Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image: Hanukkah Endcap via Anna Weinstein (TikTok @anna_0878)

“Merry Christmas!” is a phrase often said to me all throughout the month of December in stores, at school and restaurants despite my silver Star of David hanging around my neck. I usually either give a polite smile or if I am feeling extra sassy that day I wish them a happy Hanukkah, which always throws them off guard and they are quick to tell me they are NOT Jewish — as if that wasn’t already clear by their appalled expression.

The holiday season is one of my favorite times of the year. I love the cold weather, twinkling lights, hot chocolate and so much more. Unfortunately, each year I am reminded of the contrast between how Christmas is celebrated compared to Hanukkah. I can’t help but to feel envious of the people with fully decorated homes for Christmas, along with the people shopping in the enormous Christmas section in stores, while I am stuck with a few shelves — maybe a whole endcap if I am lucky. Christmas is the end-all-be-all, while Hanukkah is nothing but a mere afterthought. 

I am not looking to take away from the love of Christmas and throw it towards Hanukkah, but I am looking for the same respect for my holiday as the other one gets. If you stroll past the Hanukkah endcap, you will notice things labeled for Hanukkah that are clearly not for the holiday. Blue ornaments? Advent calendars? Stockings? None of these are part of the Hanukkah tradition — at least not in my family. It’s almost laughable, because I can’t imagine seeing a red-and-green menorah or dreidel in the Christmas section.

While I’ve cracked a few jokes, this issue runs deeper. Many Jewish people I know, myself included, feel frustration at how our culture is represented (or overlooked) during the holidays. Representation matters, even in seemingly small ways like holiday decor. It shouldn’t be so difficult to find something meaningful to Jewish traditions in major stores during this time of year. So, recently I have created a series on TikTok documenting myself going into stores such as Target, Homegoods and Michaels looking for Hanukkah decorations. I do not have a huge following nor do my videos get a lot of attention, but even if I can show what it’s like to be Jewish around the holidays to just a few people, I will feel I have accomplished something. A lot of my non-Jewish friends have come up to me or left comments on my videos saying they had no idea how small the Hanukkah section is and how they have never noticed prior to seeing my video. It’s always shocking to me how they don’t notice when it is all I notice.

Writing this piece may seem petty and mundane, but for me, it is quite therapeutic. I say these things to my family every year and they tell me that’s what it is like to be Jewish, how it always was and probably always will be, but I don’t accept that. I refuse to believe there is no chance for change because that is a sad place to live in. Why should Jewish kids grow up feeling like their holiday is second-tier? Why should we continue to accept misrepresentation — or worse, invisibility — during a season that’s supposed to celebrate joy and togetherness? So, in this, I challenge people to take notice of the things I have written about, and maybe when you notice someone wearing a Jewish star, wish them a happy Hanukkah instead of a merry Christmas. 

*  I am only speaking for how I celebrate, and this may not apply to every Jewish person and their traditions.

 


Anna Weinstein is a second-year English major.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *