Wed. Nov 18th, 2026
Image Credits: Peacock via Wikipedia

Immediately upon its announcement, “The Paper,” (2025) Peacock’s new mockumentary sitcom, had impossibly big shoes to fill. Marketed not merely as a spiritual successor to “The Office,” perhaps the 21st century’s most acclaimed comedy series, but as an in-universe spinoff, it’s an unenviable position for a brand new show to find itself in. Reviews thus far have been characterized by tired, and often unfair, direct comparisons to its predecessor: a show which, many fans would tell you, can never truly be topped. 

As such, an honest and objective review of “The Paper” necessitates that we view it on its own terms, rather than in an intricate connection to “The Office.” For all the marketing ploys that NBC pulled out to draw in viewers, this is a new show, with a new cast, setting and plot. Let’s evaluate it accordingly.

In order to find an audience in its own right, and to justify a mulit-season run, “The Paper” would have to begin carving out an identity of its own. “The Office,” for as wildly popular as it was (and still is), premiered over 20 years ago. To be relevant to audiences today, the formula had to evolve. Refreshingly, “The Paper” succeeds in this regard. The writers make no attempt to lean on the characters or tropes that defined “The Office.” For as easy as it would have been to cop out, there are no Michael, Dwight or Jim carbon copies to be found. The cast strikes an admirable balance between staying true to the quirk of the show’s predecessor, while being an ensemble of characters that is believable for 2025.

Among the talented cast, perhaps the most engaging performances come from the show’s two leads. Domhnall Gleeson plays Ned, the new, idealistic Editor-in-Chief, while Chelsea Frei plays Mare, the Compositor for the newspaper, whose passion for journalism has seemingly run thin. Together, these two characters form a dynamic that is supremely likeable. Ned’s infectious optimism rubs off on Mare, who is encouraged to spread her wings and flex her passions for writing and public service. At the same time, Mare’s pragmatism informs Ned’s relentless enthusiasm, ensuring that the paper can achieve its goals despite the numerous obstacles it faces. While it is quite apparent at the offset that this is meant to be a relationship that ends up being a romantic plotline, it surprisingly never feels forced. The script is doubtlessly well-tailored to these talented actors, who bring their characters to life in ways that you can’t help but root for.

That being said, in a ten episode premier season, not everything can be a winner. In total fairness, sitcoms often use their first season to hone in on their identity and sense of humor. Point in case, “The Office” itself. It is well-documented by fans of the original show that season one is perhaps the worst, and just a little off compared to the seasons that followed. The lighting is darker, Michael isn’t very likeable and the humor is much more akin to its original British version, rather than playing on the light-hearted antics that the show would eventually become known for. 

Like its predecessor, “The Paper” by no means delivers a perfect pilot season. There are some scattered B- and C-plots that meander and lack an engaging hook, oftentimes involving characters that feel, to this point, a bit underdeveloped. The cast that surrounds Ned and Mare are no doubt talented, each having a number of fun moments, but it is hard to shake the feeling that a bit more depth would serve them well. Esmerelda, for example, played by Sabrina Impacciatore, can be hit or miss. Impacciatore’s melodramatic performance alone leads to a number of laughs, although the writers can play this hand a bit too over the top at times. In combination with subplots that have her acting in blatantly unlikeable ways, Esmerelda has perhaps the most room, and necessity, for evolution in future seasons. Detrick, portrayed by Melvin Gregg, shines in his limited screentime, but really isn’t given enough to be fully understood in this short pilot season. The foundation that has been laid here is more than enough to confidently believe that the writers, given the opportunity to continue this series, will mold this supporting cast into a fleshed-out ensemble that regularly contributes to the plot. 

All that being said, while the inaugural season of “The Paper” necessarily builds towards a concrete identity, the moments that land do so with confidence and edge. Carried by fun performances and sharp writing, the show is absolutely worth a look for sitcom fans everywhere. There is a lot to love about “The Paper,” and early adopters can look forward to more — NBC has already greenlit a second season.

 


Carlo Constantine is a fourth-year Political Science major with a minor in Journalism. CC1031591@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *