Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: @polisci_wcupa on Instagram

This Constitution Day, the Political Science department held a panel titled “The Constitution Under Siege” to outline the current challenges within our political system, mainly how they pertain to the constitutional crisis. The panel consisted of professors within the department, with Dr. Peter Loedel moderating. 

When asked what made him want to organize the panel, Dr. Loedel mentioned that the department wanted to provide a learning opportunity as well as implore students to ask questions and understand what is going on within our government. When describing his goal for students to understand what is going on, Dr. Loedel stated, “Our constitutional system is getting stretched and pulled in ways we haven’t seen in recent times.”

The panel began with Dr. Loedel introducing the panelists and defining a constitutional crisis. The definition he used came from the Dean of UC Berkeley School of Law, Erwin Chemerinsky, which reads, “Systematic unconstitutional and illegal acts create a constitutional crisis.” The consensus among many political scientists, historians and constitutional lawyers is that there is a constitutional crisis currently in our country.

The first panelist was Dr. Jenna Becker Kane, who presented on the separation of powers. She described the current separation of powers in this country as “in peril.” This claim was backed up by the 38 executive orders President Trump signed in his first month of office. It was found that 22 of the 38 executive orders appeared to conflict with either the Constitution or existing federal law. Dr. Becker Kane sees the political struggle this country is facing as a result of the consolidation of power within the Executive Branch, as well as Congress’s unwillingness to check said power. 

Next was Dr. Chris Stangl, who covered the Supreme Court and their decision-making process. He went in depth on shadow dockets, which can refer to decisions made by the Supreme Court with a lack of explanation, usually due to urgency. The issues people have lie within more decisions being reached without reasoning, going against the public’s idea of the court’s responsibility. 

Dr. Shannon McQueen followed with a presentation on public opinion and polarization. She described the current polarization we are facing as originating during the Civil Rights Movement and only growing over time. Over the decades, identities have become increasingly aligned with political parties. This increases both polarization and hostility between people. This polarization is displayed in acts of political violence, lack of trust in institutions and difficulty passing legislation. A key point she made is that public opinion plays a big part in defending the Constitution.

Dr. Sally Lawton spoke on the topic of the colorblind constitution. This idea that the laws shouldn’t discuss race originates from Justice John Marshall Harlan’s dissent in Plessy v. Ferguson. She argued that this colorblind interpretation only challenges equity and can roll back civil rights. She also stated the importance of the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause in protecting civil rights. In bringing it back to the possibility of a constitutional crisis, Dr. Lawton commented that, “in some ways our Constitution has always been one of crisis.”

Freedom of speech, as well as freedom of association, were topics discussed by Dr. Travis Blemings. Some reasons for concern raised were the recent arrest of college students who showed public support for Palestine, as well as the harassment of law firms that have opposed Trump in his past legal battles. But, Dr. Blemings does not fully blame the constitutional crisis on the current administration, stating that a history of systematic failures has aided in bringing the country to this point.

The last presenter was Dr. Caitlin Brown, who spoke on the press and civil society. She noted that the global alliance, CIVICUS, put the US on a watchlist for countries in which, “there is a serious decline in respect for civic space.” This means a lack of respect for freedoms of association, expression and peaceful assembly in policy, law and practice. In response to this, Dr. Brown remarked, “We need a government and state system that respects civil society in order for it to be able to operate.”

The panel ended with questions from the audience. The panelists were posed with the question, “How do you see college students fitting into all of this, whether it is how it directly impacts us or what our role is in pushing back?” Responses varied, but some recommendations included: ask questions, get involved, conduct research, run for office, go to city council meetings, have conversations, pay attention to what is going on and VOTE!

 


Kendall Lange is a second-year Political Science major with a History minor. KL1035337@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *