Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Without a doubt, the stress levels of millions of American college students just went up yesterday, as the federal pause on student loan payment and interest accrual just ended. The pause began in March 2020 as an emergency measure at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and has been in effect for nearly three years. However, a recent bill from Congress included a provision that would resume interest accrual for student loans on Sept. 1 of 2023 and resume payments on Oct. 1.

This comes after The Supreme Court struck down the Biden Administration’s proposed plan to cancel $10,000 of student debt for borrowers making less than $125,000 a year in a 6-3 decision this summer. The court ruled that the Biden administration did not have the authority under the HEROES Act — a post-9/11 law allowing the president to waive federal laws and regulations in the event of an emergency — to cancel student debt.

Joe Biden made the policy one of his key election promises in the 2020 cycle, contributing to a boost in his approval rating amongst college-age Americans. In the absence of the policy, however, the administration has offered modest help to borrowers who will see payments due after almost three years. Borrowers who miss a payment between yesterday and Sept. 30, 2024, will not be considered delinquent, placed in default, or reported to credit agencies. On top of this, the administration will peg the size of each payment to a borrower’s income and family size under a plan called SAVE or Saving on a Valuable Education.

While these policy changes will help many students and former students financially adjust to the new circumstances, they will do little to address a uniquely American problem. It’s no secret that the United States does not guarantee tuition-free higher education to its citizens. College education is treated as a privilege, not a right. Instead of appropriating government funds to pay for college education like many European countries, Americans often cripple themselves financially — Americans have taken on $1.7 trillion total in student loan debt alone. While unprecedented, history sheds light on this alarming reality.

A rift has existed between prevailing attitudes toward the value of education and reality. Some of America’s founding fathers believed in the power of education in a democracy. In 1822, James Madison remarked in a letter to William T. Barry that “Knowledge will forever govern ignorance: And a people who mean to be their own Governors must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives.” Thomas Jefferson held similar beliefs. According to James Carpenter of Binghamton University, “To ensure that the people were the best safeguard against an overzealous government, Jefferson’s political vision required an informed citizenry.” Jefferson even proposed the creation of a public school system in Virginia in 1817.

Education equated to political power within the ideology of revolutionary America. Despite this, the U.S. Constitution makes no mention of education or a right to one. It is relegated to being a function of state governance. Ironically, the Constitution provides a right to firearms yet includes no right to a quality education. No matter how one feels about the Second Amendment, it’s hard to call this anything but a mismatch of priorities. It’s no wonder that the American system has no problem pricing its citizens out of the opportunity for education.

Throughout various chapters in history, there have been attempts to push for an easily accessible college education. In 1947, President Harry Truman created a commission to give recommendations for national education policy. The commission’s report advocated removing financial barriers to college and granting two years of free community college for every student. The report states: “It is the responsibility of the community, at the local, State, and National levels, to guarantee that financial barriers do not prevent any able and otherwise qualified young person from receiving the opportunity for higher education.” Overall, it called for a larger federal influence in higher education. The report would modestly influence federal education policies for the following decades.

While tuition-free college has never been formally implemented on a national scale, it has existed in small instances. California has historically been home to several colleges which, although they charged fees, were tuition-free. Ronald Reagan’s governorship and subsequent presidency would end all of this in California and nationwide. When he became governor in 1966, Reagan called for an end to tuition-free college in the state and demanded 20% cuts in higher education spending. When he became president, Reagan forever changed federal education policy, slashing over 50% of the federal education budget and even advocating to abolish the Department of Education. For a president as influential as Reagan, this was no small gesture.

A downward trajectory in state spending for higher education followed through the decades. In 1988, according to the Center for Budgetary and Policy Priorities, student tuition accounted for a quarter of the revenue of public colleges and universities. By 2019, it had risen to half. The price for a four-year college, according to Forbes, increased by 180% between 1980 and 2020. By 1992, the federal government began to give out direct, unsubsidized loans, pushing the burden of higher tuition costs onto students.

Today in Pennsylvania, students are in a particularly difficult spot. According to Inside Higher Ed, Pennsylvania ranked 49th in the nation for public spending on college per student in 2021. Looking at data from the National Science Foundation, per-student funding for previous years has been similarly slim. This is in spite of the fact that Pennsylvania ranks 4th in the nation for the number of universities. The same article from Inside Higher Ed states that the average cost of attending a state college in PA is $26,040, 70% higher than the national average.

While these facts are important to keep in mind as tuition payments take their toll, it is also important to remember that problematic attitudes towards education became predominant in the decades following President Truman’s Commission. While Truman once remarked that “A carefully developed program to strengthen higher education will inevitably strengthen our Nation and enrich the lives of our citizens,” Reagan took an opposing view just 20 years later, claiming that taxpayers shouldn’t be subsidizing intellectual curiosity.

Before we can tackle the student debt crisis, America needs to reckon with attitudes like this and make higher education a priority. It is a vital component of any democracy that wishes to save itself from decay, and financial barriers shouldn’t stand in the way. In 1970, Ronald Reagan’s education advisor, Roger Freeman, crudely commented: “We are in danger of producing an educated proletariat… That’s dynamite!” However, to pretend there is anything wrong with that is a grave mistake. 


Josh Czaja is a first-year Political Science major. JC1029473@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *