Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Billy Freeman via Unsplash

“GameStop declares the console wars are over,” so says the video game retailer in a post on X (formally Twitter) on Oct. 25 in response to Halo: Campaign Evolved, coming to PlayStation. Xbox is porting not just Halo, but also its other legacy franchises over to its competitor’s hardware. What first started out as Xbox diversifying into PC Gaming in 2016 under its “Play Anywhere” initiative has now turned into such a tectonic shift for the brand, making it hard to recognize what the business of Xbox even is. 

Is it console gaming? Evidently not, considering an interview that Sarah Bond, President of Xbox, had with Timothy Beck Werth, Mashable’s Tech Editor, on Oct. 21. In the interview, Bond was asked about the next Xbox console and whether it would be more like a gaming PC. She responded with: “Well, I can tell you you’re right that the next-gen console is going to be a very premium, very high-end, curated experience.”

Notice that Bond didn’t deny the rumors, which means that Xbox seems to be moving somewhere in the vague direction of a broader ecosystem where users can play their games across PCs, as well as handheld consoles such as the new ROG Xbox Ally, and away from its roots in console gaming.

How did Xbox go from pioneering online console gaming with Xbox Live, doing victory laps around PlayStation in the late mid-to-late 2000s with the Xbox 360, to an identity crisis at present? One could argue that the problems began when Don Mattrick presided over as Xbox CEO from 2007 to 2014. However, this isn’t the fault of just one person. Rather, a strong argument could be made that all of this began with the unveiling of the Xbox One. Back in late May 2013, Microsoft’s gaming division decided to unveil its next console on its campus in Redmond, Washington. With a great many people tuning into the live-stream or showing up in person, the public was curious about what the future of Xbox had in store.

What they got was one of the most controversial tech demos in gaming history. Throughout the hour-long presentation, various Xbox executives and guest speakers talked about how the new Xbox One would allow for live TV, movies and even Skype. In fact, the speakers spent over 30 minutes trying to hype up the multimedia and TV features, which started to leave the audience confused. And then, it got even worse.

Following this event, it turned out the new Xbox One would have to check in every day with the company servers or else you couldn’t play any games. In addition, the new console would come bundled with the Kinect and would require the sensor to be plugged in for the console to function. And to cap it off was the debacle about pre-owned games. If a user were to insert a new game disc into the console, it would tie the game to their account, and then any attempt to sell the physical game would only be available to retailers pre-selected by Xbox.

Although Xbox hastily walked back all these controversial features, it was a moment that haunted the company for years, and it only got worse as time marched on. Little by little and year after year since then, Xbox has suffered from haphazard sales numbers and a lack of groundbreaking, exclusive titles compared to PlayStation and Nintendo. Even when Xbox released good first-party titles such as Forza Horizon 4, Gears 5, Microsoft Flight Simulator, Psychonauts 2, High-Fi Rush and Halo: Infinite, it came bundled along with travesties such as Redfall, studio closures like Tango Gameworks, lay-offs galore, and the controversies surrounding the acquisition of Activision-Blizzard in 2023.

The critical moment that emphasized all these woes could be pinpointed in 2023, when Phil Spencer, CEO of Microsoft Gaming, stated in an interview with Kinda Funny Games, “We lost the worst generation to lose in the Xbox One generation.” With such a high-ranking executive admitting that its last console generation was a failure, it only makes the more recent news about the “30% accountability margin” Amy Hood, Xbox CFO, implemented that same year, even more concerning. One could even say such profit margins are unrealistic considering how, according to Lincoln Carpenter writing for PC Gamer, “S&P Global Market Intelligence estimates that profit margins in the games industry have fallen from a recent height of 22% during the COVID lockdown years of 2020 and 2021 to an average of 17% in 2024.”

These moves to maximize profits for Xbox while also focusing on handheld PC gaming, and porting over their once precious first-party titles to competitors’ hardware, have left the public scratching their heads, and wondering whether or not Xbox has just gone the way of SEGA back in 2001, waving the white flag to its competitors.

 


Kelly Baker is an alumnus from West Chester University.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *