Image Credit: Courtesy of Club Kid/A24/FLC Press
Jordan Firstman is too perfect. He’s handsome, hilarious and as his directorial debut “Club Kid”(2026) now proves, highly talented behind the camera. After a hotly contested bidding war, Firstman’s freshman feature found itself a fashionable home under the banner of A24, and has since been carried through the festival circuit on the shoulders of the cheering masses. The film made a homecoming stop at the 64th New York Film Festival, where an audience all-too-familiar with the terms kundle, bundle and gundle was the perfect crowd for Firstman’s local sense of humor. What makes “Club Kid” special however isn’t its predictably niche meme references or its zippy Safdie-esque style, it’s the bleeding heart and palpable anger broiling beneath the surface of what is otherwise a simple crowdpleasing cross between “Anora” (2024) and “Big Daddy” (1999). Firstman needs to be liked, but he also has something very honest to say about growing old and the villanization of queer culture that he refuses to let his likability stifle.
Firstman stars in “Club Kid” as Peter, an aging NYC party gay who spends his days sleeping off hangovers in his cushy Manhattan apartment, and his nights buried in a world of dancefloors and k-holes. His steady diet of Grindr, key bumps and trendy DJ dolls is interrupted when a woman shows up on his doorstep with Arlo (Reggie Absolom), a 10-year-old who she claims is his son. As Peter reluctantly assumes the role of fatherhood, he begins to find himself inching towards a more responsible, more age-appropriate lifestyle. But when some of Peter’s messier habits come back to haunt him, his newly accepted parenthood finds itself under threat.
“Club Kid” feels like a necessary antidote to years of irony poisoning. Despite Firstman’s sarcasm, it is one of the more genuine, earnest features to emerge from the recent canon of New York dramedies. Firstman and Absolom’s father-son chemistry is so adorably oddball that it’s hard not to fall head over heels for these two ugly ducklings trying to do their best in a world that has beaten the tar out of them. Absolom often finds himself outshining Firstman, and contending with that charisma is no easy feat. He has a sincerity behind his performance that lends a damage to him that feels sorely missed from Firstman’s comparably cleaner character. Their joint charm is undeniable, and it only makes the sadder portions of their journey together tug at your heartstrings more.
Beyond the heartwarming journey of an unprepared dad trying to do right by his unexpected son is a quietly radical sendup of those ostracized from society. Firstman’s script is a little at odds with how it wants to view queer club culture, even if it’s obvious Peter needs to leave it behind to achieve some necessary character growth, but one thing it never loses is an empathy for the kinds of LGBTQ+ people society hates the most. Nearly every character in “Club Kid” is queer or trans, and though they exist across a broad spectrum that ranges from Diego Calva’s respectably buttoned-up therapist to Saturn Risin9’s record-spinning partygirl, they’re all undeniably pure of heart. They embrace Arlo’s entry into Peter’s life with unquestioning kindness, and Arlo’s casual allyship feels indicative of how real life relationships between cishet and LGBTQ+ people unfold beyond the limiting lens of culture wars.
Even more complex is how Firstman portrays Peter’s identity as a gay man. Though the film has some conflicting views of party culture, Firstman doesn’t depict Peter’s growth beyond the world of nightclubs and anonymous hookups as something that “cleanses” him. Even after he sobers up and begins taking care of himself as well as his kid, Peter’s sexual orientation puts his parenthood under systemic scrutiny in a way that Firstman does not hide from narratively nor sugarcoat. It lends the film a very real, very raw emotional core, and provides one of the more candid and grounded depictions of homophobia and its consequences onscreen than mainstream cinema has seen in years. The casual judgement and inherent unfitness Peter is plastered with simply for his “unconventional lifestyle” is sure to put a lump in the throat of any queer person who has felt the blow of casual homophobia.
“Club Kid” is a rare example of a queer film destined to break into the mainstream that presents an authentic, yet not all easily digestible, view of the gay experience. If Peter was a bit messier, a bit worse of a person, it might deepen his character and add a very missed tension to his dilemma of fatherhood. But the fact that he is so likable and so quick to competency deepens what Firstman wants to say about the still prominent epidemics of homophobia and transphobia. No matter how good he looks on paper, no matter how charming and lovable he is, Peter cannot escape the fact that being gay means he will always be viewed as “irresponsible” in a straight world. It makes the path he takes in growing up and the anxieties felt as a gay man sliding into middle age feel complicated by circumstance.
The film ends with Peter walking away from the club for good, and the final image of Firstman alone on an empty NYC street says a lot with very little. He does everything right, finds himself changed for the better, and yet it still isn’t enough. In what could have ended up a vanity project, Firstman instead chooses to confront gay men with our own model minority dilemma. It isn’t an easy ending to land on for your film debut, but it’s one that proves Firstman’s inherent championness isn’t undone in the seat of writer-director.
Elijah Fischer is a senior majoring in English with minors in Journalism and Film Criticism. Af97636@wcupa.edu.
