Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Ariana Grande as Glinda in “Wicked: For Good” (2025). Photo by Giles Keyte/Universal Pictures – © Universal Studios. All Rights Reserved. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt19847976/mediaviewer/rm1261349634/?ref_=ext_shr_lnk

In 1934, Nazi Minister of Propaganda Joseph Goebbels gave a speech at the annual Nuremberg Rally for the Nazi Party, a rally later immortalized in the infamous Nazi propaganda film, “Triumph of the Will” directed by Leni Riefenstahl. In his speech, Goebbels said that, “Propaganda is a means to an end. Its purpose is to lead the people to an understanding that will allow it to willingly and without internal resistance devote itself to the tasks and goals of a superior leadership. If propaganda is to succeed, it must know what it wants. It must keep a clear and firm goal in mind, and seek the appropriate means and methods to reach that goal. Propaganda as such is neither good nor evil. Its moral value is determined by the goals it seeks.” Years later, when Riefensthal was arrested during the Nuremberg trials by fellow filmmaker, Budd Schulberg, for her role as the cinematic mouthpiece for the Nazi party, Schulberg recounted that she said “Of course, you know, I’m really so misunderstood. I’m not political.”

“Wicked: For Good” is a film whose moral value is determined by the goal it seeks, and that goal is cleanliness. There is no apter symbol of its hypocrisy than the radio silence from those behind it on the censoring of an anti-fascist comment from cast member Marissa Bode, despite that comment drawing direct parallels between what the film claims to denounce and what’s happening on this side of the rainbow. It is a movie that is at odds with its own message, and the result is a corporate frankenstein of a movie-based-on-a-musical-based-on-a-book-based-on-a-movie with all meaning and depth deliberately lost in translation, because meaning and depth do not make people want to go buy a plastic Glinda wand at Target or take their 6-year-old to Universal’s theme park in Orlando. 

The film picks up five years after the events of the first movie (something you’d have no way of knowing if you’re not already familiar with the stage show). Elphaba Thropp has now become the Wicked Witch of the West, with her acts of political defiance being spun as terrorism by Madame Morrible, her former teacher and secret right-hand-woman to the Wizard. Meanwhile, Elphaba’s ex-best-friend has now become a living piece of propaganda for the Wizard’s regime as Glinda the Good. Caught between the two women is their shared love interest Prince Fiyero, who has become Captain of the gestapo-like Gale Force in an effort to find Elphaba and set things right. But when a storm blows in and threatens to change the history of Oz forever, the friends must find a way to some form of peace and understanding before their fates are sealed for good.

 It’s hard to explain what’s wrong with “Wicked: For Good” without delving into the history behind “Wicked” as a story. “Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West” was a novel published in 1995 by Gregory Maguire. Grimdark and shamelessly adult in tone, with a psuedo-steampunk aesthetic and plenty of Catholic guilt seeped into each word, the novel is mired in the politics of its time. Everything from AIDs to apartheid can be felt through its story, as Elphaba tries and fails to violently make people care about a minority group slowly disappearing before her very eyes. The stage show drained as much of that complexity as possible, but it too was inescapably tied to its moment, debuting on Broadway two years into the War on Terror and the height of Islamophobic pandemonium in the Western world. “Wicked”, in novel and in musical form, is inherently a tragedy shaped by harsh realities: justice is never what you imagine it to be, and sometimes it doesn’t even come at all.

“Wicked: For Good” dispenses all of the tragedy in favor of a neat, inoffensive ending.

 In the novel Elphaba dies, but in the musical (scrubbed for a tourist audience) she survives Dorothy’s bucket of water. The same happens in the film, but with an additional change: Glinda, who in the musical ends her story wracked with the guilt of failing her presumed-dead friend, instead gets a longer tangent than the titular character. As Elphaba is forced to flee Oz, Glinda finishes Elphaba’s work of freeing the animals. Later, as she sings a final goodbye to her dead friend, Elphaba’s spellbook opens. Glinda, whose blonde-haired-blue-eyed character was written to represent those who throw their values under the bus to reap the benefits of a corrupt system, ends her story usurping everything that made Elphaba, a literal and allegorical person of color, unique. As Elphaba has to retreat into an endless desert, a failure who “has to be wicked so Glinda can be good”, her Ozian/Aryan friend gets to not only be the people’s princess, but gets to claim credit for Elphaba’s activism and ability in the eyes of the audience as well as the lynch mob that chased her friend out of Oz.

As of this article’s publishing, “Wicked: For Good” will have been in theaters for four weeks. Much has already been written about its cinematic shortcomings: the horrific color grading, the eyesore CGI landscapes, the less-than-stellar new songs that were crammed into an already bloated story and the notorious “sex cardigan” used to hold on to a PG rating. It’s horrifying what tentpole cinema looks like in a post-MCU world, but it’s even more horrifying to see what the corporate pipeline, shared between all artistic industries from Broadway to Hollywood, can do to a highly adult, highly political story. In Maguire’s original novel Glinda is barely present, and she certainly isn’t Elphaba’s torchbearer. But somewhere in the years between the novel and “Wicked: For Good” the story of a minority activist fighting the machine and wrestling with the consequences became “Galindafied”. The result is a story that doesn’t have much to say, and isn’t much to look at, but comes with countless branded tie-ins. Bringing “Wicked” to the big screen came with a kind of a sort of cost, and that cost was the political integrity of its source material. 

 


Elijah Fischer is a fourth-year English & MDC Major. Contact: Af997636@wcupa.edu.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *