Image Credits: Troy T via Flickr, CC BY 2.0
Bethesda Game Works, makers of award-winning franchises like The Elder Scrolls and Fallout are no strangers to controversy. For years, they have made plenty of good games, but all of them have had their woes, usually involving technical bugs and crashes. However, it seems like things at Bethesda are in dire need of fixing, not just their games.
Three weeks ago on Oct. 23rd, the video game developer and publisher held a livestream to celebrate the 10th Anniversary of their game Fallout 4, by announcing Fallout 4: Anniversary Edition, which would be released in November for modern consoles such as the PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S as well as the game being ported to the Nintendo Switch 2 in 2026. This news was followed by the announcement that Fallout 76, the online multiplayer title first released in 2018, would also receive an upgrade to modern consoles and a new expansion in the form of Burning Springs. The stream then concluded with Todd Howard, the company’s Game Director and Executive Producer, teasing future projects. What ticked off the viewership however was the announcement of the Fallout: New Vegas 15th Anniversary Bundle.
Leading up to the stream, fans were speculating whether Fallout: New Vegas, often considered one of the best entries in the franchise, was going to receive the remastered treatment like Elder Scrolls: Oblivion. Even Hollywood star Danny Trejo, who played Raul Alfonso Tejada in Fallout: New Vegas, was excited at the prospect. This sadly did not happen and probably wasn’t going to in the first place. However, what Bethesda did announce was the bundle. The backlash was almost immediate, as irate fans pointed out the absurd price of $154.99 for a game that was over ten years old, and only included a small statue, pins, patches and a re-released version of the game with all the DLC.
Things have since only gotten worse with the arrival of Fallout 4: Anniversary Edition on Monday, Nov. 10. What was supposed to be an easy layup for Bethesda, quickly turned out to be a farcical sideshow. To begin with, the new edition costs $59.99, the same price as a new game. Alternatively, if you already happen to own a copy of Fallout 4, it is only $39.99. Bethesda has tried to justify this by claiming that the game comes included with all of Fallout 4’s DLC, and “150 Creation Club mods.” Creation Club has been a sticking point for many of Bethesda’s critics ever since the program was unveiled back in 2018, which the company has defended by saying it compensates modders for their work. In all fairness, players who already own the base game along with all the DLC can just buy the Creation Club bundle for $19.99.
However, even that $19.99 price tag falls in value again when you consider the vast amount of the paid mods included amount to paintjobs for in-game items, and skins for player-characters and non-player-characters. There is some new content such as new power armor and weapons, but even then, according to Kaitlyn Peterson writing for The Gamer: “Of all the items being made available through the Creations Bundle, or Anniversary Edition, nine of these items were previously unreleased.”
All of this has garnered a storm of negative PR for the company, with the Steam store page for Fallout 4 being “review bombed,” a practice when a lot of users leave negative reviews for a game as a form of protest against the publisher and/or developer. Brendan Lowry, writing for Windows Central stated: “Fallout 4 has been getting flooded with negative user reviews on Steam, with only 44% of its 4,225 recent reviews (at the time of writing) positive. The rest give Bethesda’s open-world RPG a glaring crimson thumbs down.”
In addition to the egregious monetization attached to the Anniversary Edition, is the new patch for Fallout 4. For the last 18 months, “Fallout 4” on PC has been decried as “broken” by fans due to an onslaught of bugs that interferes with the game running smoothly. This includes the “V.A.T.S.” game mechanic integral to the core gameplay loop, as well as making the game incompatible with a vast amount of the mods for it. Putting aside the jaw-dropping fact that Bethesda did nothing to fix the substantial issues for the PC version of their popular game for 18 months, the patch that came with the anniversary edition seemed to have introduced a slew of new bugs and crashes as well, even if players aren’t using any mods at all. Lowry continues: “One such player that posted a negative review was particularly unlucky, as their game saves were corrupted by the patch. ‘The 10th anniversary edition update nonsense broke my old saves. No mods, just vanilla “Fallout 4,’” they explained. ‘I didn’t even purchase the crappy Anniversary Edition, but they still force it on you, just not the content. IT JUST WORKS. Do NOT recommend.’”
In the company’s defense, Bethesda put out a press-release on Nov. 12 via Steam, assuring players that they: “are actively investigating issues you’re encountering with the latest Fallout 4 update and Anniversary Edition launch.” Whether Bethesda is truly committed to fixing their own mess remains to be seen, it appears that is where they are headed.
All these hassles and headaches with the company raise one important question: why does this even exist? Ostensibly, it seems to have been put out to coincide with the immense popularity of the “Fallout” TV show on Prime Video and its upcoming second season, and to “celebrate” Fallout 4’s 10th anniversary. However, when you consider Bethesda’s actions, they paint a very different picture compared to whatever positive spin they try to articulate after the fact. Bethesda’s actions communicate that they don’t care about the quality of their games as much as they think they do, because they know their customer base will buy the product regardless of its quality.
Kelly Baker is an alumnus from West Chester University.
