Image Credits: Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures/FLC Press
“Behemoth!” writer-director Tony Gilroy’s first feature in 12 years, is secretly a musical. Though its cast does not sing, its score functions so in tandem with how it tells its story that to classify it as anything other than a musical would be unfair. The film had its world premiere at the 64th New York Film Festival, where it made itself at home with booming majesty in the concert halls of the Lincoln Center. Gilroy turns the intimate into the operatic through his unconventional approach to character study, and when aided by a career-best performance from leading man Pedro Pascal, delivers one of the most searingly personal films of 2026.
“Behemoth!” follows Alex Serian (Pascal), a cellist hailing from a long line of acclaimed musicians, who returns home to Los Angeles following decades spent on the road. The film jumps through Alex’s life as if time were a suggestion rather than a rule, tracking his losses in love and career alongside the slow disintegration of his messy family, all while Alex’s return to Hollywood as a scoring musician for films coincides with the rise of a strange musical prodigy who Alex suspects shares more in common with him than orchestral genius.
Gilroy’s acrobatic screenplay is like a single instrument. It plays beautifully on its own, but when joined in orchestra by a lyrical sense of editing, the lived-in performances of his cast (including a pathetic Will Arenett, a heartbreakingly real Eva Victor, and a hilariously unhinged Olivia Wilde), and a score that doesn’t reflect his characters so much as move them like the hand of God, it creates a cinematic symphony. Despite its grandeur, the film is incredibly complicated and tempered in its storytelling. We get to piece together who Alex is through subtle details and episodic glimpses into the people he passes by. It all crescendos into a story about life, death and mistakes made on the path between that feels welcomingly grounded despite its sweeping majesty.
Pascal’s performance is the tempo at which “Behemoth!” is built on, and he seems to know more about Alex than the audience will ever be allowed to. He brings warmth and charm as well as self-sabotage and indifference to the role in a way that perfectly captures the human experience in all its bittersweetness. The interiority of Alex harmoniously collides with those who drift in and out of his life in a way that builds to the dilemma of the film’s final act only to rob you at the final note of an easy catharsis. There’s an almost Sondheimian wit to the way Gilroy leaves simple answers to the emotional troubles of Alex and company just out of reach, and it only serves to make them feel more true to life. In the end, there’s no vanity to Alex, the film keeps him on his knees, and thanks to Pascal’s tender turn he stays human and understandable even if his moral character is up for debate.
Olivia Wilde is another standout, delivering one more great appearance in a year she has spent dominating up and down. She moves in and out of the story like a demon, giving us one of the movie’s highlights in an opening chase scene with Pascal that would feel more at home in a heist film. Each time she rears her head again it hits like a punchline, and as she gets locked in a Coyote/Road Runner-esque hunt for Alex across the years, she never fails to make the premiering crowd cackle. Though her role is only a small portion of “Behemoth!”’s runtime, Wilde makes the absolute most of every morsel of attention she gets from the camera. Unfortunately, she has stiff competition for the funniest performance of 2026: herself, both in “I Want Your Sex” and her directorial debut “The Invite.” What Wilde does with her momentary presence proves a point Laura Dern’s unfairly brief turn in “Jay Kelly” (2025) established about female roles in male-dominated films. Even when tangential to the stories of men, Hollywood’s women will find a way to leave their mark through raw talent.
“Behemoth!”’s score can seem overwhelming, acting as both a bridge between Alex’s memories and a Greek chorus in his life. But despite its all-encompassing drama, it becomes an almost elemental presence that functions symbiotically with both script and actors. Just as Gilroy took an unconventional approach to penning the film’s script, he tackled the scoring of the film with a similar tenacity. Nine total composers, including award-winners such as Michael Giacchino, James Newton Howard and Alan Silvestri, formed the musical brain behind the film, and their work forms its lifeblood. Some of the movie’s most emotionally arresting moments come from the blending of diegetic film scores with the compositions behind “Behemoth!” itself, blurring reality and fiction in a theatrically dizzying yet epically effective way.
Much like life, “Behemoth!” is a colossal compoundment of comings and goings. Alex loves and leaves, people around him die and people around him are born. In a Q&A following the premiere, Pascal described Alex as a passenger. It’s clear from the aptness of that description that Alex is unknowable to anybody who has not lived inside of him, but perhaps that unknowability is part of being human. Alex himself never gets to truly know his family, nor his lovers, nor his friends. Perhaps the story Gilroy wants to tell the most is a story of life and how it will carry us along whether we point it in a direction or not. While getting there, Gilroy makes his audience realize something the characters in the film are forced to learn the hard way: as unknowable as Alex is, maybe trying to get to know him is instead the best way to finally know yourself.
Elijah Fischer is a senior majoring in English with minors in Journalism and Film Criticism. He can be contacted at Af997636@wcupa.edu.

