Image: Via Solen Feyissa (Unsplash)
Artificial intelligence has become the new norm in our society. The field of AI began in the 1950s and quickly surged to popularity, with rises and declines over the years. However, AI is certainly not going to take over the world anytime soon – if at all. However, some people are allowing AI to take over themselves as individuals, particularly students. In fact, according to LearningScientists.org, Maria Radeva explains, “some researchers claim that using ChatGPT can impede the development of essential skills, such as critical thinking, problem-solving, imagination, and research abilities. Therefore, using ChatGPT for education purposes might negatively affect students’ academic and professional success.” She goes on to state that it may not be realistic to ban ChatGPT but instead show students how to use it without simply relying on it for every little thing. It is supposed to be a tool, not a replacement for one’s own work. This would certainly be a step in the right direction, but in my opinion, it is unlikely to reach the students who already use ChatGPT for everything.
It has gotten to the point where honest students are accused of using AI simply because they are good writers. How has this become the norm? It is frustrating for hardworking students to be accused of using AI when they did not. They then have to figure out a way to prove that their voice is their own, which is difficult to do. Yet, it is a necessary measure for teachers to take because AI has taken over the classroom.
Personally, I don’t use ChatGPT or any other form of AI. Would succumbing to these shortcuts make my life easier in the short term? Sure. I could finish assignments easily and complete an essay in an instant. However, in the long term, it might as well ruin my life entirely.This is because I want to be a professional writer. For context, I’m planning on double majoring in English and music. My ultimate goal in life is to work as an author. Because of this, I am offended by the mere existence of AI writing. It could take over the job I want. It could replace many of the jobs that people already have. Worst of all, it could replace the craft of writing in general. When people are given the opportunity to write in school and instead take the convenient way out, it upsets me.
Furthermore, I’m paying thousands of dollars to attend college and receive an education. Therefore, I try to take full advantage of everything I learn. I put time and effort into every assignment, big or small. There is no assignment small enough to warrant cheating in my eyes. The reason is simply because I am paying for every single learning opportunity I have. Even a simple practice assignment can teach me some sort of skill or help me gain knowledge that could be beneficial. Every essay I write improves my writing, simply because practice means progress. There is no way to progress my education by using AI to cheat on an assignment. Yet, there are countless people who believe the only way to get through certain college courses is to cheat. However, these people might not gain the knowledge they need to succeed in their career in the future.
Every time you use AI or ChatGPT, even if it’s for something simple, you are taking away a part of your voice. You are giving in to AI, allowing it to control you, allowing it to be better than you when it is not. As Dr. Diane Bublack explains on the Defense Acquisition University’s blog, “Test-It: AI -vs- Human Generated Material,” “Human writing often reflects emotional intelligence and an ability to connect with the reader on a personal level. AI-generated text, while it can mimic some forms of emotional expression, usually lacks genuine emotional depth or a truly empathetic tone. The text might seem technically competent but emotionally flat.” AI writing cannot compare to the complexities of human writing. By refusing to put in the time and effort to complete that assignment or write that essay, your human voice will not be heard. AI will be heard instead. By allowing AI to control your life, you are losing control. You are losing a part of yourself.
Madie Truglio is a first-year Music Elective Studies major.
