Wed. Nov 18th, 2026

Last week, I published an article in the news section about Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. (RFK, Jr.) being appointed as the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). I wanted to do a lot in that article, but ended up having to cut out some portions for the sake of being concise and on topic. One of these portions was an interview with Dr. Brent Ruswick, a history professor here at West Chester University who is interested in health sciences and medicine, about how public health was dealt with in the past and historical vaccine skepticism. He provided great insight on these topics, and I felt that what he provided should still be read, so below is our interview (or rather, me emailing him questions, and him emailing me a Word document with his responses). Consider this article as a follow-up or context to my previous one: 

Before the HHS was established, how was public health in the U.S. dealt with in the past? 

Dr. Ruswick: The US dealt with public health in fits and starts, dependent on the needs of the time, and initiative of individual cities, states, or other administrative units. As far back as the Revolutionary War, in 1777 George Washington ordered all his troops to be inoculated against Smallpox — inoculation being the precursor to modern vaccination. His reasoning was sound: “Necessity not only authorizes but seems to require the measure, for should the disorder infect the Army in the natural way and rage with its usual virulence, we have more to dread from it than from the sword of the enemy.” And indeed, disease killed 90% of all Continental regular soldiers who died during the War, with Smallpox the leading threat. Washington’s public health measure was also a crucial war measure. Similarly, much of our modern Public Health movement originated in the Civil War. Northern war supporters established the United States Sanitary Commission to address the needs of injured Union soldiers, but also to institute public health measures to reduce the threat of disease on the battlefield. The successes of the Sanitary Commission led many Northern states to establish State Boards of Health after the Civil War. Some of those boards held little power beyond investigating and advising, collecting statistics, while others had the power to shape government policy on matters of public health. Cities, most notably New York City, took similar measures. Those efforts ranged from educational campaigns on proper cleaning in light of the discovery of germs, to fights against major killers and disablers like Tuberculosis. Tuberculosis, Typhoid, and Smallpox all could result in quarantine measures: Muncie, Indiana, had a smallpox outbreak in 1893 that resulted in guards outside the houses in one afflicted neighborhood, with a house designated for where they would incarcerate anyone who tried to break the quarantine. 

One major thing about RFK is his stance on vaccines. Are you able to detail the history of vaccine skepticism and how it persists? 

Dr. Ruswick: There have always been moments and pockets of skepticism toward vaccines and before them, inoculation. Lady Montague faced doubts in 1720 when she explained smallpox inoculation techniques to the scientific establishment in England, which dismissed it as women’s “folk” medical knowledge from the Middle East and Asia. At the same time, the Rev. Cotton Mather and Dr. Zabdiel Boylston faced religious and scientific opposition to their inoculation efforts in Boston — in part because the knowledge of how to protect against smallpox came from an enslaved African man, Onesimus. But these objections rapidly disappeared as the technique quickly proved effective against history’s greatest killer. A prominent historian of medicine calls the Rabies vaccine developed by Pasteur in France in 1885 as “America’s First Medical Breakthrough.” It’s hard to wrap our brains around what it was like to wait, in terror, for weeks, to see if the bite your child got from a strange dog would result in getting rabies, and with it, an agonizing, undignified, certain death. When Pasteur’s vaccine saved the lives of several small kids from New Jersey, they became national heroes and celebrities. It’s similarly hard for us to appreciate the fear parents had of polio, and the sense of national joy and accomplishment when Salk’s vaccine came out in 1955. My grandmother used to explain that polio is the reason why my mom never learned [how] to swim, but my aunt did. My mom was a child growing up before the vaccine, and public pools kept closing because no one wanted to risk their kid being paralyzed from catching polio at the pool. My aunt grew up after the vaccine was available, and so got to learn how to swim. There were pockets of resistance, especially against vaccination laws. The Jacobson vs. Massachusetts case in 1905. A smallpox outbreak a few years earlier in Boston had killed hundreds, resulting in a mandatory vaccination law. Jacobson refused, was fined five dollars, and took the case to the Supreme Court. In brief, they found that his liberties had not been violated because it was a legitimate exercise of government power to protect the safety of its citizens, and the determination of the need for mandatory vaccination had been made by the proper medical experts, so it was neither unreasonable nor arbitrary. Vaccine skepticism can be found anywhere: most of us aren’t medical experts, and any medical intervention for ourselves, or especially our kids, can produce lots of anxiety. But those moments of personal skepticism didn’t produce larger, durable anti-vaccine movements until quite recently. Instead there tended to be isolated flare-ups though within an otherwise broad, deep, strong and enthusiastic consensus that vaccines were a modern marvel, one of the hallmarks of civilization and progress. There [wasn’t] a widespread movement to transform vaccine skepticism into an anti-vaccine movement until the 1990s. While you can find things like the Jacobson case in 1905 or anti-inoculation and anti-vaccination rallies in the 1800s, and much of the rhetoric about individual choice and questioning of the scientific findings on efficacy and safety sound familiar, it’s of a different kind than the modern movement.  

Again, I would like to thank Dr. Ruswick for all the information he provided. While I regret not being able to fit his answers into my original article, I hope that this interview can help others contextualize the modern anti-vaxx movement and the history of public health, which is a topic that could tend to be overlooked.  

 


Jack Snock is a third-year political science major with a journalism minor. AS993182@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *