Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

“Severance” Season 2, Episode 4 had me waiting desperately all week after the jaw-dropping ending of Episode 3. We’re not even halfway through this season, and it feels like so much has happened. The more I continue to watch this show, the more I realize it’s becoming my favorite show of all time, with very few to rival it. I love spending every day in between episodes talking about what I think is going to happen next and figuring out the many mysteries of “Severance.” This episode in particular, I was theorizing about so much, and once I started the episode, I was glued to the screen.

Before I get to the main part of this review, I want to note that since this is an episode review, I will be diving into major spoiler territory. So let this be a fair warning for whoever is going to watch “Severance” in the future. Once the show is completed, I will dedicate a small portion of my full season review to avoiding spoilers, but those wanting that will just have to wait.

From Mark’s reintegration to Cobel running away from Lumon, I was left with so many questions from Episode 3. This is all on top of the many other questions this show continues to throw at us and the ongoing mystery of where Ms. Casey is. Going into this episode, though, the main thing I wanted to see was how they would deal with Mark’s reintegration, as I originally thought they did it too early. After watching this new episode, though, I don’t even know what to say.

I’m going to cut to the chase and say this episode made me feel like the biggest idiot ever. Watching the reveal of Helly actually being Helena this whole season was the most shocked I’ve been in a long time. I was so blindsided, similarly to Mark, of the idea of Helly and Mark being in love that I ignored all the suspicions. I made note while watching the first three episodes that Helly was acting a little stranger than normal, but I figured it was because of her finally feeling more connected to the macrodata team. Looking back, I realize how stupid I sound, and I can’t believe I didn’t suspect a thing.

I did some research after the episode, and there were numerous people who suspected Helena of pretending to be Helly, and the way they figured it out was crazy. There were so many small hints scattered throughout the first few episodes that you had to really pay attention to find. The team behind “Severance” is creating some of the most intelligent and thought-provoking television to ever come out, and I know now to pay more attention to these small details going forward.

Now, going back to the beginning: from the moment this episode started I was so lost as 1,000 questions raced through my mind. Why are the innies outside? Where are they? How did the outies accept this? While Mr. Milchick does give us answers in his pre-recorded message atop the cliff, I take every word he says with a grain of salt.

Milchick explains how, since the innies have complained about not seeing the outside world, they created a program called the Outdoor Retreat Team Building Occurrence, or ORTBO. He tells the macrodata team that they are in Dieter Eagan National Forest, which is named after Lumon’s founder Kier Eagan’s twin brother, who has never been mentioned before. This is already making things suspicious as it is, but the message isn’t over. Milchick then tells them they must work as a team to find Kier’s fourth appendix at Scissor Cave, with hints along the way.

By the end of this message, the whole situation felt a little more clear, but the question of “how were the outies okay with this?” still haunted me. At this point in the show, we know Mark’s outie is skeptical of Lumon and would most likely not allow this to happen. This led me to a theory that I have good reason to believe: I think that Dieter Eagan National Forest isn’t a real place and is actually a simulation of sorts. 

First off, there is no way Lumon would just send their severed workers out into the winter wilderness with absolutely zero warning or training. It is just way too dangerous, and it would be hard to explain to an outie’s family how they got injured or died in the woods. Secondly, this explains how Irving didn’t freeze to death or at least get frostbite when he fell asleep in the woods later in the episode. While we don’t know exactly how cold it was outside, we know it was cold enough to freeze a lake, but somehow he didn’t have any level of frost on him when he woke up. Lastly, and this is a small detail I noticed, but the TV that appears on the cliff of the beginning of the episode isn’t there in a previous shot. Now, this could have just been an editing mistake, but I sincerely doubt it. 

While I do think there is a lot that backs up this theory, this show has made me look stupid before, so I wouldn’t be surprised if it happened again.

Now after the macrodata team begins their journey, they are helped by what looks to be clones of themselves. While I was originally speculating that this was proving a popular fan theory that Lumon is working on cloning people, I now don’t think that’s right. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, the “Severance” cast discussed this clone theory and completely dismissed it. Now, while it doesn’t change the fact these clones, or what Milchick calls “twins,” are still really weird, I don’t have much of a clue on what that could lead to.

The team eventually reaches Scissor Cave and begins to read Keir’s fourth appendix while continuing their journey to Woe’s Hollow. At first glance, Kier’s text may seem like a very poetic tale of his twin brother becoming one with nature, but the more you look into what is actually being said though, it is very, uhh… masturbatory. This wasn’t something I even caught onto until Helly makes a joke about it by the campfire later in the episode.

This I found to be one of the funniest moments of the show so far, as it even had me pause the episode and re-listen to what is actually being said. If you haven’t done this already, I heavily suggest you do; it is definitely worth it.

As Mark and Helly continue to laugh at her joke about Kier watching Dieter masturbate in the woods, Milchick does not. He proceeds to have Ms. Huang throw their newly gifted marshmallows into the fire, and then leaves them to sit with their punishment. 

While Mark and Helly find Milchick’s punishment to be ridiculous, he isn’t the only one who had a problem with Mark’s joke. Irving looks over at them and precedes to tell them that it wasn’t funny, but this isn’t the only time Irving has acted in such a serious manner this episode.

This whole episode, Irving has been very suspicious of Helly, even talking with Mark about the “night gardener” Helly said she saw during season one’s finale. While we obviously know that is a lie, Irving is unable to convince Mark that there is something off. Then, once the macrodata teams reach the tents, Irving confronts Helly about what she really saw that night. Helly tries to tell him she wasn’t lying, but by the end you can still see Irving is suspicious. 

This culminates at the end of this fireplace scene, after Irving tells Mark and Helly the joke wasn’t funny. While Mark defends Helly, Irving is quick to make note that Mark’s judgment is clearly skewed due to his feelings toward Helly. Irving then confronts her again about the “night gardener,” until Mark tries to stop him. Irving is finally fed up, saying Mark is “using his pupils to make love to [Helly], while [Mark’s] outie’s wife rots away somewhere.” While I do think Irving went a little too far with this line, Helly strikes back, telling everyone that “It’s okay. We all know Irving’s upset because he can never see Burt again. And he’s really lonely.” This line struck me as really weird, not because I wouldn’t put it past Helly to make a rude comment, but it’s the tone she said it in. Obviously, looking back I know why, but the way Britt Lower said this line just perfectly traced the way for us to figure out she was actually Helena. 

After that line, Irving storms off into the cold wilderness, while Mark and Helly warm up together in a sex scene I think everyone eventually saw coming. I knew from the beginning of this season that Mark and Helly’s relationship was going to be a central point of the show, but after the ending of this episode, it is especially weird. 

In the moment I loved seeing Mark and Helly finally confess their love to each other, but now knowing that Mark actually had sex with Helena, I don’t know what to think. I believe this proves my theory from my review of Episodes 1-3 that Helena is falling in love with Mark’s innie, but I will talk about that later.

This scene I found to be incredibly well done as it cut from Irving freezing alone in the cold to Mark and Helly making love together by the heater. It is here we also see Mark’s reintegration play a small but incredibly important role, as Helly’s face turns into Gemma’s for only a few seconds. As I’ve made it very clear, I originally was not on board with Mark reintegrating so early, but I love the way they’ve done it so far. I was worried that, just like Petey, it would mix the innie and outie together at once, ultimately erasing both of them. Seeing it only affect Mark’s innie in such a small way now assures us there will be more later, but as of now it’s not playing a huge role.

As we cut back to Irving lost in the woods, he realizes he has no choice but to sleep out there. I was certain Irving might freeze to death in the cold as he stared up into the stars, but all that happened was a nightmare. From season one, I’ve learned that Irving’s dreams are not to be taken lightly, and this is no exception. From this dream, Irving’s suspicions are confirmed, as he realizes not only that Helly has been her outie this whole time, but also that she is an Eagan. While I did love this nightmare that Irving has and thought it was creepy, I did think there was one glaring problem: the green screen.  That may just be me nitpicking, but I found it to be not well edited and in turn really distracting. This is really my only complaint with the episode though, so it wasn’t a big deal for me.

