Image Credits: Copyright Owned by © 2025 Apple Corps Limited, ℗ 2025 Calderstone Productions Limited (a division of Universal Music Group) / Apple Corps Limited via Wikimedia Commons
The Beatles, the most popular band of all time, have released a new anthology album over 50 years after their breakup. To date, they have released three anthologies — one in 1995 and two in 1996. It’s been 29 years — who would’ve thought they would revisit this project? Turns out, they did. On Nov. 21, 2025, “Anthology 4” was born, home to rebranded versions of well-known songs such as “In My Life” and “Here Comes The Sun,” as well as remixed versions of lesser-known songs like “Matchbox” and “Hey Bulldog.” Whether you’re a die-hard Beatles fan, a casual but loyal listener or a blunt hater, I want to tell you that it won’t be long until you get back to the band that rightfully dominates any 1960s radio station.
Which Songs Are in This Anthology?
Running just shy of two hours long, “Anthology 4” contains 36 tracks. It is organized chronologically, from the Beatles’ mop-top era (early to mid-1960s) to their LSD-infused era (mid-1960s) to their “Get Back” era (1969). Upon listening to the two-hour compilation, I can confidently say that all of these versions deserved to be released. While they may not be radio-worthy, people who recognize the charm within will likely appreciate the vintage quality present in each song.
While all of the original songs have been released before, “Anthology 4” serves to provide previously unreleased versions of said songs. While many of these versions, namely “Strawberry Fields Forever – Take 26,” had previously been released in other albums and/or compilations, “Anthology 4” features many new tracks, or “takes.” For instance, “In My Life (Take 1)” was a gentler, more realistic version of the original Lennon-McCartney composition. Another example is “Baby, You’re A Rich Man (Takes 11 and 12),” which was twice as long as the original version. A more noticeable difference can be seen in “Something (Take 39 – Strings Only Instrumental),” which is, as the parentheses indicate, solely instrumental. Several other instrumental-only songs are featured on the anthology, some of which are new, while others were previously released.
Additionally, many of these takes include dialogue from the band members. Hearing this in “Tell Me Why (Takes 12 and 13)” made me emotional because I hadn’t expected to hear background chatter from the band members, especially from my favorite Beatle, George Harrison, whose dialogue means more to me since he has passed.
Overall, though these differences are subtle, as they accumulate throughout the album, they demonstrate the emotional sparks that powerful music can yield.
“Free As A Bird” and “Real Love”
The most widely anticipated releases for Beatles fans were the 2025 mixes of “Free As A Bird” and “Real Love,” which were released in “Anthology 1” (1995) and “Anthology 2” (1996), respectively. Both songs were unreleased demos written by John Lennon, which weren’t discovered until after his death. During the “Anthology” project in the mid-1990s, the remaining three Beatles at the time – George Harrison, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr – worked together to revitalize these demos, ultimately releasing them for the first time 15-16 years after Lennon’s death. Because these songs were only released in compilations, alternate versions didn’t exist until 2025.
“Free As A Bird (2025 Mix)” was released in Aug. 2025, so fans received one out of these two alternate mixes before the anthology was released. At first, I had a similar reaction to many other fans, which was that I vastly preferred the 1995 version. The 2025 vocals sound extremely over-edited, and it was obvious that they’d used AI. However, once I listened to it a few more times, I began to appreciate its vintage quality more.
Although it’s true that the 2025 mix utilizes AI, I believe one of its sole appropriate uses is to remaster old material, which is exactly what the Beatles did. They did the same thing with “Now And Then” in 2023, and it worked seamlessly. While the vocals weren’t nearly as clean on “Free As A Bird,” I began to appreciate its vintage quality, especially with the revitalized vocals from Harrison.
I was undoubtedly the most excited to hear the 2025 version of “Real Love,” which is one of my favorite Beatles songs. Similar to the 2025 mix of “Free As A Bird,” though, I was disappointed at first. Upon the first two listens, I once again recognized that just because the vocals sound artificial doesn’t mean that the Beatles’ team didn’t try. Additionally, just because I prefer the 1996 version doesn’t mean that the 2025 version doesn’t yield significance in revitalizing one of Lennon’s unreleased song tapes from the late 1970s. It’s still a significant moment in the song’s history, and I’ll certainly revisit the track during my re-listens of the anthology.
On a more positive note, something the Beatles anthologies do well is provide fans with much more realistic and raw-sounding vocals, which can certainly be seen in many of these songs, especially the 2025 mixes of “Free As A Bird” and “Real Love.”
How This Lives up to Previous Anthologies
“Anthology 1” (1995) featured unreleased songs from the band’s early days, including their British secondary school years, in which Harrison, McCartney, Lennon and their school friends were in a band known as “The Quarrymen.” This anthology included new tracks, such as “Free As A Bird – 1995 Mix.” Next, “Anthology 2” (1996) primarily focused on their psychedelic-infused music, from “Rubber Soul” (1965) to “Magical Mystery Tour” (1967), as well as some singles. This anthology also included previously unreleased tracks, such as “Real Love,” and previously unavailable tracks, such as “12-Bar Original – Take 2 Edited.” Last but not least, “Anthology 3” (1996) included the Beatles’ version of Paul McCartney’s solo song, “Junk,” as well as demos like “Old Brown Shoe,” which was a previously unreleased Harrison song.
The biggest caveat with this anthology versus the previous three is that “Anthology 4” doesn’t contain any new songs. Now, the question is, can the Beatles still go above and beyond expectations?
My answer to this question is, and always will be, no matter the content – yes. While I would’ve loved new songs, it’s becoming increasingly more unrealistic to expect new songs from a band that broke up in the early 1970s.
Their Legacy
There are several reasons why the Beatles remain the most popular and famous band of all time, one of them being the revolutionary impact their music had on both their fans and the rock genre as a whole. Though many of their earlier songs were inspired by an American rock-influenced Liverpudlian genre known as “merseybeat,” by the time the mid-1960s came around, they started to invent their own distinctive sound.
“Anthology 4” serves to prove that even in 2025, with Lennon and Harrison having long since passed and McCartney and Starr in their mid-80s, Beatlemania lives on. Beyond McCartney’s and Starr’s eventual passings, I believe that each generation will continue to honor all that these four boys from Liverpool have done for music, and that that influence will continue, now and then, throughout generations.
Charlotte Ruth is a third-year English major with minors in Creative Writing and Italian Studies.
