With Nov. 7 rapidly approaching, election day is right around the corner. Various state and local positions are on the ballot this year, including the Pennsylvania Supreme, Superior and Commonwealth courts. In an effort to inform the West Chester University community on this upcoming election, The Quad conducted an interview with Pennsylvania Supreme Court candidate, Dan McCaffery.
McCaffery, of Philadelphia County, is running as a Democrat in the Supreme Court race to fill the seat left open after Justice Max Baer’s death in Sept. 2022. He is currently a judge on the Pennsylvania Superior Court, a position he has held since 2019.
McCaffery’s background experience includes working as a prosecutor for the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office, a civil trial attorney at a law firm in Montgomery County and a judge on Philadelphia’s Court of Common Pleas for six years. McCaffery was chosen by the PA Supreme Court to serve on the Committee of Judicial Discipline in 2020.
McCaffery emphasized prospective issues that will be ruled on by the state supreme court and his history of involvement with social movements as important to his campaign.
“I think what you see right now at the national level is — I think you’re seeing a lot of cases… that are really being peeled back by the U.S. Supreme Court level,” McCaffery said. “These are now all issues that are of interest to me, that are also going to be decided by each individual state under state supreme court constitutions, so that is why I am running.”
The following is a transcript of the interview between Olivia Schlinkman and Dan McCaffery edited for clarity and length.
Q: You mentioned that you are running based on those substantive due process cases that are being rolled back at a national level. How else are you distinguishing yourself as a candidate to voters?
A: Judicial elections are very simple. Judicial elections historically are all about your qualifications, your credentials, a little bit about your judicial philosophy. But I think they’ve become very politicized over the last several years. When you start looking at the polls, I think the U.S. Supreme Court level right now, or the courts in general, enjoy the lowest approval rating in their history. I think that’s because a lot of people now believe that the courts are becoming politicized. When I talk about this particular race, I talk about my life experience because I think it’s important. You’ve heard my experience and why I think I’m the best qualified person for this race, but it’s also your values. I come from a very blue-collar, middle class background which distinguishes me dramatically from my opponent. I’m someone who’s worked my entire life for social justice issues, criminal justice reform; I’ve got a proven track record along all those particular issues. I’m the only one frankly who’s running for the top appellate court in the commonwealth of Pennsylvania with any kind of appellate experience.
Q: And you mentioned how currently [the courts] are at the lowest level of confidence that we’ve seen in a long time for the judicial system. What do you think is key to restoring that confidence in the American public?
A: I think judges have to do it one case at a time. The American public —in Pennsylvania specifically —people have to believe that you’re fair, impartial and that you’re going to put partisan politics aside. Politics is kind of part of the process of getting elected judge, but politics has nothing to do with the actual job itself. Once you’re elected judge, you have to hang up your partisanship. I’ve got a very well-defined career. I’ve literally represented and been involved in thousands of public decisions. Nobody’s ever going to point to one of my decisions and say it was politics, it was partisanship. That’s not what I do, that’s not what I’m known for. I’m known as somebody who is a judicial ethicist, somebody who strictly adheres to judicial conduct rules. You have to build a collegial relationship with the people you’re serving.
Q: As a judge, what do you believe is the proper role of the court in interpreting and applying the law, and do you supplement this position with originalist or nonoriginalist views?
A: The supreme court’s a bit of a different animal. The supreme court is what’s called a policy making court. [It] handles all cases regarding constitutional interpretation, statutory intent and public policy questions. As for originalism, I think originalism is a phony, made-up kind of legal construct. Originalism never existed in American legal parlance for the first 200 years of our constitution. So they basically came up with this legal construct they called originalism saying we need to apply the constitution as it was originally intended. Nobody had ever heard about that because it’s kinda silly — even the framers of our Constitution said this is a living document. It’s got to be interpreted in accordance with its times.
Q: In a common vein, what are your views on judicial activism?
A: When you say judicial activism I think we should clarify what we’re talking about. Judicial activism is nothing more than ignoring precedent to arrive at a conclusion that you want as opposed to what the law provides. A lot of conservatives use the term, “I’m not a judicial activist,” but yet they turn around and say, “well, we agree with what the Supreme Court did in Dobbs.” Well, Dobbs reversed Roe v. Wade. Roe v. Wade was the law, [the] precedent for over 50 years. That in itself is pure, unadulterated political judicial activism. When you see what’s going on at the U.S. Supreme Court level, [like] rolling back affirmative action; affirmative action’s been upheld by multiple supreme courts over 50 years. That’s judicial activism. Allowing discrimination against LGBTQ couples based upon an alleged first amendment protection is in fact judicial activism. So that’s what I mean when I say rolling back rights. These are rights that evolved over the last 50-60 years that are now being rolled back.
Q: Issues such as healthcare and voting rights have been in focus in national and state courts, as well as political and legal discussions in general. An article published earlier this month in The Philadelphia Inquirer described how the results of this race are “expected to become a tie-breaking vote on election cases ahead of the 2024 presidential race.” Whether or not you as a candidate have publicly expressed your opinion on such issues, how do you view the court’s role in ruling on such topics?
A: Obviously the bedrock principle of American democracy is one person, one vote — we all understand that. I think there’s been a lot of discussion in our race about Act 77, which is the expansion of vote by mail. I look at things pretty simply. From a constitutional perspective, I believe the Constitution is in fact a living document. I’ve already told you how I feel about originalism, which is the antithesis of a living document. I’ve been pretty clear as far as voting rights are concerned. Judges, we need to be very careful that we are not going to commit to any particular result in a case because that would violate the judicial canon. But generally speaking, Act 77 was passed with broad bipartisan support. The whole statutory intent behind Act 77 was to encourage more voters. I’ll say this: I think we should be looking for ways to count votes, not to discount them.
Q: Young voters are becoming an increasingly important population in terms of voter turnout. But with local elections like this, sometimes voters aren’t as inclined to know about or engage with these elections. What would your message be, especially to this younger demographic, about the importance of state judicial elections and their impact?
A: Very simply put, the people you elect today are gonna create the society you want to live in tomorrow. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: when we talk about substantive due process rights that are getting pulled back into the states, these issues are on the table. Womens’ reproductive rights, abortion access, LGBTQ equality; these are things we thought were settled for a generation and now they’re going to have to be decided by the state Supreme Court because of what’s happening at the U.S. Supreme Court level. Everybody needs to pay close and careful attention to who the people running for judges are, and what their stances are in these particular issues. I’ve told people before: everyone gets excited for Josh Shapiro, John Fetterman, and nobody really pays much attention to judicial races. But no governor, no senator, no president can take away your rights with the stroke of a pen — but a judge can.
Olivia Schlinkman is a third-year Political Science major with minors in Journalism and Spanish. OS969352@wcupa.edu
