Image Credits: Courtesy of Fjord/Neon/FLC Press
In “Fjord”(2026), the new Palm d’or winner from Romanian filmmaker Cristian Mungiu, Sebastian Stan is distractingly, disarmingly bald. The shine that illuminates off of his bald head, like the gleam of the North Star that led the Three Wise Men to baby Jesus, is so hypnotic, so entrancing that it almost makes one forget how right-wing the film unfolding around that naked cranium is. “Fjord” screened as part of the 64th New York Film Festival, and like most of the Americanized Oscar-hopefuls coming out of Europe, it feigns being a “complicated” story where who’s in the right and who’s in the wrong is murky. The trouble is the film itself has already decided on who’s in the right, made clear by the points-of-view it decides to prioritize and what it chooses to omit from the audience’s view. The fact that it is already getting away with this bias, under the guise of both-sidesism, makes it the most dangerous film of 2026.
“Fjord” follows the Gheorghiu family, headed by Romanian father Mihai (Sebastian Stan) and Norwegian mother Lisbet (Renate Reinsve), as they emigrate from Romania to a small coastal town in Norway. The Gheorghiu family are devout Evangelical Christians, something that almost immediately draws controversy from the Norwegians whose stuffy, liberal town they occupy. When one of the Gheorghiu children absentmindedly discusses the discipline they receive at home, a nosey employee of their International school immediately contacts child services, throwing the Gheorghiu family into a very messy public battle to retain custody of their children which may have far more to do with their identity than any alleged abuse.
Mungiu’s film is based on the real life case of the Bodnariu family, whose children were seized by the Barnevernet (Norway’s equivalent to CPS) in 2015. It’s important to note that since the Barnevernet has a code of conduct that prevents it from speaking publicly as an entity, as well as from sharing details of any of its cases, the story of the Bodnarius as told by media has placed the microphone almost exclusively in their hands. That’s not the issue, however, as the Barenevent’s controversy is just one of many examples of Child Services across the globe operating on objectionable grounds, such as how America’s Adoption and Safe Families Act offers financial bonuses to employees for fulfilling a quota of children removed from their biological parents to be placed in other homes. What is the issue is how “Fjord” singles in on the parent viewpoint and then claims complexity, despite sacrificing the voices of all involved except Mihai and Lisbet, most notably that of their children. With what real-life sources he has to work with Mungiu’s hands are a bit tied, but with the film taking so many other clear liberties, what the Gheorghiu children themselves think or feel about their upbringing themselves is woefully hidden.
What’s more insidious than the one-sided focus on the plight of Mihai and Lisbet, however, is how it infects Mungiu’s filmmaking. “Fjord” hits its stride when Mungiu is exploring the subtle xenophobia displayed by Norway’s ostensibly leftist society towards Eastern Europeans. In those moments the hypocrisy and complication the film aims to tap into is on full force, arresting and infuriating as it intends to be. The only problem is, to get there, every Norwegian in the film needs to be as villainously “progressive” as possible. The evil of Norwegian society, as represented by Mungiu, comes in the form of unmarried women with short haircuts who wear pants. It is present in advertisements featuring gender inclusivity for children and interracial parents plastered on the walls of the fascistic facilities, where Mihai and Lisbet are only permitted to see their children under the watchful eye of their oppressors. It is present in the targeting from local academics who look down on “backwards” cultures while pretending to be welcoming. It is present in the lawyers who openly mock the Gheorghiu family in a court of law while reprimanding Mihai every time he so much as opens his mouth. Mungiu knows which side of this culture war he’s on, and it prevents him from ever exploring anything that might be wrong with the Gheorghius, even when Mihai welcomes the assistance of violent conservative mobs (of course the mob’s violence, just like the corporal punishment the film centers on, is only ever hinted at verbally rather than shown on screen).
Despite the film’s shallow exploration of the meat behind its drama, Stan and Reinsve deliver incredibly tender and difficult performances. Stan’s stern paternal turn reaches moments of vulnerability amidst the struggles that humanizes what could have otherwise been a stereotypical image of a wounded father’s masculine rage. Reinsve is restrained, as Lisbet’s beliefs say every woman should be, and it brings a heartbreakingly real pain to the screen as her baby is ripped from her arms. The leading duo are given the difficult task of making general audiences see the people behind the beliefs, and they do an incredible job in spite of how Mungiu makes it easy for them. Cinematographer, Tudor Vladimir Pandoru, focuses his camera on the harsh beauty of Norway’s mountains and bays, complementing the strangled strife the Gheorghius find themselves in by trapping them in the frame with jagged pillars of rock and ice.
What makes “Fjord” so dangerous is not so much what it has to say as what its reception says. It is undoubtedly a right wing movie, one where uppity liberals are sadistic and the worst crimes conservatives commit are spanking their kids, and yet the ostensibly “progressive” film institutions of the world have embraced it with open arms. Art deserves to be judged bipartisanly, and a film aligning itself with conservative values does not mean it can’t be moving or magnificent, but the “complexity” being ascribed to it seems nowhere to be found within what unfolds onscreen. “Fjord” is a clearly cut, one-sided story of a family torn apart by the woke mob. As the movie itself states, the great thing about freedom is that Mungiu is entitled to tell that story if he so wishes, and to judge it based solely on its lean to the right would be a hypocritical bias. But that lean to the right is boldly there, and if that’s what’s considered multifaceted by the tastemakers of culture at large, what does that say about the culture “Fjord” claims the Gheorghius are oppressed by? And furthermore, what does it say about our global status quo?
Elijah Fischer is a senior majoring in English with minors in Journalism and Film Criticism. He can be contacted at Af997636@wcupa.edu
