Image Credits: Netflix via Wikipedia
Warning: Contains spoilers
What happens when you put “white boy of last month,” Corey Mylchreest (the actor who made you watch thirst traps of King George), and Netflix rom-com prisoner/B-Tier Disney Channel star Sofia Carson in the same movie? According to Oxford student Isobel Wanstall, it results in a total letdown of a film. I am truly bamboozled as to how the script was written, edited, re-edited and continuously approved. I am flabbergasted at the length of time Sofia Carson has probably gone without an acting coach. And after the ending, I’m unsure how the author of the book was able to see this movie without suing for damages.
“My Oxford Year” (2025) was released on Netflix on Aug. 1 and is adapted from a novel of the same name (though a lot is changed, including the name and backstory of the protagonist). Cornell graduate Anna de la Vega (Sofia Carson) defers her position at Goldman Sachs as a data analyst to study Victorian literature at Oxford university for a semester. There, she meets local heartbreaker and trust fund baby Jamie Wilson (Corey Mylchreest), who is revealed to be her professor!
Granted, he isn’t technically her professor – he is a PhD student finishing up a thesis that is never elaborated upon in this film. He just happens to be teaching the class. Except the students address him as such in the movie, so what do I know? This doesn’t stop the two from flirting in front of the other students who are strangely okay with the weird power dynamic. A sane person would call this dynamic predatory, especially since Jamie is known for being with a lot of girls. A sane person would think it’s odd that Jamie parties with the students and frequents their pubs, but “My Oxford Year” is covered in a haze where all the odds are stacked in Anna’s favor, where the poems they discuss are ones that a kindergartener could figure out. The entire environment is unrealistic.
Case in point — near the end of the movie, Anna graduates from Oxford. But why would she graduate after being there for one year? Did the professor pay the university off or something? Is it main character syndrome? I don’t understand!
Anna is an empty character. There is nothing to her but loving books. No flaws, no obstacles, everything put in front of her is resolved so quickly that you forget they even happened in the first place. No matter how much she ditches her friends for a weird professor, they still have her back. Which sucks, because the friends are one of the redeeming qualities in this movie. I like the characters and wish they’d just kick Anna to the curb! Sofia Carson’s acting doesn’t help, pursing her lips and saying her lines like she’s trying to seduce somebody. I could see her in a shampoo ad way more than I could see her in this movie.
Anna’s one flaw is that she’s realistic and has everything in her life planned out. Jamie tells her over a lamb kebab (which she has never eaten, despite being from Queens, New York) to “embrace the messiness of life.” She has a good point to counter this, as Jamie has the financial security to easily follow his dreams while she doesn’t. However, the writing doesn’t support this trait, as studying at Oxford seems a bit out there to me, especially when she already has her master’s degree. It costs a lot of money to live abroad, not to mention pay her tuition, and this is not discussed at all in the movie. It’s odd that it wouldn’t, considering Anna’s point from earlier. Maybe they never edited the first draft of the script to add a throwaway line. Or maybe writing is probably just that bad. I wonder how many life changing movie pitches were rejected for this one.
I mentioned redeeming qualities earlier, and admittedly there are some. Anna’s friends: Esme (Maggie Timbs), Charlie (Harry Trevaldwyn) and, my personal favorite, Tom (Nikhil Parmar). Tom stole the show in every scene he was in and I would love to see an entire movie about him. His comedic and flirtatious nature make me much more interested in his (small) character arc with Esme more than the main plot. All the friends bounce off each other very well with their witty dialogue and give the movie moments of levity that are well deserved. Jamie’s father also has a compelling plotline that tugs at your heart. I can’t say the same with Jamie.
Aside from the obvious issue with his and Anna’s relationship (in no world should a teacher be shagging their student, regardless of age), Jamie is a really weird boyfriend. He hides things from Anna, ignores her for weeks, never tells her he loves her until the end of the movie and they never even date officially. Not once does he ask her to be his girlfriend. He keeps trying to break things off from her for no reason and he never tells her he loves her! Thank God he’s rich, because that’s all he has. Otherwise, I’d have no idea why Anna put up with this trust fund loser with no friends his age. Corey Mylcreest is an amazing actor, though, and does well with the scenes he is given, and his attempt at karaoke is my favorite scene in the movie. It’s unfortunate that he is pretty much playing the same character that he did in “Bridgerton”: an emotionally unavailable sick man.
MAJOR spoilers ahead. Be warned! Though it may be an act of mercy, because if I spoil you, you won’t have to watch this movie.
Surprise! He has cancer!
He decides he doesn’t want to undergo more treatment and live his life to the fullest while he has time. I wonder if the writers know anything about cancer, because he is still unbelievably attractive throughout the entire movie without a hint that he is dying. His only symptom is that he faints once. He is still able to party with students, teach a class and run around Oxford with no consequences. Why he is able to live normally is not discussed — does stopping treatment include palliative care? What type of cancer even is it? Who cares? Let’s cut to another scene of him and Anna kissing! I thought we learned from the mistakes of sick-lit after “The Fault in Our Stars” over a decade ago! Only John Green is able to do this plotline right.
The best (worst) aspect to the plot is while he dies in the movie, he lives in the book! He travels with Anna and resumes treatment, allowing him to go into remission. There’s no reason to kill him off other than shock value! The movie has a lot of changes from the book and they’re all shoehorned in for angst. They make Anna Argentinian-Cuban not for any compelling reason, but to have racist taunts thrown at her in a club. Movies need more Latinx representation, but it should never be like this.
Overall, “My Oxford Year” isn’t even fun to watch. It’s presumptuous and obnoxious in its messages and insults the viewer with its horrible writing that encourages unhealthy relationships. Do not watch this movie. I will, however, be open to a movie with Tom on the condition that Sofia Carson be banished to Hallmark Hell for the rest of time.
Emily Rutz is a second year English major and French minor. ER1034711@wcupa.edu
