“Iran was not a high-level threat to the United States,” said Dr. Travis Blemings at his April 16 teach-in on the War in Iran. “On a scale of one to ten, they were never above two or three.” As the conflict in the Middle East carries well into its second month, Dr. Blemings and the Political Science department sought to explain the origins and implications of the ongoing U.S.-Israeli military operations.
The lecture kicked off with context on Iran as a nation, and its diplomatic history with the United States. As the world’s fifth largest oil producer, and exerting large amounts of control over the Strait of Hormuz, Iran plays a massive role in the global gas supply. In America, we’ve seen this play out first-hand with soaring prices at the pump.
Dr. Blemings proceeded to explain that while Iran maintains the “trappings of democracy,” it is functionally an authoritarian Islamic theocracy. It is ruled by a Supreme Leader, who wields religious authority and oversees broad policy decisions. The current Supreme Leader, Mojtaba Khamenei, has only held the position for under two months. His predecessor, Ali Khamenei, was assassinated in February by a U.S.-Israeli airstrike.
The United States and Iran have a long and historically tenuous relationship. In 1951, then Prime Minister Mohammed Mossadegh nationalized the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, the country’s chief oil producer that was jointly owned with the British. The U.K. viewed this as unacceptable, and quickly turned to their allies across the Atlantic. The U.S. swiftly cut off economic aid to Iran and banned the import of their oil.
In 1953, U.S. and British intelligence sought to oust PM Mossadegh, carrying out a covert plan known as Operation Ajax. It would put in place Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the Shah of Iran, as the new leader of the country, effectively serving as a Western puppet. While Mossadegh was a popular leader among his people, the Shah was, by contrast, deeply unpopular and generally viewed as an American figurehead. It was here, following the Western-backed coup that ultimately empowered Pahlavi, that anti-American sentiment began to take root in Iran.
After decades of military dictatorship under the Shah, the situation in Iran reached a boiling point in 1979. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khamenei, a religious dissident and political activist, returned from exile amid massive street protests, advocating for a fundamentalist Islamic state. During the already untenable unrest, the Shah, requiring medical care, left for the United States. Fearing that the U.S. and the Shah would collude to restore him to power, anti-American protestors stormed the American embassy in Tehran and took 52 diplomats hostage for 444 days. For both Iran and the U.S., this was a point of no return for friendly relations. The U.S. would permanently suspend diplomatic ties following the hostage crisis, which became a watershed moment in American politics.
Today, the defining issue of U.S.-Iran relations is the ambiguity of Iran’s nuclear program. Dr. Blemings noted, however, that this deep-seeded suspicion was not always the case. As a matter of fact, the United States had helped Iran jump start its nuclear infrastructure. In 1957, the U.S. entered into an agreement with Iran in which uranium fuel and technical expertise would be provided for the creation of energy sites. Ten years later, the agreement was renewed, with the U.S. providing Iran plutonium — the main ingredient required for nuclear weapons.
In the immediate aftermath of the 1979 revolution, the Ayatollah actually disavowed the nuclear program he inherited from the Shah’s regime, viewing it as a Western technology. However, the outbreak of the Iran-Iraq War (in which the U.S. backed Iraq) made him reevaluate the benefits of a nuclear program. As Iran tried to revive its nuclear capabilities, the U.S. lobbied the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) against them. In response to American resistance, Iran began to work with U.S. rivals to build up its nuclear infrastructure, such as Russia and China.
In 2002, the U.S. discovered Natanz, a secret Iranian enrichment facility that could theoretically produce a warhead. The IAEA ultimately concluded that while there was no evidence to support the idea that Iran was actively pursuing nuclear weapons, they did specify that the regime engaged in a “policy of concealment.”
American paranoia surrounding Iran’s nuclear program largely remained at a fever pitch until 2015, when President Obama signed the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). This agreement with Iran was unprecedented — the activities of their nuclear program and the amount of plutonium they could enrich and stockpile was heavily limited, and an “extensive inspections regime” was instated. Ensuring that Iran could not acquire a nuclear weapon seemed like the best-case-scenario conclusion to the long-standing geopolitical rivalry, and the JCPOA stood as a milestone achievement in American foreign policy.
However, in 2018, President Trump unilaterally withdrew from this agreement. He notoriously claimed that it was one of the worst deals ever made, and vowed to create a better one. To date, no such treaty has been signed with Iran. Just one year after the dissolution of the JCPOA, in 2019, Iran resumed uranium enrichment.
In June 2025, shortly after President Trump’s resumption of the presidency, the U.S. dropped a “bunker buster” on Fordow, an Iranian nuclear facility. The administration, in the aftermath of the bombing campaign, claimed to have completely destroyed Iran’s nuclear capabilities.
The War in Iran we currently find ourselves in, having started in February 2026, lacks a clear narrative, Dr. Blemings said. President Trump has made meager efforts to sell the war to the American people, with perhaps the most common refrain being the claim that Iran was close to the development of nuclear weapons. Dr. Blemings added that this is not a new idea — the misconception that Iran has been close to a warhead goes back as far as the 1980s. More specifically, Benjamin Netanyahu, Prime Minister of Israel and close ally of President Trump, has been making this alarmist claim for the better part of the 21st century.
Dr. Blemings said that Israel has lobbied every American administration for the past 20 to 30 years to pursue regime change in Iran. President Trump, in his second term, is the first to comply. Joe Kent, the recently resigned National Counterterrorism Center Director, said of the war: “Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.”
As for the shaky claims that Iran was on the verge of a nuclear arsenal, the IAEA says that it cannot be certain. The U.S. and Israeli bombing campaigns have made it impossible for international inspectors to visit.
When asked if regime change was a reasonable outcome to expect from the war, Dr. Blemings was skeptical. He acknowledged that the toppling of Iran’s current government would likely be an overall good thing, seeing as it regularly engages in state violence and is otherwise incredibly authoritarian and repressive. At this point in time, however, Dr. Blemings said that regime change was “absolutely not in the cards.” American bombs have only served to further radicalize the Iranian government, he reasoned. If the goal of the war was to dismantle their nuclear program, such an escalation only means the Iranians will pursue nuclear weapons more aggressively, if it is indeed a goal of theirs. The people of Iran have also found themselves in an unwinnable situation. While there have indeed been massive street protests against the Ayatollah, many Iranians would be hard-pressed to see the U.S. as their saviors, a nation actively dropping bombs on their cities and with a history of meddling.
While the future of the conflict remains unclear, Dr. Blemings said that he would be very surprised if the Republican controlled Congress votes to end the war.
Carlo Constantine is a fourth-year Political Science major with a minor in Journalism. cc1031591@wcupa.edu
