Photo by FX
Season 12 of “American Horror Story” premiered Sept. 20 on FX and Sept. 21 on Hulu. The new season stars Emma Roberts, Kim Kardashian and Cara Delevingne.
Unlike any other season that’s premiered so far, this one is based on the book, “Delicate Conditions” by Danielle Valentine, about a woman named Anna who goes through her IVF journey and soon after feels like someone is trying to stop her from getting pregnant. A few weeks after she is finally pregnant, her doctor tells her she miscarried, but she can still feel someone…or something growing inside of her. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Valentine said her book “is essentially a horror novel about pregnancy…[she] was really much more inspired by “Alien,” which [she] think[s] will also give readers an idea of where [she is] taking this.” Similarly, to the movie “Rosemary’s Baby” (1968), which is about a woman having a baby and noticing something is not normal about her bundle of joy, “Delicate” follows the same plot in a different horrific way.
Season 12 of AHS starts out strong with Anna, a famous actress managed by Siobhan, played by Kim Kardashian. Later on, we find out Siobhan also attempted IVF but was unsuccessful. Not only is Anna finally coming up as an actress and getting her big break after years of small roles, she is also trying to have a baby. The balance of late night shows, keeping up with her social life and following strict instructions by her doctor begins catching up to her. She begins to notice strange people watching her. The opening scene begins with Anna asleep as she suddenly wakes to a black figure watching her at the end of her bed. She then notices the later-introduced Nurse Ivy, played by Cara Delevingne, lurking around watching her from a distance, and an older woman taking photos of her at the clinic who later appears in an audience of a late night show. Anna tells Siobhan that her greatest fear while getting pregnant now is that her baby will come out as a spider because she is so old and dusty. This parallels the promotional photos for this season which feature her holding a giant spider on her stomach like a baby. Maybe her greatest fear will come true?
Though we don’t know much about the new season, we do know someone is trying to stop Annafrom getting pregnant: her fertility pills go missing and then reappear in strange places, she hears whispers telling her not to take her medication and someone is hacking into her calendar, changing her appointment times. Of course her partner does not believe her when she tells him about all of this — he brushes it off as stress with her new baby and working too much. After meeting his friends for dinner, we discover Anna’s partner was previously married but his former wife passed away suddenly, unknown thus far in the season, but he and his friends are still talking about her and comparing her to Anna. We even get to meet Sonia, the doppelganger of Anna’s husband’s late wife. She gives a mysterious but eerie presence on screen.
Ryan Murphy has definitely been taking a different turn in his most recent seasons of “American Horror Story,” since we are used to seeing witches, clowns, vampires and demons from earlier seasons. The newest seasons, Cult, NYC and Delicate, have been showing us true American horror stories.
Although this new season is a new genre of horror for “American Horror Story,” they have done a similar episode in Ryan Murphy’s “American Horror Stories,” which is a one-hour short horror show. The episode I’m referring to is season one episode five, “BA’AL.” A woman is given a small statue of a “fertility god” that will help her get pregnant after five failed rounds of IVF. Months later after successfully having a baby she begins to be haunted by a demon, goes insane, stabs her husband and ends up in a mental facility. After all of this we find out she was gaslighted by her husband and his friends because he never wanted a baby, just her money. This can be a little confusing due to all of the images of BA’AL shown in the episode.
The moral of both of these horror stories: being gaslit is the real horror story in this generation of horror.
Lauren Flynn-Miller is a third year Interdisciplinary Studies Major with minors in Journalism, Media & Culture, and Professional & Technical Writing. LF954013@wcupa.edu
https://ew.com/books/delicate-condition-danielle-valentine-american-horror-story-season-12-kim -kardashian/
https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/21/entertainment/kim-kardashian-american-horror-story-delicate-r eview/index.html
https://variety.com/2021/tv/recaps/american-horror-stories-episode-5-baal-recap-1235035441/