This leads into one of the greatest scenes in the show’s history, where Irving reveals that Helly has been Helena this whole season. While I originally didn’t believe him and thought he was going crazy, the more I thought about it, the more it made sense. As he began to drown Helena in the pond in front of Mark, Dylan and Milchick, I kept thinking “there’s no way”. But as soon as Helena yelled “goddamm it, Seth, do it,” and Milchick said into his walkie talkie, “remove the Glasgow block now,” it hit me like a ton of bricks. What kept racing through my head, though, was: why? Why would Helena pretend to be Helly?

The main theory I have — and I’ve seen this online as well — is that Lumon wants to assure that Helly never causes any more damage to the company like she did at the end of season one. Lumon also knew that the whole macrodata team would be plotting against Lumon as soon as they returned, so having a mole within the group would definitely help stop them. Now, while I think that’s why Lumon wanted Helena as a mole, I think she personally wanted something different. I think seeing her innie kiss Mark’s innie made her fall in love with Mark, too, and she used this moleing as an excuse to get closer to Mark. Another theory is that Helena was doing what she thought Helly would do in that situation, but I’m not sure. Either way, this flips “Severance” on its head, adding another reason to not trust anything we see.

After she returns for the first time this season, Irving stops and apologizes to a lost and confused Helly. Milchick and Mark go down to where Helly and Irving are, and we see one of the most tragic scenes yet. As Mark holds Helly in his hands, Milchick orders Irving to stand up and begins his execution. As Dylan yells from across the pond, apologizing to Irving for not listening to him, Irving is able to let out a few final words: “Just remember. Hang in there.” Milchick then orders him to walk into the forest as he begins his firing speech. No matter how many times Dylan yells at Milchick to “leave him alone!,” it doesn’t matter. We see Irving accept his innie’s death, knowing full well that he did the right thing. 

Just thinking about this scene gives me the chills, as I still can’t even believe it happened. Seeing the once-loyal servant of Kier making his last moment rebuff against everything Kier stands for is just a beautiful end to his character. Irving’s legacy will never be forgotten, by the macrodata team or the fans.

It goes without saying that this will have devastating consequences for the team. Mark will certainly feel guilty for not listening and letting his love for who he believed to be Helly get in the way of his judgment. Dylan, on the other hand, I think, will be more determined than ever and make it his mission to find the export hallway and complete what Irving started. When it comes to Helly, I’m not sure if we’ll see her again for a while. It is clear that Lumon does not trust her on the severed floor, and now even the macrodata team will have a hard time trusting her. Only time will tell, but I’d be surprised if we don’t see Helly’s return to the severed floor later this season.

I think next episode we’ll get an understanding of what actually happened this episode and how Lumon was able to pull it off, similarly to how Episode 2 was earlier this season. I’m not sure if the episode will be completely an outie perspective episode or not, but it wouldn’t surprise me at all.

Overall, the ending of this episode was by far my favorite for this season, and it makes me so much more excited to see where the show goes. I have never been more engaged in not only the story but the characters as well, as they go on such an emotional and mysterious journey.

I also want to mention how incredible Lower and John Turturo specifically have been this season. While I mentioned in my last episode review how well Turturo has played Irving this season, it really culminated perfectly in this episode in an emotional spectacle. Lower, on the other hand, has been acting a lot more subtly, but is just as brilliant. The way she was able to play Helena pretending to be Helly and not make it too obvious or too difficult is incredible and has become a new highlight of the season for me.

Every episode of this show continues to push the boundary on what I think a show can accomplish, and I can’t wait to spend this whole week theorizing what will happen next. “Woe’s Hollow,” to me, felt like such a perfect episode, and it would be absolutely criminal to say this isn’t one of the best episodes of “Severance” yet.

Episode 4: “Woe’s Hollow” – 10/10

 


Samuel J. Beadle is a first-year English major. SB1033446@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *