Image Credits:© 2025 – Apple TV+ via IMDb
After the crazy, explosive ending of episode three, “Pluribus” fans sat on the edge of their seats waiting for Episode Four: “Please, Carol” to release. All three episodes so far have remained very consistently entertaining and intriguing, pushing the viewer to really investigate what is going on here. This new episode only furthers those ideas as Carol begins to investigate, and new characters come into play.
Episode Four: “Please, Carol”
Episode Four opens with us finally getting to see Manousos, whom Carol had a short but angry dialogue with on the phone in the last episode. We see him trying every different radio station he can, which we know to be useless, but as he goes down the list, we see how barricaded and isolated he has made himself. Even as the hivemind comes to deliver him food, something Manousos is very desperate for, we still see him turn it away.
Once he is able to find some small rations, we see the last episode’s phone conversation from his perspective. His annoyance is pretty understandable, especially when you consider how he thought Carol was a part of the hivemind. After it’s over though, we see him write her name down, making it clear this isn’t the last we’ll see of him.
While this intro didn’t move the plot extremely forward, it did reveal a lot about who Manousos is and how we might see him in the future.
After the title sequence, which has quickly become one of my favorites, even though it is quite simple, we see Carol driving back home in a cop car. Once she gets back home, she sees the hivemind fixing her house, which of course immediately enrages her. She begins to yell at them before realizing she said they could clean up the house while in the ambulance. Still slightly irritated, Carol goes inside and begins to come up with a list of things she knows about “them.”
This list ranges from “Eager to please,” “Can’t kill” but also includes “Weirdly honest?” With Carol still not sure about their ability to be honest, she realizes she must find out. She grabs one of the hivemind members outside, whose name was Larry, and begins to interrogate/ask him questions.
She proceeds to ask him if they like her books, to which the hivemind, as Larry, responds with an astounding yes. It gets to even the point where Larry says Carol’s “Wycaro” series is equally as good as Shakespeare’s work. While Carol is confused, Larry brings up how a woman named Moira, who is now a part of the hivemind, had severe mental health issues until she read Carol’s book, which proceeded to give her a reason to live. Larry explains how this is how they see Carol and her work, and while I still find it strange the way they praise Carol’s work, I think the hivemind uses whatever individual opinions someone had and just says that it’s all of theirs.
Carol then makes things very uncomfortable when she asks Larry what Helen thought of her books. While Larry is hesitant to answer, he eventually spills that Helen thought of the books as “harmless” and like “cotton candy.” While this is very insulting, it gets worse as Carol asks what Helen thought of her unpublished novel, mentioned briefly in the first episode. Larry again, reluctantly reveals Helen thought of it as “meh,” and that she never actually read the whole book. While Carol seems to be very confused and upset, Larry tells her that Helen knew the book wouldn’t “hurt her career,” and was more worried about Carol being happy. Carol then kicks Larry out, and we see her erase “Weirdly honest?” on the whiteboard to “Weirdly honest. Can’t lie.” While Carol doesn’t seem to be too hurt by Helen’s true thoughts, Carol has such a protective shell around her that it is very hard to tell.
Cut to Carol at the hospital where she meets with Zosia in her room. Carol apologizes for getting Zosia hurt, which I found to be quite surprising since Carol rarely ever shows any level of kindness towards her.
Carol asks Zosia if she can ask her a few questions, and while Zosia is more than happy to, neither her or the audience was ready for these questions. Carol questions Zosia on the fact that in the first episode, they told Carol they really didn’t understand much about the “joining,” and was wondering if she knew more. Zosia says that they do, leading Carol to ask if there is any way to reverse the “virus.” Zosia immediately gets quiet, and for the first time ever, she tells Carol that she “can’t answer questions like that.” Carol picks up that since they can’t lie, and that Zosia would have told her if the answer was no, that there must be a way to reverse the joining.
For one of the first times in the whole show, Carol is actually happy, finally understanding that this can all be reversed. While Zosia still makes it clear their plans are to bring her into the “hivemind” as well, Carol proceeds to ask her about Freedom Falls. While the audience has never heard of Freedom Falls, Carol makes Zosia tell her the story of how Carol’s mother sent her at 16 to a conversion therapy camp known as Camp Freedom Falls. While Zosia explains how they love everybody equally, Carol displays the irony in that Zosia is deliberately trying to convert her into the hivemind even though Carol doesn’t want to. Zosia then reverses the irony saying that Carol wants to convert her and everyone back to the people they used to be, even though the hivemind doesn’t want that. It honestly is a very layered and difficult argument, as both sides think they are completely in the right. While of course I stand with Carol trying to save humanity, I can completely understand Zosia’s argument from her “save the world” perspective.
As the camera focuses in on Zosia’s IV drip, we cut to Carol walking into the hospital’s pharmacy, where things start to get confusing. She opens a book called “Dosage Calculations Simplified,” and after going through it she finds a drug called Thiopental Sodium. After ripping the page out and finding the drug, the hivemind in the form of a doctor asks her if she needs help. Carol shockingly and hilariously asks if they have any heroin, to which the hivemind is very confused. While he tries to stop her, revealing that she actually took heroin in her sophomore year, he eventually tells her it’s on the way.
Back at home, Carol holds up the heroin and immediately flushes it away. Instead she begins to set up a camera facing her couch, as she prepares to take the Thiopental Sodium. After getting everything ready and finding the vein, she uses the needle to insert the drug directly into her blood stream. Once the deed has been done she turns on the camera and sits there quietly until it jump cuts to her sleeping on the couch in the middle of the night.
She wakes up, and right away she plugs the camera into the TV and watches her high. In what has to be the most vulnerable and embarrassing moments in the show, we see Carol in the most emotional and goofy state she has ever been in. Whether it be her reading her own book out loud, crying over Helen or loudly yelling “bulls**t,”it was all very interesting to watch, as we have never seen Carol act this way before. Carol eventually shuts it off once she refers to Zosia as “so f**kable,” which has me on the floor laughing the first time I watched this scene. While it is still unclear what her plan is, she throws away the SD card, and keeps the Thiopental Sodium, saying: “We got a winner.”
We then see Carol back at the hospital where she meets back up with Zosia. Carol offers to wheel her outside for a walk, and while Zosia happily agrees, this is where we finally learn Carol’s plan. While in the elevator, Carol sneakily inserts the Thiopental Sodium into her IV, as Zosia sits obliviously small talking about elevator music.
Once they get outside, Carol wheels her to a spot with very few people around, and asks Zosia about the temperature. As Zosia attempts to answer though, she begins to lose her train of thought. As soon as Zosia is very clearly loopy, Carol immediately asks her how to reverse the “joining.” As Zosia fails to get any words out though, more people part of the hivemind walk outside toward them. As they start to take Zosia away though, Carol handcuffs herself to Zosia, telling them all to stop.
As more and more hivemind people begin to circle Zosia and Carol, Carol continues to ask questions. In one of the creepiest moments since episode one, everyone around Carol begins to unemotionally say in unison “Please, Carol.” As the chants start to get louder, Carol yells at Zosia to tell her, but before she can say anything she falls to the ground.
Two of the people around them stop her from hitting the floor, and tell Carol that Zosia is in cardiac arrest. They ask if they can save Zosia, as they chop off the handcuffs between her and Carol. As one of them proceeds to give chest compressions, and someone else prepares an AED, the screen cuts to black.
Once again, “Pluribus” has left us on a cliffhanger, wondering whether Zosia will live or not because of Carol’s actions. While the first time with the grenade was at least a mistake, this one was directly Carol’s fault.
Episode Four: “Please, Carol” I found to be one of the most enjoyable episodes yet. While I definitely expected the plot to move in a different direction once she found out she can get whatever she wants, “Pluribus” continues to be the best show on television right now. This episode in particular continues the pattern of quality that seems to be on par with Vince Gilligan’s last shows. What I love most about this show though, is how it continuously makes the viewer think and ask questions.
From everything we’ve seen so far, I think there is something very strange about the hivemind’s behavior. I don’t understand why they are so nice to all of the survivors, meeting every want, need or demand they have. They treat those that are immune as gods nearly, always doing what they are told and never denying anything. It makes me think that there is something far more special about the survivors than we are being led on to believe. I know Zosia made it clear that they are trying to convert her eventually to the hivemind, but the level of patience and care that they show for Carol is definitely suspicious to me.
Episode Five: “Got Milk” will push us into the second half of this season, and I can’t wait for all the new questions this episode will raise.
Episode Four: Please, Carol – 8/10
Samuel J. Beadle is a second-year English major. SB1033446@wcupa.edu
