Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: “Luigi Mangione by nycmayorsoffice” via Flickr

On Sept. 16, a New York judge dismissed Luigi Mangione’s terrorism charges, though upheld his second-degree murder charge. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, Jr. originally announced Mangione’s indictment on Dec. 17, 2024, stating that Mangione was charged with first-degree murder in furtherance of terrorism for his murder of UnitedHealthcare (UHC) CEO Brian Thompson. 

He was also charged with two counts of second-degree murder, with one listed as killing as an act of terrorism. It was argued that Mangione’s motives could fall under terroristic intent, where an act is committed to “intimidate or coerce a civilian population,” and that he intended to influence public policy by intimidating a unit of government through his actions, according to The People of the State of New York vs Luigi Mangione. However, according to Justice Gregory Carro, there was no evidence of ideological motivation, and that while Mangione was expressing his resentment towards UHC and the healthcare industry, it did not follow a goal to intimidate or coerce people. 

Outside Response to Mangione Before Terrorism Charges Were Dropped

Views on Mangione’s crime have varied greatly since it was committed. On April 1, Pam Bondi, the Trump administration’s Attorney General, directed federal prosecutors to seek the death penalty for Mangione to uphold the president’s agenda to “Make America Safe Again.” She described the attack as, “a premeditated, cold-blooded assassination” and that the murder was “an act of political violence…and because the murder took place in public with bystanders nearby, may have posed grave risk of death to additional persons.” On Dec. 5, 2024, conservative commentator Ben Shapiro covered the assassination and the social media response to it in a YouTube video, covering various posts that criticized UHC and Thompson. In this video, he stated, “Well, if you’re a member of the far-left, apparently, you believe that somebody with the wrong political principles, maybe they should be murdered.”

Shapiro received pushback in the comment section of the video, with various users describing their previous negative experiences with the healthcare system and how it is not a political issue, but rather a class issue. The comment section featured various conservatives pushing back against Shapiro’s comment, such as one comment stating, “Nah Ben, we conservatives agree that it’s time for healthcare reform.” Another wrote, “Just unsubscribed, starting to see who’s back the daily wire has. It isn’t any of us (rep or dem), just the wealthy corporations.” Another comment states, “As a lifelong conservative, I’m surprised to discover I’m left-wing bc Ben Shapiro says so. Sorry, Ben, we’re united on this one. Maybe both sides of the media benefit from keeping us divided.”

WCU Students Respond to Mangione’s Terrorism Charges Being Dropped

After asking multiple West Chester University students their opinion on Mangione’s terrorism charges getting dropped and the crime itself, there was a common consensus that the charges were unfair, and that the negative response to Thompson’s murder showcased the influence that corporations and wealthy people have. It is a class issue, not a political one. One anonymous student stated, “I am happy that the terrorism charges were dropped. In my opinion, terrorism was a bit of an unfair charge.” Another wrote, “I’m glad the terrorism charges were dropped because the only reason he was charged with it is because he killed a wealthy white man. If he had killed anyone different, he would never have been charged with it. We as a society love to pick and choose who we mourn the death of, and it’s always someone with privilege, and never anyone marginalized.”

One student responded with, “I believe the alleged murder of Brian Thompson from, allegedly, Luigi is an attempt to call out the very broken healthcare system in America. The government calling him a terrorist shows how the government protects corporations that ultimately hurt American citizens. This later got dropped, which is a win, but he’s still on trial for alleged murder. They are still trying to get him the death penalty…”

Another student wrote back with, “I think it was outrageous that they even charged him with terrorism in the first place. Terrorism is usually considered as an act that’s meant to inflict fear in the civilian population, but in his case, Luigi Mangione, allegedly, murdered only one person. Although there were some political intentions, this murder was committed against one CEO, it wasn’t taken any farther than that. That charge honestly is a representation of the absolute power and influence that corporations hold in American society today.” They continued in another message, “I think that this case shows the way that the justice system is often weaponized in cases that involve the rich and famous. It’s a horrible case, but it’s clear that more resources were going into it purely because the victim was wealthy and the CEO of a major health insurance company.”

 


Jack Snock is a fourth-year Political Science major with a Journalism minor. AS993182@wcupa.edu.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *