Wed. Nov 18th, 2026
default

Image: News_TMI_1: “Three Mile Island” by zoso8203 is licensed under CC BY 2.0.

In 1979, the Three Mile Island, a Harrisburg nuclear power plant best known for being the site of the most severe nuclear meltdown in American history, is now reopening for the first time after closing its doors in 2017. The plant has been purchased by Microsoft as part of a plan to reduce its carbon footprint, utilizing nuclear power’s carbon-free electricity generation to power its data grids. According to Constellation, this years-in-the-making sustainability effort will create thousands of jobs and contribute $16 billion to Pennsylvania’s GDP. However, there is still skepticism from environmental groups and state residents about the project and an overlooked threat in the form of AI. 

The main aim of reopening the Three Mile Island is providing carbon-free electricity which will be used by Microsoft’s data centers, according to Penn Capital-Star.  However, the tricky issue with AI production’s energy use comes not from carbon, but from a different resource: water. According to Forbes, the cooling process needed to sustain AI servers uses a whopping 43.8 liters per kilowatt hour. To compare, an adult human only needs 2-3 liters of water per day. Considering the increasing global epidemic of water shortages, with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection reporting that at least 18 of the state’s water suppliers have experienced shortages since June, there are concerns to be raised about how Three Mile Island’s new AI efforts are going to affect Pennsylvania water accessibility. Despite protests from environmental groups raging since the project was announced in September, there has been little to no mention of potential drawbacks of such a large AI powerbase taking root in PA.  

In an article published by Broad + Liberty, State Rep. Tom Mehaffie (R), discussed his shift in advocating against reopening the plant, which he now ardently supports. On its reputation, Mehaffie said “For decades, TMI has been unfairly demonized through misinformation. When talk of closure began, some voices were quick to spread fear rather than facts. But the truth is that Unit 1 at TMI has one of the best safety records of any power generation facility in the country,” referring to concerns of another partial meltdown. Unit 2 of the TMI experienced the meltdown, exposing small amounts of radioactive releases that didn’t cause detectable health issues to the public, according to NRC. 

The Pennsylvania government’s aim in reopening Three Mile Island is to reinvigorate the middle class, providing jobs and funding schools in towns in the Dauphin county area, which according to NIDIS has a current 10,276 residents affected by drought.  

In spite of greater environmental concerns with the unsustainable cooling process AI power grids require, nuclear power is actually one of the most environmentally conscious forms of mass power production, serving as a zero-emission clean energy source, according to energy.gov. However, with the payoff provided by nuclear’s clean energy comes bigger questions about the increasing power vacuum of AI production. In an interview with Living on Earth, Evan Halper, who covers energy transition for The Washington Post, spoke of how the companies spearheading the AI boom have no plan for its future and no indication of what might happen if AI production grows bigger than our natural resources can sustain. “How long is this going to continue?” Halper asks. “That’s a question they don’t like to get, and they don’t really give a clear answer to.” Halper’s words only ring more true as the question of AI is omitted from most discussion of the plant’s reopening.  

Harrisburg residents continue to protest, according to Penn Live, as local communities express fear over another meltdown. Activists held signs saying “No nukes, not again” congregating near the infamous site on the 45th anniversary of the meltdown. Despite local pushback, PA politicians on both sides of the aisle seem to hold a positive attitude towards the plant’s reopening and the impact it will have on the state’s economy. Despite all this discussion, AI remains at the back of the conversation, even as global warming makes water scarcity a more and more pressing issue for Pennsylvania communities.  

 


 Elijah Fischer is a third-year English and Media & Culture major.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *