This September, thousands of actors and filmmakers have taken up sides regarding participation in Israeli entertainment projects, with one group orchestrating a boycott while another opposes.
The situation came to the public’s attention on Monday, Sept. 8, when the organization calling itself “Film Workers for Palestine,” announced a pledge to refuse to work with Israeli entertainment productions. According to their website, the group’s mission statement reads: “Inspired by ‘Filmmakers United Against Apartheid’ who refused to screen their films in apartheid-era South Africa, we pledge not to screen films, appear at or otherwise work with Israeli film institutions — including festivals, cinemas, broadcasters and production companies — that are implicated in genocide and apartheid against the Palestinian people.”
The pledge itself comes in the wake of the outpouring of protests and concerns from human rights groups, academic circles, NGOs and government institutions, over the war in Gaza. The Film Workers for Palestine cited a resolution published by the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS) this August, which itself argues that the Israeli government and military are responsible for crimes against humanity, which itself drew sharp criticism from the Israeli Foreign Ministry.
The pledge itself garnered a rapid number of signatories in the days after it launched, with well-known celebrities such as Olivia Colman, Joaquin Phoenix, Brian Cox, Emma Stone, Tilda Swinton, Adam McKay, Mark Ruffalo and more, all promising not to cooperate with Israeli film productions. Last week, during the 77th Primetime Emmy Awards, multiple participants in the pledge showed their solidarity. Javiar Bardem, known for his appearance in the upcoming film “One Battle After Another,” wore a keffiyeh, a traditional black and white Palestinian scarf. During the ceremony, Hannah Einbinder, who had received the award for “Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series,” made clear her support for the cause by proclaiming: “Free Palestine” during her acceptance speech.
The pledge has drawn skepticism and critique from across the entertainment industry. Paramount Pictures, one of the oldest organizations in the industry, publicly denounced the boycott on Friday, Sept. 12. In an article from Variety, authors Matt Donnelly and Angelique Jackson quoted Melissa Zukerman, Paramount’s chief communications officer: “‘We do not agree with recent efforts to boycott Israeli filmmakers. Silencing individual creative artists based on their nationality does not promote better understanding or advance the cause of peace…The global entertainment industry should be encouraging artists to tell their stories and share their ideas with audiences throughout the world. We need more engagement and communication — not less.’”
The non-profit organization “Creative Community For Peace and The Brigade,” published an open letter in opposition to the pledge on their blog on Sept. 25 describing the signatories of the pledge of “being misled.” According to Catherine Shoard, writer for the Guardian, “The open letter makes the point that much of the Israeli film and TV industry are ‘often the loudest critics of government policy’ – and frequently penalized by them for this. Last week, the winner of Israel’s own academy awards, The Sea – about a Palestinian boy who risks death to go to the beach in Tel Aviv – was submitted as the country’s entry to the Oscars.” This open letter reacting to the pledge has currently over 1,200 signatures working in the entertainment industry, including Liev Schreiber and Jennifer Jason Leigh.
As of Friday, Sept. 26, the pledge has over 5,000 signatures.
Kelly Baker is an alumnus of West Chester University.
