Image Credits: Ame Inu, Flickr
You may have seen certain individuals in our government hailing that they will discover the cause of autism come September since April of this year. Ever since the beginning of the Trump administration, an asinine amount of lies have been spread about autism as a disorder and what scientists know about it. Now, autumn has begun and the administration has a clear cut answer.
On Sep. 21, RFK Jr. claimed that autism is linked to mothers using Tylenol during pregnancy because of its main ingredient, acetaminophen and that the cure is a drug called leucovorin. However, studies have concluded there is no significant evidence that Tylenol, one of the only safe drugs to use during pregnancy, causes autism. There is only an association which is confused as a causation. Even if Tylenol did cause autism, Dr. Zeyan Liew points out to the Yale School of Public Health that taking Tylenol should not necessarily be discouraged, as untreated fevers can harm child development as well. Most people would rather have an autistic child than a dead one.
It’s also essential to know that autism has existed before Tylenol. Most people would know, but Trump stated on the 22nd that the Amish don’t have any autism because they don’t use Tylenol. This is a myth that our president is spreading. Tylenol, which was created in 1955, is not older than the human genome.
It is doubly essential for the reader to know that I am on the spectrum, and in 2020 I was part of a study that helped determine the cause — the biggest autism study in history. I spit in a tube and my DNA was sent to SPARK— the organization running the study — and they found a genetic abnormality. In fact, they found hundreds of genes in hundreds of thousands of individuals that are linked with symptoms of autism. This confirms the suspicions scientists have had for decades — that autism is mostly genetic.
Autism isn’t real. Or, at the very least it’s not what you think it is. Autism is an umbrella term for hundreds of genetic abnormalities that fall under the same category with similar symptoms and characteristics. Under each genetic abnormality the genetic expression varies within the individual. That’s why if there are two siblings with autism, the same gene may be expressed little in one and more in the other, the difference between ‘moderate’ and ‘severe’ autism being akin to moving a switch further down the line. All autism cases are caused by a difference in gene, with 80% being inherited mutations, which means autism is hereditary. Think back to seventh grade biology. Every other case is caused by a gene mutating during pregnancy — an environmental cause.
According to SPARK, “An environmental factor in autism is something, other than DNA, that affects a child before, during or after birth.” This automatically disproves the Tylenol claim, because Tylenol would be a chemical cause, not an environmental one. Vaccines are chemical. Medicine is chemical. But pollution, which has been on the rise, is environmental. Getting sick during pregnancy is environmental and so is having a baby later in life, or complications during birth. It should be noted that how much the environment has to play is disputed, as some scientists like Zoe Gross claim there is only an association instead of a causation. But the consensus is that environmental factors play a role. All in all, there is no singular cause of autism.
Now that we know where autism comes from, you can tell that what Trump and RFK are spewing is nothing short of political propaganda. These politicians are not autism experts. They aren’t autistic parents or caregivers or autistic themselves, nor are they one of the thousands of researchers with decades of experience they laid off. They are also cisgender men who have never had the luxury of having a uterus or getting pregnant. They are men making decisions for women. It is a worry that they will go about blaming women for the decisions they choose to make responsibly during a pregnancy. It is adjacent to “The Handmaid’s Tale” by Margaret Atwood, where no medical intervention is allowed at all during a pregnancy.
The medicine proposed to treat autism is Leucovorin, also known as Folinic Acid. Leucovorin is not FDA approved and is mostly used on chemo patients deficient in vitamin B9. One study in India tested Leucovorin with autistic children and found improving behaviors. However, studies testing the drug have been found to be inconsistent and varied. Yes, it may have benefits — as autistic people are deficient in foliates, so folinic acid could help — but it will not be a cure. Any cure would have to manipulate the gene itself. Saying that it is a cure is incredibly manipulative to vulnerable parents who will do anything to help their child.
The people who will be put on this medicine most likely are nonverbal, intellectually disabled and exhibit challenging behaviors. I do think it will be beneficial to develop medicine to help those who have uncontrollable behaviors that diminish their quality of life. I will not shame parents and caregivers who need help even if I don’t personally believe in an entire autism cure. But people should be allowed to keep their personality and their soul; people should be allowed to exist as they are. We don’t need a cure, we need accessibility first.
Emily Rutz is a second-year English major with a French minor. ER1034711@wcupa.edu
