Image Credits: World Economic Forum Annual Meeting, Flickr
As Washington Retreats from Free Trade, Bipartisan Protectionism Takes Hold.
After three lower courts ruled the taxes unlawful, the tariffs case arrived at the Supreme Court, where justices confronted the question of whether President Trump had overstepped his authority. The decision delivered a significant blow to the administration’s second‑term economic agenda. Officials had long cautioned that losing the case could unravel trade agreements and trigger massive refunds to importers, warnings that now appear prescient. Trump became the first president to claim that a 1970s emergency statute, which never references “tariffs,” empowered him to impose duties without congressional approval.
Writing for the majority, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. held that the statute simply does not authorize the president to impose tariffs. “The president asserts the extraordinary power to unilaterally impose tariffs of unlimited amount, duration and scope. In light of the breadth, history and constitutional context of that asserted authority, he must identify clear congressional authorization to exercise it,” Roberts wrote. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel A. Alito Jr., and Brett M. Kavanaugh dissented, warning that the refund process, potentially involving billions, would create a substantial “mess,” especially since many importers had already passed the costs on to consumers. Notably, two of Trump’s own appointees, Justices Neil M. Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett, joined Roberts.
The 6–3 decision pushed back against Trump’s sweeping tariffs on U.S. trading partners, offering relief to American businesses and signaling that the ramifications extend far beyond international trade agreements. In response, Trump has sought alternative authorities under national‑security statutes to justify new “emergency tariffs,” insisting that his original goal, reducing the trade deficit, remains unchanged.
The tariffs began as a purported punishment for Canada, Mexico and China for failing to stop the flow of fentanyl: 25% on goods from Canada and Mexico, 10% on China. But the program quickly expanded. Trade deficits took center stage, and the duties spread to nearly all major trading partners. Although the Court’s conservative majority had often granted Trump emergency relief in the past, this case was different.
Last year, Trump invoked the International Emergency Economic Powers Act of 1977 (IEEPA) to impose tariffs on imports from more than 100 countries, an unprecedented move. He argued that doing so would shrink the trade deficit and spur domestic manufacturing. By the start of fiscal year 2026, the administration had already repurposed tariff revenue to offset policy costs and pressure foreign governments in negotiations.
A dozen states and a coalition of small businesses, including an educational toy manufacturer and a wine importer, filed lawsuits arguing that the president had unlawfully infringed Congress’s constitutional power to impose taxes. The resulting cases, Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump and Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, Inc., made clear that IEEPA contains no clause authorizing taxes, tariffs or duties. The power to regulate trade during a national emergency is not interchangeable with the power to tax.
A friend‑of‑the‑court brief by Michael W. McConnell, a former federal appeals court judge, and Joshua A. Claybourn, a lawyer and historian, argued that Trump’s tariff program violated fundamental constitutional structure and placed him at odds with the conservative legal movement. Signed by an unusually broad coalition of conservative, libertarian and liberal scholars, the brief warned that Trump’s reliance on expansive executive authority breached core separation‑of‑powers principles. One district judge cited the same point eight times: “The powers to tax, to regulate commerce, and to shape the nation’s economic course must remain with Congress.”
Even the Court’s liberal justices were unsatisfied with the administration’s distinctions. Justice Sonia Sotomayor noted, “You want to say tariffs are not taxes, but that’s exactly what they are. They are generating money from American citizens.” And, as filings and social‑media posts made clear, the administration viewed the case as critical to its trade and foreign‑policy agenda.
On “Liberation Day,” the U.S. Treasury collected roughly $240 billion in tariff revenue. Capital Economics estimated that refunds could reach $120 billion, about 50% of the gross domestic product. Whether refunds will be ordered, how they would work, and how long the process might take remain unclear. If refunds proceed, Customs and Border Protection and the Treasury Department will need to build a system to return the money, a process that could take months or years. FedEx filed suit yesterday demanding refunds, and many more companies are expected to follow in the Court of International Trade.
While Trump searches for alternative authorities and attempts to preserve billions in revenue, American businesses face their own battle. As the Court concluded, “The two words ‘regulate’ and ‘importation’ do not give the president the power to impose tariffs on imports from any country, of any product, at any rate, for any amount of time.” Roberts emphasized that the president’s use of IEEPA violated the major questions doctrine, which requires Congress to speak clearly when authorizing sweeping economic actions. The Court relied on the same doctrine when it struck down President Biden’s student loan forgiveness program.
Meanwhile, Census Bureau data show a record U.S. trade deficit, softened only by a strong surplus in services. Companies rerouted orders, restructured supply chains and stockpiled goods in anticipation of new levies. Investors turned to foreign gold as a hedge against volatility. American manufacturers shed more than 80,000 jobs over the past year. New waves of high‑value imports, AI data centers and weight‑loss drugs further widened the gap. China retaliated against Trump’s policies, and the U.S. goods trade deficit with China fell to $202 billion in 2025, its lowest level in more than two decades and, for the first time, smaller than the deficit with the European Union.
Analysts from the New York Federal Reserve and Columbia University concluded that, as in Trump’s first term, the costs of the 2018 and 2019 tariffs were largely borne by U.S. companies and consumers as they renegotiated contracts and reorganized production. As China’s share of U.S. imports declined, imports from Mexico, Vietnam and India surged. Trump has long pointed to tariff revenues as evidence of success. Without them, the government may face greater fiscal strain, especially after Republicans added significantly to the national debt through costly tax reductions.
Businesses now argue that the government must refund the levies they paid. Roughly 900 claims have already been filed in federal court, according to the Liberty Justice Center. With little clarity about how refunds would work, or whether courts will order them, companies such as L’Oréal, AllSaints, Bausch + Lomb and FedEx are pursuing multiple avenues at once. Some filed motions with U.S. Customs to recover duties already paid; others hired lawyers and began filing early lawsuits to secure refunds through litigation.
Jeffrey Schwab, senior counsel at the Liberty Justice Center, said businesses are in “pretty good shape” legally “because the government has already essentially promised” to issue refunds. “We won the case, and our clients were harmed by paying the money,” he said. “Our clients are the ones that are, right now, harmed by the fact they haven’t gotten their money back.” The White House declined to comment. And for now, it appears few are eager to join the tariff‑war bandwagon.
Abella Turczynski is a first year Media and Culture Major. ATurczynski086@wcupa.edu
