Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Searchlight Pictures via Wikipedia

Marriage is not for everyone! To prove it, I have a movie for you. “The Roses,” directed by Jay Roach, centers on the witty-chaotic demise of married couple Ivy (Olivia Colman) and Theo Rose (Benedict Cumberbatch). Ivy and Theo, a talented chef and architect respectively, are struggling in their marriage. We meet the Roses in a therapist’s office exchanging humorous but calculated jabs. Their affectionate but agitated attitudes follow them as they navigate career, family and love. Tensions rise as the characters are forced to confront their unmet needs and buried anger. Now, with all spoilers kept close to my chest, here are the petals and thorns of “The Roses.”

My favorite quality of this film was the execution of “show, don’t tell.” The strength of screenwriter Tony McNamara’s dialogue is evident, but what goes unsaid sticks with you. There are incredible moments of both anguish and humor that are communicated solely by the actors’ physicality or the way shots are framed. Even in the couple’s verbal arguments over the little things, there is clear unspoken depth. There are also high intensity conflicts, each impressively acted and dynamically shot, and I appreciate the balance of huge reactions and capturing the minute details. “The Roses” is shot in a way that trusts that the audience can follow the more emotional and clever moments without them having to be spelled out. Though I can list instances where that quality faltered, a general feeling of intellectual respect between the audience and film remains. 

Another strength of the film is the emotional arc of the couple’s story. In no uncertain terms, Cumberbatch and Coleman are a masterclass in showing the human condition and all its emotional complexities. Many times, it felt like I was intruding on private moments, both wholesome and destructive. Theo and Ivy are relatable characters: ambitious, loving, oftentimes selfish and stubborn. They also have children and their different parenting styles create great dramatic tension, as well as humanizing them after the raw, ugly conflicts we see. Ivy and Theo are fully fleshed out, with entire careers, relationships and motivations, a lot of which is shown without being plainly spoken. There is a clear rising action that all culminates in a cathartic final act, which is beyond satisfying to watch. Squeezing a quality emotional journey into an hour and forty-five minutes is a feat, and “The Roses” was able to accomplish this with a character driven story that was deeply personal and humorous.

“The Roses” does have some thorns. The humor feels discombobulated, as I am not sure who this comedy is for. It attempts to be a black comedy, which is a comedy that is more tragedy and heavy drama, but then the film adds in Seth Rogen-esque gimmicks that muddle the tone. For example, there are overdramatic crash-outs on the beach, a random viral meme of one character and Kate Mckinnon doing strange bits about marital infidelity. These comedic moments exist beside well done sharp, cruel and witty comments. The movie seems to not know what is in tone and it leaves the audience confused, though not completely unentertained. There is space for different types of humor in the movie, such as the playful comedy in Ivy’s restaurant with her staff, played by Sunita Mani and Ncuti Gatwa. Overall, if the film had stuck to the Shakespearean vibes of an existential tragicomedy, it would have been better off. 

Two SNL legends tee up the more in-your-face, cringe-worthy, American comedy: Andy Samberg as Barry and Kate McKinnon as Amy. I resent admitting their talents were not well utilized. Barry and Amy serve as an odd couple who point out unannounced tension. Amy goes out of her way to create low stakes issues for Theo and Ivy, but that is her biggest impact. This is one of the instances that ruins the mutual respect between the film and audience that I mentioned earlier: Barry and Amy felt like cheap laughs and exposition tools. The additional couple in their social circle, Rory and Sally (played by Zoë Chao and Jamie Demetriou), are passive-aggressive and snobby, and do not have much of a role. There is one fantastic dinner scene in the second act of the film that combines most of the ensemble and the main couple, and is both funny and emotionally volatile, but that was a standalone moment.  Later, Allison Janney appears as Eleanor, and she owns the screen from beginning to end, bringing the sharp cruel wit we needed. She balanced out Barry, Ivy, and Theo, and had a strong command that matched the film well. The comedic issues with the ensemble point to characterization and script issues, not performance quality, as I think each ensemble member did their best with the characters they were given. Sometimes, there are just too many characters and too many types of humor for the story being told.

Despite my critiques, I generally enjoyed “The Roses”. The film had three-quarters of a knock-out movie, but overshot on scope and missed the mark in comedic consistency. In an attempt to cover a lot of ground it was shaky, but passionate, with many tear-jerking moments and lots of laughter. If you can swing a twenty and a short drive, I would recommend seeing the film but reframing it as a drama with some comedy. Be prepared to cry just enough, laugh out loud, be a bit tonally confused, but by the last half hour, completely committed to the explosive chaos of the final act. Go see the film, there is no better gauge for your feelings about a film than your own viewing…except me giving you the highlights, of course.  

 


Sam Mullen is a third-year psych major with a theater minor.  PM1010011@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *