Image Credits: Team Cherry via Wikipedia
It is impossible to talk about metrodivania games without talking about “Hollow Knight.” Ever since its release in 2017, the gaming industry has yet to stop praising this indie classic. Now, with “Hollow Knight: Silksong” (2025) finally just released, the hype for both games have never been higher. Having never played “Hollow Knight” though, I sought to see if it is really as good as people say, or if people are just losing their minds over nothing.
“Hollow Knight” immediately throws you into the world of Hallownest, with little to no introduction to a story or reasoning for why your character is even there. You are left lost, with no choice but to explore and slowly uncover your purpose in this land. There are small cutscenes and characters along the way that will help you realize your quest, but none of it is upfront. Normally, I would criticize a game for having such a simple story, but for one of the first times in my gaming experience, it really had no effect. Where the story lies is not in character or plot, but in worldbuilding.
Exploration is the building blocks of this game, as “Hollow Knight” gives you a heavily detailed, beautifully animated and densely atmospheric world to explore here. Every room you enter is riddled with little details, whether that be in the background or foreground, and it makes each area feel so real. There are no areas that feel barren or wasted, everything here has a purpose.
While the character and enemy designs are quite simple, the world itself is so meticulously crafted to transport you in the land of Hallownest. The art design and sound design work perfectly in unison to create an atmosphere so thick, that just thinking about a specific area can bring back memories and moods. There are 15 main areas to explore, and each one is just as exciting as the last, with a completely new look, new enemies, new bosses, new music and a whole new atmosphere to get completely enveloped in.
The player movement too is very fluid, as it rarely feels like you are not in complete control of your character. While at first it can feel very slow to traverse this huge map, there are many upgrades and powers to be found along the way that make that process feel way smoother. Especially as you explore more and the map continues to unfold, being able to see it all becomes an absolute pleasure, even when it’s not necessary.
You can play through the whole game and leave huge chunks of an area still unexplored. There is so much to do, so much to see, and it’s surprising how much of it all feels rewarding and exciting. On top of that, the more you play, the more you begin to learn more about Hallownest, and how it became the desolate-violent place it is now.
Like I said earlier, the story here is not direct at all. It isn’t about watching a series of events play out, but more about player discovery. How you choose to explore and uncover the important story beats of this game is really up to you, “Hollow Knight” just guides you in the right direction. That being said, “Hollow Knight” allows you at every turn to go on your own, very rarely discouraging you from going off the beaten path. Its bigger concern is: are you ready for the unbeaten path?
When the game begins, you start off with five hearts and a nail, uneasy and uncertain of what lies ahead. The combat starts very simple, as there doesn’t seem to be much to it besides swinging your nail. But similar to movement, the more you play the more materials you get at your disposal. The game slowly gives you new abilities, giving the player time to master each one before you get to the next. By the end, you’ll be pulling off moves and attacks you never thought you could, and it makes the overall experience of “Hollow Knight” feel so much more engaging.
There are also charms that you get throughout playing that serve as upgrades to your combat, health or movement. The catch is that you can only have a few enabled at once, forcing you to think very strategically about which ones you need. While there are certainly some charms that don’t feel useful at all, the majority of them allow for many unique ways to play the game. Especially as you get to some of the more difficult enemies and bosses, finding the right charms will become incredibly important.
With over 150 enemies and 47 unique bosses, “Hollow Knight” is filled to the brim with variety. While many enemies don’t have much of a strategy besides just hitting them till they die, they each have a different method of attacking the player This requires you to find strategic ways to take each one down. Each enemy has their own appearance, making the game visually much more interesting. It makes walking into a room or exploring a new area 100 times more exciting, as you have no idea what on the other side will come out to kill you.
The bosses then take everything great about the enemies and up it tenfold. There is not a single boss that I noticed in my playthrough that wasn’t an absolute blast to take down. It’s certainly not going to be easy, and it will take numerous tries but successfully beating any of the bosses is so rewarding. Learning attack patterns and slowly mastering each boss is not only so much fun, but stayed consistently fun throughout my 25+ hour playthrough.
While you can technically beat the game when you reach its end, there is still so much “Hollow Knight” has to offer. Not only are there four alternate endings, but there are numerous DLCs that add much more content to this already large game. Alongside the new content, it is one hundred percent worth your time to explore every nook and cranny of this map that you haven’t yet explored. Whether it be optional to the main story or not, the quality never dips, creating one of the most consistently entertaining games ever made.
Accompanying this game is over an hour’s worth of original music composed by Christopher Larkin. Each song beautifully flows with the player throughout their entire experience. Every boss fight is made so much more intense by a soundtrack that not only makes your heart race, but makes every fight feel like life or death. Then when you’re not fighting an enemy, the soundtrack takes a step back and allows you to appreciate the visuals with a soothing and calming instrumental. Without Larkin’s beautiful work this world would feel incomplete, but now it’s impossible to think about “Hollow Knight” without also imagining its beautiful score.
“Hollow Knight” is not just a great metroidvania game, but one of the best metroidvanias ever made. While the story may not be life changing, in a game like this that doesn’t matter, as lore and atmosphere take the precedent. There is so much to do in the game, yet it never feels overwhelming, as it perfectly paces you from one battle to the next. No matter which direction I took I felt as if I was going the right way, and I only wish I could do it all over again for the first time. When everything is so fine-tuned and polished to absolute perfection like this, it’s impossible to not call “Hollow Knight” a masterpiece.
Game Rating: 10/10
Samuel J. Beadle is a second-year English major. SB1033446@wcupa.edu
