Image: Ubisoft sign at PAX Prime 2014 by camknows via Flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 2)
Unless you have been living under a rock lately, these are strange times indeed for the gaming industry. Despite more games being published every year, sales have been waning since the end of the COVID-19 lockdown, and no other gaming giant has been feeling the pinch quite like Ubisoft.
In spite of the French gaming behemoth’s rich catalog of beloved intellectual properties, the company itself has been on shaky ground for the past five years. Its recent releases, such as “Skull and Bones,” “Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora,” “Star Wars: Outlaws,” “XDefiant” and “Champions Tactics: Grimoria Chronicles,” received poor-to-mixed receptions, the last of which were met with mockery by the gaming public for being seen as an attempt to capitalize on NFTs.
This was made clear back in September 2024, when Ubisoft faced pressure from its investors regarding the substantial decline of its stock price, which had peaked in January 2021, according to data from CompaniesMarketCap.com, at $99 per share. Another criticism leveled at Ubisoft was CEO Yves Guillemot’s perceived mismanagement of the company, according to one investor, AJ Investments. The Slovakia-based private equity firm had issued an open letter that September to Ubisoft’s management, as well as their new stakeholder, Tencent, stressing “dissatisfaction with the performance of the company and its current share price,” according to an article that same month by IGN’s Wesley Yin-Poole. He continues and also quotes the open letter itself: “AJ Investments, a hedge fund that holds less than 1% in Ubisoft, urged the board of directors to take the company private or sell it to a strategic investor. The group clearly wants to see Guillemot out as CEO and threatened to gather similarly disgruntled minority shareholders for a ‘proxy fight’ that would brute force a sale if its demands are not met. It also called for further layoffs at the company, despite the brutal state of the video game industry for developers. ‘Ubisoft at [its] current state is mismanaged and shareholders are hostages of Guillemot family members and Tencent who take advantage of them,’ the open letter reads.”
Part of this investor backlash was due in part to Ubisoft’s decision to delay the release date of their newest game from November 2024 to February 2025, and then again to March 20, 2025. According to an article from Insider Gaming’s Tom Henderson in September of last year, the reasons behind this double delay involved the game’s developers stressing the need to polish the quality of the end product: “Seven developers working on the project said that they have been pushing for a delay for some time, and their situation had even been heard at other studios in the company. Ultimately, though, the delay comes down to a strict development timeline and the need to address issues caused by the set timeline.”
This friction between Ubisoft and AJ Investments continued up until just before the release day of “Assassin’s Creed: Shadows,” with AJ Investments threatening to hold a protest demonstration outside of the company’s headquarters in Saint-Mandé, France, this May. As reported by IGN’s Vikki Blake on March 12, “In a statement seen by IGN, Juraj Krúpa, CEO of AJ Investments, claimed Ubisoft is ‘horribly mismanaged by current management,’ and wants a ‘clear roadmap for recovery’ from the senior team to address ‘declining shareholder value, lackluster operational execution, and failure to adapt effectively to market trends.’ Krúpa alleged that Ubisoft has not been transparent about its decision-making, accusing the firm of ‘hiding information’…The shareholder also pointed to a restricted article published by business investment platform MergerMarket that alleged ‘discussions between Microsoft, EA, and others that are interested in acquiring IPs from Ubisoft.’ ‘Management did not inform the public about these steps either,’ Krúpa claimed.”
All of this popular discontent with CEO Yves Guillemot and Ubisoft seems to be on the mend, however, as “Assassin’s Creed: Shadows” launched on March 20 to a generally positive reception from critics and rising sales for the French gaming company. According to Ubisoft’s official account for Assassin’s Creed on X (formally known as Twitter), the company boasted on March 22 that their newest game had reached two million players and claimed that “Shadows” “has now surpassed the launches of ‘AC Origins and Odyssey!’” As of the time of this writing, the game sits at a positive 81% on Metacritic.com.
Ubisoft’s management had a lot riding on the success of this game, following the controversies around “Shadows.” One of which surrounded the depiction of a one-legged Torii Gate in the game’s promotional materials, which some irate audiences claimed looked similar to the sacred Sannō Shrine in Nagasaki, Japan, known for surviving the atomic blast during World War II. Another controversy involved the potential for players to damage religious shrines in-game, which was picked up on by Japanese authorities, specifically involving the real-life Itate Hyozu Shrine in Hyogo Prefecture, Japan, but thankfully Ubisoft has released a patch for the game that makes this potential to damage shrines impossible.
With the success of “Assassin’s Creed: Shadows,” it is possible that Ubisoft’s investors, including Tencent, will find a sense of renewed faith with the Guillemot family, who founded the gaming company 39 years ago and are the majority shareholders. As of the time of this writing, AJ Investments have not publicly made any statements regarding the success of Ubisoft’s latest game, and it is murky to say whether they will undo their plans for a protest of the company.
Kelly Baker is an alumnus of West Chester University of Pennsylvania.
