Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Missed opportunities and the same ol’ same ol’. That’s what the almost 100 million viewers who tuned into last Monday night’s debate got from the presidential frontrunners.

Donald Trump, contrary to his typical “braggadocios fashion,” showed up to the debate unprepared with his guns holstered in more ways than one. Hillary Clinton on the other hand, though prepared and composed for much of the 90 minutes, failed to deliver anything different than the standard liberal agenda we’ve become accustomed to seeing every four years.

So, who won the debate? Well, if you ask me, it doesn’t matter, because one thing is for certain: the American people lost, and it doesn’t look like it will get any better.

First thing’s first, presidential debates are no longer an informative medium. As the weeklong pre-debate coverage on CNN and Fox News advertised, the presidential debates are a spectacle for entertainment purposes only.

If you’re looking to decide whom to vote for this November, you should consider doing research elsewhere, because what Monday night’s debate gave to the American public was nothing more than a he said, she said.

The candidates know they only have to appeal to the voters already on their side, and like political commentator Bill O’Reilly said, “Please keep in mind that many folks only hear what they want to hear. Partisans will never see things for what they are – it will always be what satisfies the agenda.”

Overall, Trump and Clinton gave responses similar to what we’ve seen them say in the past, although it seemed that former Secretary of State Clinton did a better job at promoting a clearer agenda than Trump.

When asked about the economy, Trump focused on revitalizing struggling American business by cutting taxes on big business in an effort to bring jobs back to America: “Under my plan, I’ll be reducing taxes tremendously, from 35 percent to 15 percent for companies, small and big businesses. That’s going to be a job creator like we haven’t seen since Ronald Reagan. It’s going to be a beautiful thing to watch.”

This was a good response by Trump in the eyes of the conservative viewer and for good reason, seeing as tax cuts for businesses and name-dropping Ronald Reagan are two of the most popular selling points for Republican voters.

Clinton also pandered to her side’s agenda when discussing the economy by giving out social programs and calling for wealthy to pay their fair share in taxes, as the Democratic nominee has done in previous years.

“I’ve heard from so many of you about the difficult choices you face and the stresses that you’re under. So let’s have paid family leave, earned sick days. Let’s be sure we have affordable childcare and debt-free college. How are we going to do it? We’re going to do it by having the wealthy pay their fair share and close the corporate loopholes,” Clinton said.

Now this plan may make Clinton seem sympathetic to middle-class America, but seeing as some of the top contributors for Clinton’s campaign come from hedge funds and investment groups like Paloma Partners and Saban Capital, who also help make up the one percent, it’s hard to believe that she truly wants to make those at the top pay their fair share – unless, of course, that payment is going into her pocket. So, in the realm of economic policy, this is perhaps the one area where Trump seemed like the more reliable candidate. However, that credibility quickly faded away as the debate wore on and the candidates began expanding on issues of social and foreign policy.

“The fact is insults now play a crucial part in our election process, and surprisingly, Trump was the weaker bully on the political playground Monday evening.”

Trump, who eventually began to lose his cool, had a major slip up when the candidates exchanged thoughts on how to address terror threats overseas: “See, you’re telling the enemy everything you want to do. No wonder you’ve been fighting – no wonder you’ve been fighting ISIS your entire adult life,” Trump said.

Clearly, since ISIS has only been an active threat for a few years, Clinton was right to call the fact checkers on Trump. This also made her appear more knowledgeable on global terrorism, a topic that’s been a major focus of Trump’s campaign.

Clinton was also able to stump Trump in other areas like the constitutionality of Mayor Giuliani’s stop-and-frisk policy in New York City, which, in 2013, was ruled unconstitutional in its practice by the NYC police department. Clinton didn’t hesitate to call out Trump on his verbal abuse of women and his reluctance to release his tax returns.

It was these kinds of attacks that brought out the egotistical defensive side in Trump that has both benefitted and hurt his campaign thus far. Though, in my opinion, Trump’s defense was weak at best, and his lack of return attacks on Clinton only furthered his downfall.

Rather than return fire on the former Secretary of State, Trump focused on defending his own name and missed several chances to condemn Clinton on her own questionable activity in instances like Benghazi and hefty donations from Wall Street. Whether or not one agrees with the appropriateness of smear tactics in politics is irrelevant.

The fact is insults now play a crucial part in our election process, and surprisingly, Trump was the weaker bully on the political playground Monday evening.

But what does all of this mean for the undecided American voter? Absolutely nothing. If you’re a Republican and want to take down Clinton, you’re going to vote for Trump. If you’re a Democrat and want to defeat Trump, you’re going to vote for Clinton.

Nothing that either frontrunner has said or will say in the upcoming debates is going to change the minds of those already decided. Nor will either candidate make a convincing case for the undecided, moderate voter because each candidate is going to continue to tailor their campaign to that of the majority viewpoint in their party.

They’ll do this because the two-party system has coerced the American public into believing that their allegiance to a particular party is more important than the policies being presented by the people who represent those parties.

We no longer elect the candidate best fit for the job; we elect the most popular party. And only when the Presidential Debate Committee allows third-party candidates like Gary Johnson or Jill Stein to participate in the debates will the American people receive a perspective other than the same tired fight between left and right.

Until that happens, it doesn’t matter who wins the debates because America will still be missing out.

Andrew Heller is a fourth-year majoring in English with a minor in journalism. He can be reached at? AH804286@wcupa.edu.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *