Image Credits: Courtesy of NEON/FLC Press
To feel like a stranger in your own body is one of life’s biggest nightmares, and it’s one the trans community knows all too well. Arthur Harari, who co-wrote 2023’s “Anatomy of a Fall” alongside his partner Justine Triet, is no stranger to tapping into the implicit horror of gender in our world. His newest directorial effort, “The Unknown,” is another collaboration between Harari and a loved one, this time springing from a graphic novel co-written alongside his brother Lucas. The film screened as part of the 64th New York Film Festival, and saw the Harari boys join together with French screenwriter Vincent Poymiro to spin a strange tale of discomfort in the body and the soul; one that feels firmly rooted in the horror of gender dysphoria at a time when trans people everywhere are under attack for trying to escape that horror. Roger Ebert famously said that movies are like “a machine that generates empathy,” a way for the audience to understand what it’s like to endure a life outside their own. “The Unknown” places its surreal premise in the hands of a raw and naked directorial vision, and when audiences feel themselves buried within the same powerlessness of its characters, there is no doubt that the empathy for those suffering in bodies they can’t call home the film is sure to generate.
“The Unknown” stars Niels Schneider as David Zimmerman, a French photographer on the cusp of 40 struggling with his mental health. When David has a mysterious sexual encounter with Eva (Lea Seydoux), a woman he meets in the dark corners of a nightclub, he wakes up the next morning to find that he has switched bodies with her. As he tries to track the woman down, David discovers that he is not the only person this has happened to. With the mystery expanding, and the list of people now trapped in bodies of the opposite sex following encounters with the evasive entity growing by the day, David must come to terms with the horrible possibility that he may never see his own face in the mirror again.
Schneider and Seydoux deliver two of the year’s best performances as prisoners of the opposite sex. As the Hararis’ script avoids cheaply making gender stereotypes the butt of the joke (the way body-swap stories so often do), the two stars are allowed to represent characters trapped in vessels that don’t match their souls in far more subtle ways. Seydoux’s gait changes, Schneider’s voice grows more soft-spoken, and it’s in these little details we see the people trapped inside fighting against the bodies nature has held them captive in. Arthur Harari’s direction embraces a style emulative of sci-fi thrillers of the 1970s, which marries pulp with intimacy in a shockingly well-done way. The slow-zooms capture the familiar just as well as the alien, and the Kafkaesque hell the two find themselves in is presented with disorienting bluntness. While “Eva” and “David” race to find a way back to their true bodies before all hope is lost, audiences are left just as helpless in the face of their situation.
The Hararis’ script also sinks its teeth into some deeper intricacies of gender that push the film’s terror beyond being stuck in a body you’re not at home in. The sexually transmitted nature of “David” and “Eva”’s predicaments fills the film with deeply unsettling sex scenes, which obscure any graphicness and refuse to leer but still convey all the violence and coldness they need to simply through uncompromising performances. Furthermore, being trapped as the opposite sex means “David” and “Eva” are both at the mercy of their outward appearances, foreign genitalia and societal baggage. The issue of pregnancy rears its ugly head throughout the film, which brings in borderline Cronenbergian horror, but also allows our characters to be confronted with gender roles they’d previously condemned to the opposite sex. When a woman trapped in a man’s body and a man trapped in a woman’s body are forced to come together as a couple, the result is a Rubik’s Cube of gender politics where power and choice are put under a microscope by those completely robbed of it. The contradictory feelings towards gender present in every human, where blessings and curses don’t always come separately, are explored with a certain tenderness by writer-director Arthur Harari that is rare to see in a world where gender has been turned into an essentialist battleground.
“The Unknown” stands out in a year where the iron of sex and gender is hardly the hottest to strike because, like Kafka or Cronenberg, Arthur Harari and his brother hide an earnest and grounded voice inside of a dizzying outer shell. Aided by the complex performances of their cast (including a surprisingly heartbreaking appearance by fellow NYFF 64 entrant Radu Jude) and a gaze that meshes past with present, Arthur Harari tells a simple story about regular people held hostage by anatomy. While bleak and nihilistic at times, it never abandons a clear empathy for those who are forced to live a life in an outer shell that doesn’t match their insides, and “The Unknown” finds an evergreenness in gender trouble that is bitterly human. The case of David Zimmerman and his companions may not be a very happy one, but perhaps understanding that is the first step needed to make sure no one else has to go through life trapped in a body they don’t belong in.
Elijah Fischer is a senior majoring in English with minors in Journalism and Film Criticism. He can be contacted at Af997636@wcupa.edu
