Image: Photo from the Student Coalition for the Liberation of Palestine’s 2023 “Stand with Palestine” demonstration. Photos by @wcuyearbook
On Saturday, March 8, ICE agents detained student activist Mahmoud Kahlil just outside his Columbia University-owned apartment in New York City. This came as a result of President Trump signing an executive order that would deport all U.S. visa holders who “intend to commit terrorist attacks, threaten our national security, espouse hateful ideology, or otherwise exploit the immigration laws for malevolent purposes.”
This is obviously targeted at the pro-Palestinian protests that have taken place on college campuses in the past year. After Kahlil’s arrest, Trump showed his approval for the move by stating that those who participated in these protests were “pro-terrorist, anti-Semitic, [and] anti-American.” Kahlil was then transported to a detention center in Jena, La. where he would await a sentence from an immigration judge.
While some may agree or disagree with Trump’s decision to deport students for protesting and demonstrating the first amendment right of free speech, a key detail is being left out in this whole process. Kahlil is not here on a visa; he has a green card.
While he is not a full citizen, a green card gives him the right to live and work permanently in the United States. While certain conditions can be met where a green card holder can be deported, no mention of it appears in the aforementioned executive order. Because this is the case, there should be no punishment given to Kahlil since he has rights that are protected by the Constitution.
While this may seem like a one-off story and may not relate to the average person who doesn’t participate in protests, the precedent that this sets, along with the rhetoric that the Trump administration and its political supporters have been spreading, could potentially lead to an infringement on free speech. Trump has repeatedly called all form of pro-Palestinian protest “anti-Semitic” and “Hamas sympathizers.” This is obviously a huge mischaracterization of what the protests are about, which is the ability for Palestinians to have their own land without having to worry about being bombed or shot by IDF soldiers.
By painting this with such broad, inaccurate and negative strokes, the Trump administration can change the perspective among the common American and deem it worthy of arrest. This can be applied to any number of subjects, such as speaking negatively about the president himself. It is common knowledge that Trump hates when the media covers him in a negative light, even when it is justified. By continuing to demonize and mischaracterize speech that does not align with his ideologies, he could implement laws that would punish those who speak negatively against him.
Trump has already threatened that he would cut funding to schools that allowed “illegal protests” on campus. Some universities have chosen not to comply with this and continued to allow their students to exercise their first amendment right. West Chester University has taken any measures to comply with this directive since Trump took office again in January, WCU did implement a policy prior to the election that restricts not only student speech, but faculty and staff speech as well: . “On October 16th 2024, Dr. Jeffery Osgood and Mr. Andy Lehman approved the Exterior Posting and Advertising Policy.” The policy goes into detail and essentially states that students may no longer have signs, posters, flags or any type of board that carries a message, even one that isn’t political, placed on campus property in public view. This even includes putting signs in the windows of dorms, which students were known to do. Many have speculated that this is because prospective students visited campus and were turned off by the political messaging of these signs. If this is indeed true, the message that WCU is sending is one that prioritizes financial benefits and student enrollment over student expression. While the university is free to do what they want and enforce any policy they want to, like the Trump case, it sets a bad precedent that could lead to further restrictions soon.
Geoff Soland is a fourth-year History major with minors in Journalism and Museum Studies. GS1003383@wcupa.edu.
