Image Credits: @antjearnold_author on Instagram
We often do not know how different our lives would be if they took place at a different time or location. However, if they did, we could find them radically different from what we are used to. On Oct. 9th, I went to the German Club early to wait for the guest speaker event.
Shortly after, the speaker, Antje Arnold, arrived at 5:40 p.m. and I introduced myself to her. Arnold is an author and Chester County local who grew up in East Berlin during the Cold War. She mentioned how she liked the blue cornflower, which is the national flower of Germany. When I asked about which season was her favorite, she replied that she used to think summer was her favorite season, until she came to Pennsylvania and experienced our humidity.
As I asked her a few questions about her experiences in East Germany, more people came into the room to hear her speak. What I asked just before the event started was how she viewed the totalitarian regime she lived under. Was it normal to her, or did she know it was bad and wished her country was governed under a freer system? She replied that growing up, it was just normal to her, and she did not know any other system. Additionally, those who lived further away from the wall would have been more accepting of what life was like, but there were still people who recognized they did not like the system and hoped for a better society.
Another question was whether she had “Ostalgie,” a term referring to the nostalgia the older generation has for the East Germany of their youth. Arnold said that she does because certain aspects of that time were part of her childhood. An example is that if she were to go into a living room exhibit set in East Germany, at a museum, she feels like she is going back in time. Something that could feel historical to us in 2025 in America would just be a childhood memory to her. This brings up an interesting point, and when I asked her how old she was when the Berlin Wall fell, Arnold explained she was only 11. For some perspective, she is around the age of most of our parents, and we don’t consider their childhoods or the 1980s to be “history” in the same way we would view her life in East Germany.
One pervasive part of East German life was whether you were being heard by informants, people whose job it was to gather information on those around them. As Arnold told us, these people could be anyone, and you would not know who they were until after the regime fell. They could be your neighbor or even your own spouse, and you would not know who to trust with ideas that may be contrary to what the government wanted you to think. After the end of the German Democratic Republic or GDR (East Germany), informants had a hard time gaining employment due to them being seen as untrustworthy for their previous occupation, especially those who were employed full-time as informants and not as a side job. Some did odd jobs such as delivery to make a living in this new system. Although they did not go to prison, they still had to face the consequences of their actions. If Arnold could ask just one question to an informant she would ask: “Why? Why would you betray your own family and how could you get through your day knowing what you were doing?”
With informants around, being advised about what she could and couldn’t say and disappearances of those who stepped out of line, it makes sense that she wondered what was allowed growing up.
Just as kids do now, Arnold went to summer camp as a kid. She recalled watching E.T. (which she did not like) there, even though apparently, she was not supposed to see that movie. Additionally, in the bathroom she remembered there being 30 sinks and all the children brushing their teeth, one after another, like in an assembly line. One day, however, a child made a swastika out of toothpaste. Arnold never saw that child again, and no one was allowed to talk about that person.To this day, she still does not know what happened to the child.
On an edible note, the East German diet consisted of what could be grown in the country and what was in season. Potatoes and canned food were eaten, and it was often those who had connections that could buy certain foods under the table. When it came to tropical fruits, she only remembered eating oranges, but they were only available during Christmas and were still limited in availability. Additionally, she only tried pineapple at age 12, after the Berlin Wall fell, because before that the only fruits she would eat regularly were apples, cherries and others that could be grown in Germany.
After reading all these experiences of life in East Germany, would it be shocking to hear how some people wish that they still lived in the GDR? Some older people do. Why would anyone want to go back to such a time? Because the GDR offered something that many people lost when reunification happened in 1990 with the West and that was security. They had jobs, housing and other things provided to them by the communist government. It was a trade-off. To get freedom meant losing security and keeping security meant losing freedom. Depending on the position of the person now, that answer varies, but to Arnold, the freedom to travel, speak her mind and be free was worth it. She would not want to go back to living like she did in East Germany, but what do you think? Is freedom worth the cost of security or vice versa to you?
Marcus Schundler is a first-year History major. MS3015118@wcupa.edu

