Image Credits: © 2025 MARVEL via IMDb
To say that PlayStation has had a rough year would be an understatement. With so much negative PR within the span of one summer, so much has been riding on the shoulders of Insomniac Games to deliver a hit with their latest venture, Marvel’s Wolverine. And why shouldn’t the newest X-Men game be a hit? An enormous budget allegedly has been poured into its development courtesy of its publisher, PlayStation Studios, to the tune of at least three hundred million, according to unconfirmed sources. Insomniac is favored enough to be one of PlayStation’s first-party studios ever since 2019. The developers have historically been known for making hits and have already made multiple superhero titles like the critically acclaimed Marvel’s Spider-Man. Because of this, why has Marvel’s Wolverine landed with such an unexpectedly soft reception from some gamers and critics?
Without diving into a full-fledged review of the game, it does certainly seem impressive. Insomniac Games have always been known for good presentation, such as with their previous work like Spyro the Dragon and Ratchet and Clank. Beginning with 2008’s Resistance 2, the developers have often focused on a cinematic vibe to their works. Naturally, Marvel’s Wolverine seeks to emulate this style. It makes sense in the context of a superhero character like Logan (aka Wolverine), as the camera follows him while he soaks up live gunfire and explosive carnage left and right.
Speaking of carnage, the developers have certainly ensured that Logan spills just as much of the proper red stuff himself. To quote Game Informer’s Matt Miller: “The high speed, brutal slashing and unstoppable force of Wolverine are captured better than any film or game to come before.” With bloody adamantium claws and Logan’s devil-may-care demeanor towards danger, it’s hard to not feel engaged by the first look at the finished product!
That being said, while striking visual design is important, good graphics do not make a good game, and some reviewers certainly consider the game to be style over substance. One such review that garnered significant attention was YouTuber Ralph Panebianco’s (aka Skill Up) take. “I do not recommend Marvel’s Wolverine because it is a bad game,” Panebianco stated. “I would argue that the defining characteristic at the center of Marvel’s Wolverine is a design philosophy that assumes that the player is extremely stupid.”
And it is not just one YouTuber who has expressed their frustration at the new game, as the Metacritic score for Marvel’s Wolverine currently sits at a 77% critical score and a 6.5 user score. Writing about their own mixed feelings about the game, The Guardian’s Keith Stuart stated: “As the game goes on and the enemies line up, it feels increasingly like a chore. Logan becomes what he always dreaded: hired muscle.”
The game’s main strikes against it are what seems to be gameplay that lacks a real sense of width and depth that expands beyond just viscerally slashing up enemies until they fall, and holding the player’s hand in an oppressively linear experience. Even Mountain Dew echoed this last point on their X (formerly known as Twitter) account: “How do I turn this off,” they wrote in reference to the game’s ubiquitous blue scent trails that lead to objectives.
Marvel’s Wolverine is more than just a new game that probably failed to live up to the marketing hype; it has become a flashpoint in the tumultuous discourse surrounding PlayStation and the gaming public. In almost every analysis of Marvel’s Wolverine, the circumstances surrounding PlayStation’s lackluster situation is mentioned. Andy Chalk, writing for PC Gamer said as much. “The platform’s live service travails have gotten so far out of hand that it’s managed to kill Destiny 2,” he wrote, “More recently, it pulled a massive botch with Hideo Kojima’s Physint that led to the auteur partnering with Xbox on the project instead.”
Obviously, all art is subjective. And critics of all stripes can jump on the bandwagon because it generates attention and even revenue. Regardless, the Marvel’s Wolverine situation is important. The game certainly aimed high, as most AAA games have done since the seventh generation of gaming consoles, but Weapon X didn’t manage to completely stick the landing. Otherwise, people wouldn’t be complaining about quick-time events (moments where you must hit the right button at the right time) that you cannot fail. With Marvel’s Wolverine not quite what it was cracked up to be from the trailers, the game has now put PlayStation back in the crosshairs yet again in a year that has not been kind to them.
Kelly Baker is an alumnus from West Chester University.
