Wed. Nov 18th, 2026
xr:d:DAE1FFFgjGE:357,j:2916475435738939710,t:23062620

Image: Welcome Golden Rams via First-Year Accepted Students WCUPA

How should universities respond if high schools fail to prepare their students for college-level academics? What measures should be taken to ensure that an institution’s academic standards are not compromised by the unpreparedness of incoming students who attended high school during the COVID-19 era? These are some questions that West Chester University (WCU) and other institutions of higher learning must face. 

The Quad recently published an article titled “Incoming College Students Are Not Ready for a University Level Education” by WCU student Emma Reel, who described how her high school education left her unprepared for college. Indeed, there is no doubt that high school education in the United States leaves much to be desired. For decades, people have complained about the declining quality of education in this country. The underlying problems were exacerbated in recent years, largely due to the impact of COVID-19. During the pandemic — particularly in the distance-learning phase — many teachers became more lenient with their standards, assigning grades based on completion rather than accuracy, and giving students far more time to complete assignments. Additionally, the expanded use of technology facilitated by the pandemic has made it easier for students to find answers on the internet rather than memorizing facts or using critical thinking skills. On top of all this, attending school in the COVID-19 era was simply not motivating for many young people. 

Given the situation, is it any surprise that freshmen in the past few years feel less prepared than previous incoming students? While I have heard some professors bemoan this issue, I’ve heard very little about it from the university itself. Last spring, in her first interview with The Quad, President Bernotsky stated that we should be less focused on whether students are prepared for university, and more concerned about whether the university is prepared to meet students where they are. The question is, does this imply a lowering of academic standards or an increased focus on helping students quickly adapt to normal college-level work? 

From my experience, there is no standard approach to this question. Certain pedagogical methods seem to imply the first option. When professors give students unlimited deadlines, easy grading, many opportunities to redo assignments and unfettered access to the internet, including online exams, it encourages the habits that students adopted in high school — strategies that will not serve them well in the long-term. On the other hand, some professors give students large amounts of work without explaining how to handle college-level assignments and then become frustrated by students’ inability to complete such high-level work. Unfortunately, neither of these approaches help students adjust well to college academics. 

Lowering academic expectations to meet the level of incoming students — who are unprepared for college through no fault of their own — does them a disservice, as it will leave them lacking in the knowledge and skills needed for success in the workforce. It does no good to meet students where they are and then allow them to stay there if their knowledge and skill sets are insufficient. At the same time, we must acknowledge that current incoming students attended high school in far different circumstances than previous generations. Therefore, it’s crucial to help students adapt to the more rigorous standards of their new academic environment. 

It is imperative that incoming students understand exactly what is expected of them in a university setting and what skills and knowledge they will need — as well as what resources are in place to help them attain a higher level of academic achievement. First-Year Experience classes should be geared towards accelerating students’ transition from high school to college, clearly explaining exactly what they will need to succeed at this level, and teaching students how to utilize the university’s resources in order to attain that standard. Professors should also make clear what their expectations are and what resources are available to help students succeed academically. Rather than lowering their expectations and making classes easier or expressing frustration at students’ unpreparedness, they should facilitate students’ academic growth and help them to achieve more challenging things than what was demanded of them in high school. Being able to confidently produce higher levels of work — and knowing which university resources are in place to help them do so —  gives students a sense of accomplishment. 

By showing students how to achieve at a higher level — neither by coddling them nor by ignoring the challenges of their high school background — the university will help set students on the right path to succeed academically and professionally. While high schools may be leaving students unprepared for the real world, institutions of higher learning like WCU should focus on raising students up to the full potential of their academic abilities. 

 


Emily Karreman is a fourth-year student with majors in History and Russian and minors in Spanish and Global Studies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *