I asked AI to cast someone full of soul for my movie, and it offered Tilly Norwood. Entertainment deserves human passion, not artificial intelligence.
Recently, an actress and producer named Eline Van Der Velden generated an artificial intelligence performer, Tilly Norwood. Performers everywhere were appalled by the announcement, including the acting labor union SAG-AFTRA, Whoopi Goldberg and EmilyBlunt. The world constantly finds new ways AI can do our jobs. For example, a study showed that by 2026 respondents said, “over 20 percent of all entertainment, industry jobs… will be cut.” The creation of art connects people through experience, and builds communities. AI cannot do that. Instead, loads of AI songs, photos and now actors are being generated. The easy access and immediate production of art can leave aspiring artists discouraged. Thus, stopping them before they even start. As of 2023, over 63 million people held degrees in fine and performing arts. The fear of art lacking any skill or substance is real.
AI creation utilizing unethical methods is another growing fear. A recent report emphasizes that when implementing AI, humans and algorithms are equally responsible for protecting human rights. Human rights in the arts are currently being neglected because of the rise in deepfakes. Deepfakes are a threat to performers everywhere, fostering the exploitation of humans’ faces without permission or compensation. Artists are insulted because AI adds no genuine feeling or emotion to anything. Deepfakes in a wider context are bigger than just performing. Any person in an audio or video medium is at risk. This means social media users, minors and deceased artists. Humans must be more accountable when using this tech for creation. Everyone who uses AI needs to ensure that it values ethical boundaries and human agency.
Creating movies, social media content and scripts is fulfilling but tedious work. At times, using AI helps speed up the process. Editors can rely on AI to generate subtitles on a video. The time taken to edit photos or videos is also significantly reduced. Using apps like Adobe Photoshop and Premiere Pro have been helping editors for years now. Businesses even call for people skilled in these apps proving that humans can incorporate AI to make art properly. But every business should have experts who check the AI for accuracy. Generative artificial intelligence can only be skilled if the humans controlling it are as well.
Artists should learn the ethics of using artificial intelligence before using it to create. AI should not have the final say on one’s production. Rather, they should be aware of how much they want to take away from AI suggestions. A Nigerian artist, for instance, used AI to instead find what’s missing. Performing artists should learn their craft and perfect their artistry. Train their ways of performing like they would any other skill then find ways to connect their knowledge of arts history with the eminent growing tech. Students who are starting to hone their art skills can turn to theatre journals and magazines like American Theatre and discover how to recenter human creation. As of right now 50% of Americans are more concerned with AI usage than excited about it. By teaching students that they don’t need to rely on AI to be great they will gain confidence in their own expertise.
The performing arts are a space for community and connection. They serve as a place for others to hear each other and reflect. Humans don’t need AI to imitate sympathy, but another soul to cry alongside them.
Mali Taylor is a second year Media & Culture and Theatre Performance major. MT1027927@wcupa.edu
