Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Image Credits: Hulu via Wikipedia

If you’re a true crime podcast junkie, an autumnal New York enthusiast or anyone looking for a new murder mystery to binge, fear not — season five of “Only Murders in the Building” aired this past Sept. 9, bringing new plot twists and unfinished business just in time for spooky season. Brought to you by actors and executive producers Selena Gomez, Martin Short and Steve Martin, “Only Murders” is a murder mystery set in the Upper West Side of Manhattan. The “Arconia,” the “building” that the title refers to, is a mysterious, elaborate apartment complex known for its fair share of crime and grime. United by their love for a true crime podcast, characters Mabel Mora, Charles Haden-Savage and Oliver Putnam have a knack for getting themselves into trouble. However, this is no innocent set of characters, for they have their own secrets amidst the ever-constant chaos of the murders in their apartment building.

As I provide spoiler-filled recaps and reviews for the first four episodes of the season, I invite you to delve into a world of mystery and intrigue that encapsulates the epitome of autumn in Manhattan.

Episode One: Nail in the Coffin

The first episode opens with Mabel, Charles and Oliver processing the death of the late Lester Coluca, the well-loved doorman of the Arconia. As most things go with this series, the trio discovered his body at the worst of times – the evening after Oliver’s wedding. As if that wasn’t somber enough, his method of death is even more disturbing. In case you don’t remember, the trio discovered Lester’s body in the Arconia fountain, where he’d bled out. Despite the gruesome circumstances of his death, it was ruled an accident, but the trio believes otherwise.

One fascinating loose end from the previous season is the disappearance of Nicky Caccimelio. Although the trio turned down his wife’s request for them to investigate his disappearance because it happened “outside” of the building, they quickly realize he may be more important than they think. Spotted in the background of a photo from Oliver’s wedding day, Nicky is caught handing Lester a thick envelope of cash in plain sight. What could he possibly need this cash for, I wonder?

With these new findings, Mabel, Charles, and Oliver head to Staten Island to meet with Sofia Caccimelio and her five sons. This is no ordinary family, mind you — they’re a mob family, which is why Nicky’s disappearance is so concerning. Sofia gives Charles Nicky’s deck of cards, which, unbeknownst to any of them at first, contains a card with a hidden map and keycard. Once Charles discovers this, he informs Mora and the map leads them to the basement of the Arconia, where they find a hidden casino. Meanwhile, Putnam makes a gruesome discovery in the Caccimelio-owned dry cleaners next to the Arconia – Nicky, a cadaver in his chest, hanging dead from the dry cleaning rack.

Turns out Lester had more secrets, after all. Could his death really be an accident?

Episode Two: After You

“After You” is set in the past, showcasing Lester’s doorman career from start to finish. He seems clumsy and unsure of himself, eager to please George, the doorman training him. Over time, he falls in love with the Arconia — and his future wife.

As this episode spans approximately thirty years, we see cameos of younger versions of Mabel, Charles and Oliver. The youngest of the bunch, Mabel’s first cameo is as a baby, where Lester is friendly to her from the start. He later witnesses a young, shy, friendless Mabel evolve into the confident woman she becomes. Meanwhile, he witnesses the effects of Oliver’s messy divorce and Charles’ downward-spiraling career, ultimately seeing the most vulnerable sides of the three characters.

With sweet moments come sour ones, and we learn that Lester was aware of the existence of the Arconia’s underground casino. When George retires, he introduces Lester to none other than Nicky, who hosts secret casino game nights on Saturdays at midnight in exchange for large amounts of money. As the years pass, this questionable side-hustle is lucrative enough to get Lester’s children through college. It turns out the Lester we knew and loved was involved in a risky game.

Flashing forward to Lester’s death scene, he drops the mysterious elevator door crank, an instrument we see someone steal at the end of the scene. When Lester starts training the new doorman, Randall, the former refuses to answer the latter’s questions about the crank. What is the significance of this object, and why is Lester hiding it?

