Ever since the release of the original Hollow Knight (2017), it has been revered as one of the greatest games ever made. With its sleek combat system, beautiful world-building and unique enemies and bosses, there was very little to not love about it. As soon as people began finishing the game though, a sequel was demanded by the public. Though first announced in Feb. 2019, the anticipated sequel, Hollow Knight: Silksong finally hit the shelves on Sept. 4, 2025. With hopes high and a huge bar to leap, the big question on everyone’s mind is: will this sequel live up to the original? After hours upon hours of playing, it is clear there is much to love, but also some issues I didn’t see coming.
The biggest thing I was excited for was the world of Silksong, and that did not disappoint. While it’s tough to beat its predecessor, I found the world of Silksong to be an absolute blast to traverse and explore. Whether it be the greenery of Bone Bottom, the dusty winds of the Blasted Steps or the bell-infested world of Bellhart, Silksong brings a lot to this new world. Also, just like its predecessor, Silksong’s beautiful score composed by Christopher Larkin elevates every aspect of this world. With unique characters and enemies found all across the map , I loved every second I spent exploring this new world.
Unlike the first Hollow Knight, Silksong drops the subtle story moments and replaces it with a full and clear-cut story. Playing this time as Hornet, you find you’ve been captured and taken by unknown bugs, into an unknown world. Split up into three acts, Silksong works off of main objectives that change as you progress further in the story. While this does help make the game feel more streamlined, I do miss the non-linear storytelling that Hollow Knight perfected so well. While you can certainly go off the main path, but now that there is a main objective, I feel a lot less likely to.
The positive side of there being a more linear story now, is that it allows for more interesting and compelling characters. It feels like there was a lot more effort put into the dialogue, and making these characters feel more at home in their world. While a lot of the characters do tend to exposition-dump, I still found it very interesting to see the conversations held between each character and Hornet. Also, many of the characters are more involved in this new world, with numerous different side-quests you can venture off into.
While not mandatory, the side-quests are definitely a fun way to get the player to explore all the nooks and crannies of Silksong, which the main story doesn’t focus on. While this came as a huge surprise, I like how they offer unique ways to upgrade your character, as well as the new currency, beads.
Instead of shells, this time we have beads, and they’re more important than ever. Nearly everything you buy is with beads, and it is important to make sure you always have some on you. With the familiar tune of Cornifer gone, he is replaced with the equally enjoyable Shakra, and there is always a new map for sale. With the ability to purchase strands of beads, you can also keep them after you die. And when it comes to all the new enemies you’ll be facing in Silksong, you’re going to be dying a lot.
The combat system is very different, which definitely takes some getting used to. The sleek and simple combat system of the original Hollow Knight was so well polished, that it does feel strange the first time you boot up Silksong. As you progress you can find up to 4 different combat styles, each with their own unique way of playing. Charms are also now gone, replaced instead with tools that you pick up along your journey. While not as fun as the charms, these tools add new weapons and features that change the way you play. All the new stuff that Silksong offers allows the player to pick the style they prefer best, but it does also make me miss the simple nature of the original.
Healing also works differently in Silksong, as you either heal all of your hearts, or none at all. In Silksong’s predecessor you used your focus ability to heal each heart at a time, but in Silksong you use your bind ability to heal up to 3 hearts at a time. This may sound like a small change, but being forced to use all of your bind ability at once, even to heal one heart, can change a lot. Especially with how quickly you’ll be losing them.
Like I previously mentioned, the new enemies and bosses are a lot of fun. Just like the first game, I had so much fun learning attack patterns and figuring out the unique ways I had to take down each enemy. In Silksong especially, I thought they did a great job at not just reusing what made the enemies so fun in Hollow Knight, but instead making them feel very much a part of the world. They also each have their own unique look to them, so you know just from looking at them what you’re in for. When it actually comes time to fight these enemies and bosses though, is where Silksong begins to struggle.
While I would love to say this game is as flawless as its predecessor, I found a major annoyance that persisted throughout my entire playthrough. In the first Hollow Knight, many attacks hit you for one damage, with only real strong hits taking two. In Silksong, we see that switch. It feels like almost every attack, especially by bosses, hits for two hearts, and it makes dying a lot easier. With the healing system being changed too, it makes the game so much more strategic in regard to health management. I wouldn’t have a problem with this if only a few bosses hit for two hearts a lot, but in the latter half of the game it nearly becomes every enemy.
Overall this makes the Silksong much more difficult than it needed to be. Now, while I know you might be reading this and just telling me to “get good,” I dare you to play and not feel at least tempted to huck your controller at the wall. Especially with how long some of these bosses and fight sequences can get, it turns the game from challenging to just unforgivingly difficult. Numerous times I felt as if I was cheated out of my hearts and killed too early from one mistake, and it made the Silksong experience less rewarding.
Hollow Knight: Silksong isn’t the game I was expecting, but I still had an incredibly fun experience. While the story, characters and dialogue are better than its predecessor, the spikes in difficulty can make the moment to moment gameplay irritating and unforgiving. With a whole new set of enemies, and a beautifully looking world that rivals the original game, I found that it’s worth diving into the unknown most of the time, even if I knew I was likely to die. Hollow Knight: Silksong is everything fans have been waiting for, but Team Cherry sure didn’t want to make it easy for us.
Game Rating:8/10
Samuel J. Beadle is a second-year English major. SB1033446@wcupa.edu
