towards Nicaraguan authoritarian Somoza García: “He’s a son-of-a-bitch, but he’s our son-of-a-bitch.” 

For as beneficial as U.S. partnerships with Latin American strongmen have been over the past century, Dr. Stevenson pointed out that our history of gung-ho interventions has directly led to a plethora of the issues that contemporary conservatives decry. The prolonged revolutions and civil wars that were instigated by the United States invariably led to thousands of deaths, ghastly human rights abuses and significant setbacks to national development. Seeking refuge from these depleted societies, waves of migrants began to seek better lives abroad, many in the United States. As such, Dr. Stevenson posited that Donald Trump’s neo-colonial intervention in Venezuela will only exacerbate the very same “migrant crisis” that he so often laments. 

Dr. Travis Blemings, professor of political science, continued the conversation with a focus on international law and its ramifications. In doing so, he did not mince words. Trump’s invasion was “unequivocally illegal,” violating the “most basic principles of sovereignty,” Dr. Blemings said. Posing to the audience a rhetorical question, he asked if the U.S. has the authority to outright remove the leader of a foreign nation. “No,” Dr. Blemings answered. “For so many reasons.” Maduro’s removal disregards the concept of diplomatic immunity, wherein world leaders are not detained due to political disagreements. A nation as powerful as the United States acting in blatant opposition to this principle could invite others to do the same.

Likewise, Dr. Blemings warned that illegal U.S. intervention in a sovereign nation sets a “dangerous precedent.” Russia may have a renewed justification for their invasion of Ukraine, while China may start to view military action in Taiwan as viable. In a global order where the United States does not have to abide by international law, its fiercest competitors will consequently feel no responsibility to do so, either.

Dr. Caitlin Brown of the political science department concluded the event by exploring worldwide ramifications. She observed that, in many ways, Trump’s Venezuela scheme is indicative of his broader foreign policy philosophy. The administration’s ambitions extend to Greenland, Iran, Cuba and Nigeria, Dr. Brown said. Whether it be supposed national security concerns or the desire to topple an antagonistic foreign regime, the White House is heavily involved overseas. “‘America First’ is not isolationist,” Dr. Brown added. Although the Trump administration has often lamented the human rights abuses of other countries, Dr. Brown is skeptical of this posturing. She believes that humanitarian issues are only important to Trump insofar as he can leverage them as a justification for American imposition. The main objective of the White House’s foreign policy at present is the political and economic enrichment of the President and his inner circle, Dr. Brown said.

She also acknowledged how this saga has diminished American respect on the world stage. Such an unapologetic and illegal show of force only exacerbates the notion that there is an eternal, oppositional divide between the Global North and the Global South, Dr. Brown said. The pivot to hard power tactics has come at an incalculable cost to the U.S.’ long established soft power, she added. By utilizing military force and tariffs rather than diplomacy and partnership, Dr. Brown reasoned that the United States is “quickly losing” influence and respect in the international community. Consequently, it will likely be much harder to achieve its foreign policy goals for many years to come, amidst a global community that is greatly dissuaded by Trump’s strongarm tactics. 

Dr. Brown elaborated that, in combination with the near total dismantling of U.S. foreign aid, America’s egocentric international presence will only further isolate emerging, peripheral nations in the Global South. In turn, these countries will begin to look towards partners seen as more reliable — U.S. adversaries such as China and Russia. Trump’s foreign policy is making far more enemies than friends, upending the decades-long paradigm of U.S. diplomacy which has proven to be massively beneficial for American hegemony.

Throughout the teach-in, each speaker emphasized the need to have a fact-based understanding of President Trump’s invasion. To hear exclusively his justification is to know just one side of what has been a highly propagandized issue by the White House.

In the end, it is difficult to know if Venezuelan destabilization will prove to be beneficial to U.S. interests. Delcy Rodriguez, Venezuela’s new leader, was Maduro’s vice president. She assumes the office governing the same regime that her predecessor left behind, with no plans to do so democratically, Dr. Malkin-Fontecchio said. Notably, however, Rodriguez has already passed a law allowing non-Venezuelan oil producers to resume activity in the nation. The United States has a “very long history of dictators who we loved working with,” said Dr. Malkin-Fontecchio. When it comes to American interventions, she offered a simple lens through which to understand the true intentions: “Look at where we intervene, and why.”

 


Carlo Constantine is a fourth-year Political Science major with a minor in Journalism. cc1031591@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *