Image Credits: Borough of West Chester – Meeting Management Center
In the wake of “Operation Metro Surge,” a federal initiative by the Trump Administration that has seen thousands of masked ICE agents pour into the state of Minnesota and led to the broad-daylight killings of US citizens, Alex Pretti and Renee Nicole Good, local governments across the country are scrambling to protect their communities before it’s too late. Last month, Philadelphia City Council Minority Leader Kendra Brooks and Councilmember At-Large Rue Landau introduced their landmark “ICE OUT” legislation. Among the proposals within the legislative package are an order legally banning ICE agents from covering their faces and traveling in unmarked vehicles while operating within the city of Philadelphia, as well a ban on collaboration between ICE and city agencies such as the Philadelphia Police Department. “With this ‘ICE OUT’ legislation,” Councilmember Brooks said at the package’s announcement, “We are doing everything within the City’s power to limit ICE activity in Philadelphia. Staying silent is not an option.” Councilmember Landau’s statement held a similar strength: “Fear is not public safety, trust is.”
On Feb. 10, West Chester Borough Councilmembers Brian McGinnis and Lisa Kearns (Ward 3) introduced an Ordinance to require Borough Council approval “prior to any participation by the West Chester Police Department in Immigration Enforcement authority under Section 287(g) of the Immigration and Nationality act.” The ordinance amends current Borough law, codifying that any contracts entered with ICE by the Borough must be publicly disclosed and approved via Council vote at a public meeting. Though he clarified that the ordinance does not prevent future Borough administration from collaborating with ICE, Councilmember McGinnis said that the amendment “ensures transparency and public input” by “preventing backdoor decisions.” He ensured that the legislation “was vetted by Chester County District Attorney Christopher de Barrena-Sarobe and State Rep. Chris Pielli,” and that the aim of the ordinance is to “affirm home-rule authority.” He also credited Councilmember Kearns as the inspiration for the ordinance, saying her concerns over “what can we do as a community” were the basis for this legislation.
As explained by Councilmember Kearns, a 287(g) contract would “create an agreement between the borough police and ICE in order to have the police act as mini-ICE agents.” However, to highlight the Borough’s current feelings towards potential collaboration, Mayor Lillian DeBaptise was invited to address the council and audience. Mayor DeBaptise referenced the joint statement shared on Feb. 6 by DA de-Barrena Sarobe and Michael P. Carroll, President of the Chester County Police Chief’s Association. In their statement, the two emphasized that “Chester County law enforcement does not enforce civil immigration orders. In fact, none of the police departments have signed a Section 287(g) agreement with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.” Mayor DeBaptise echoed this sentiment in a statement of her own.
“The events in Phoenixville certainly brought what’s going on up close and personal,” Mayor Debaptise said, referencing a video captured in Phoenixville, PA of ICE agents smashing car windows and dragging a person across asphalt. “My concern was that I did not want West Chester to be a mini-Minnesota. I did not want violence and blood on the streets here in West Chester. We know that ICE is here in Chester County […] Our concern was always to protect the citizens of this borough. All of its citizens.”
The ordinance drew support from both Councilmembers and citizens, with the Borough Council voting 3-0 to consider the legislation, but some controversy was still generated by its limitations on the power of West Chester’s Mayoral Office and Police Department. Former Mayor and State Representative, Dianne Herrin, approached the council taking “great exception” to Councilmember McGinnis’ interpretation of West Chester’s charter. Former Mayor Herrin noted that the borough’s charter “very specifically and very clearly puts the Mayor in charge of the police department,” arguing that the ordinance is “moot” considering Mayor DeBaptise’s publicly stated views. “When I was Mayor I was challenged from the inside legally, and from the outside in court. And I won. And I’m here to just implore you to respect the Mayor’s authority.” The former Mayor has spoken before on the issue of Borough police conduct, including in 2019 following a viral incident in which a West Chester Police Officer was recorded punching a man in the face during an arrest.
Though multiple WCU faculty supported the ordinance, including acting Councilmember Bryan Travis, it is unclear what this ordinance means for West Chester University and its community, as Campus Police constitutes its own police department independent of the Borough. One professor, addressing the Borough council, said “We’re in a serious crisis situation here, and this ordinance is the very least that we can do. […] ICE is racially profiling people across the country. They’re abducting people without due process. I would like to see law enforcement step in and protect the citizens against these unlawful terrorist actions that we’re all being terrified by.” Currently no statement has been made by university administration in regards to the ordinance, and no intention of similar codified actions towards transparency with the WCU community in regards to ICE collaboration has been made public at this time.
Elijah Fischer is a fourth-year English major. Af997636@wcupa.edu.