Episode Three: Rigor

Fast-forwarding to the present, Mabel, Charles and Oliver share their respective discoveries. Now that they know of the existence of the casino and the fact that Nicky is dead, not only must these two variables be connected, but Lester may have been involved.

Seeing one dead body is one thing, but this is the fifth murder the trio is attempting to solve, and that surely messes with the psyche. Here’s a brief review of how the characters are processing the fifth murder in the building:

Mabel performs her morbid dream of conducting an autopsy, which I fully endorse. However, her former toxic best friend, Althea (known as fictional pop artist “Thē”), moves into the Arconia’s penthouse, overshadowing Mabel’s success with the podcast.

Oliver seems happy with his relationship with Loretta, but he now has his DNA all over a mobster’s dead body – not to mention he frantically wheels said body throughout the streets of Manhattan, bumping into people along the way. Now, the body is in his apartment. Not the best look, is it?

Charles is simply having a crisis. Although Sazz’s death undoubtedly affected him the most, Nicky’s death makes him think of his own mortality. While seeing visions of ghost-Sazz talking to him seemed semi-normal, he hallucinates sporadic conversations with Nicky, someone he never knew.

Returning to Nicky’s informal autopsy, the trio identifies he’s likely already experienced rigor mortis, the stiffening of the body approximately 2-6 hours after death. Mabel further discovers a burn mark behind his ear, which she speculates is a freezer burn. Who has access to a freezer that large, and how long has Nicky been dead?

Putting these questions aside, the trio sneaks into the casino on Saturday at midnight. Because Nicky’s death isn’t public knowledge, they figure some guests might show up. Their suspicions are correct as three not-so-ordinary billionaires enter the room, one of whom is missing a finger.

It seems the Arconia harbors its fair share of secrets.

Episode Four: Dirty Birds

In this episode, billionaires Jay, Camilla and Bash attend an impromptu dinner party at Oliver’s apartment. Unsurprisingly, they threaten to sue the podcast for libel if they mention any of them by name. Trying to put them at ease, the trio decides to split up; Mabel corners Jay, Oliver confronts Camilla, and Charles cooks “duck à l’orange” with Bash, who doesn’t know how to wield a cadaver – the very weapon found in Nicky’s chest.

Mabel and Jay seem to form a connection, but he’s reluctant to divulge what happened to his finger.

Camilla criticizes Oliver for his interior design choices, but he manages to extract knowledge on how Nicky lost his finger.

Bash simply frightens Charles with his poor cadaver skills, a suspicious coincidence given the sloppy circumstances of Nicky’s death.

Although they think the rendezvous went well (despite no one eating Charles’ home-cooked meal), things are not what they seem. At the end of the episode, the wealthy company “Wondify” agrees to sponsor the podcast. To everyone’s surprise, especially Mabel’s, they head to the studio immediately to sign their contracts. The unexpected caveat, however, is that they are now locked into a three-year deal where Jay, Camilla and Bash can control what content they are permitted to record and publish on their podcast. As if matters couldn’t get any worse, tensions are still high with Lester’s killer on the loose and Oliver’s DNA on Nicky’s body. Furthermore, Mabel realizes that the finger she found points left, whereas Nicky’s points right. Not only are they back to square one, but they’re worse off than when they started, trapped in a game of cat-and-mouse led by the rich.

Concluding Thoughts: Theories, Suspects, and Teasers

Though it’s too early for me to say, I’m highly suspicious of the obvious suspects, the three billionaires. However, I can’t help but wonder if the Caccimelio family, particularly Sofia, could’ve been involved. Another suspect is Thē, who rubs me the wrong way, though we don’t have enough information on her. Based on past episodes, the killer is always someone we don’t expect, so I’m keeping my eyes out for intriguing side characters.

Stay tuned for next week’s article, in which I’ll delve into the suspense and intrigue in episode five.

 


Charlotte Ruth is a third-year English major with minors in Creative Writing and Italian Studies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *