With Nov. 7 rapidly approaching, election day is right around the corner. Various state and local positions are on the ballot this year, including for the Pennsylvania Supreme, Superior and Commonwealth courts. In an effort to inform the West Chester University community on this upcoming election, The Quad conducted an interview with Pennsylvania Supreme Court candidate Carolyn Carluccio.
Carluccio, of Montgomery County, is running as a Republican in the Supreme Court race to fill the seat left open after Justice Max Baer’s death in Sept. 2022. She is currently the first female president judge of the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas, a position she has held for two years.
Carluccio’s background experience includes working as a federal prosecutor for the U.S. Attorney’s Office for nine years. She was also Montgomery’s county’s Chief Public Defender and Chief Deputy Solicitor and the president of the Montgomery Bar Association. She has served as a judge on the Court of Common Pleas for 14 years.
Carluccio said she is running on a non-politicized platform, saying that the sole role of the judiciary is to “apply the law and uphold the constitution.”
“I certainly have grown to realize that we need somebody who is independent, who is fiercely unbiased. We need somebody who understands the role of the judge and I’m that person,” Carluccio said. “I am not political. I understand that lady justice is blind for a reason.”
The following is a transcript of the interview between Olivia Schlinkman and Carolyn Carluccio edited for clarity and length.
Q: Something unique about Pennsylvania is how its judicial elections are partisan elections — however, you have made it clear that you are not running on a platform of specific issues or stances. How are you distinguishing yourself as a candidate to voters?
A: I’m honest, I’m ethical, I have integrity. This is what differentiates me from the opponent. I am not political, I do not have an agenda. Because there is no judge that should ever take the bench and bring their agendas with them. I can’t be more firm about that. I think that the people of Pennsylvania deserve judges who understand their role and who do not bring agendas with them, and unfortunately, not all judges understand that.
Q: In your history of working in the PA legal system, how have you demonstrated an ability to prioritize the law over politics?
A: You can look at any case. For 14 years I’ve been a judge and I have applied the law every single time. There is not one case that anybody can point to that I’ve decided that has been based on any political agenda. I think my body of work is my proof.
Q: As a judge, what do you believe is the proper role of the court in interpreting and applying the law, and do you supplement this position with originalist or nonoriginalist views?
A: I do not give a definition because I think it means different things to different people. My opinion is I think it’s just the way the judge has to be. If you look at our constitution with three branches of government, it is very clear there are delineations between each of them. It’s the executive branch, legislative branch and judicial branch. And our entire country has been built on the differentiation between those three branches. And although there are checks and balances, there is no place for the judiciary to take on the role of the legislature. There is no room for that. We need to understand our roles. It does not mean I disagree with anything, all it means is that I know where I belong in this system.
Q: In a common vein, what are your views on judicial activism?
A: I reject judicial activism, not just from Democrats but from Republicans too. I reject it from everyone, there is no place for it. The courts are generally the last place people can go for consistency and to know what’s going to happen, and if we let that go then there’s nowhere for people to go. We’ll lose integrity in the system, in our justice system, and that’s not fair to the people of this commonwealth.
Q: Issues such as healthcare and voting rights have been in focus in national and state courts, as well as political and legal discussions in general. An article published earlier this month in The Philadelphia Inquirer described how the results of this race are “expected to become a tie-breaking vote on election cases ahead of the 2024 presidential race.” Whether or not you as a candidate have publicly expressed your opinion on such issues, how do you view the court’s role in ruling on such topics?
A: It’s really simple. Our job is to follow the law. And whatever the law is, we should follow [it]. You’re going to know what to expect from me because I’m going to follow the law. If it’s an activist judge, you don’t know what they’re going to do because they may agree with your viewpoints one day and the next day they may not agree with your viewpoints. They’ll take it upon themselves to make a change they think needs to be made. I think there’s a lack of understanding of what a judge’s role is. This is not about politics, this is about what our judges need to be doing and what they don’t need to be doing. Just be aware, an activist judge today will be one you don’t like tomorrow. But I’m going to be consistent.
Q: Young voters are becoming an increasingly important population in terms of voter turnout. But with local elections like this, sometimes voters aren’t as inclined to know about or engage with these elections. What would your message be, especially to this younger demographic, about the importance of state judicial elections and their impact?
A: I would say, people, they don’t really realize how much a judge impacts them. In the end the rulings are broad, and they’re very important things — not much gets up to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court takes about 150 cases a year. They’re also involved in a lot more than just that. They’re involved in administrative, supervisory [tasks], which is what I do as a president judge. I do all of that already. I am supervisory, administrative over my 24 judges, my 30 magisterial district judges [and] all of our treatment courts.
Olivia Schlinkman is a third-year Political Science major with minors in Journalism and Spanish. OS969352@wcupa.edu

I’m curious because I’m always amazed and amused by people like you. What makes you think that you are uniquely qualified to make decisions for women like me?? It seems to me to be delusions of grandeur! A response would be appreciated please!
I’m curious. What makes you think that you are uniquely qualified to make decisions for women like me, Delusions of grandeur perhaps??