Thu. Nov 19th, 2026

Image: “Creature Commandos” (2024) Show Poster via IMDb

“Creature Commandos” (2024), the first TV show in the new cinematic DC Universe (DCU) created by James Gunn and Peter Safran, was released over winter break. The first episode was put on Max on Dec. 5, and has received much critical acclaim since it ended on Jan. 9. This show, created and written by Gunn, is filled with a lot of the charm and humor you can expect. The directing was split between Matt Peters and Sam Liu who complement Gunn’s writing very well, and it resulted in a show that has become massively popular. 

When originally prompted to watch “Creature Commandos” though, I was quite hesitant. Like many people, the idea of starting a whole new cinematic universe seemed exhausting, and not worth my time. Especially with the DC’s former cinematic universe, the DC Extended Universe (DCEU), struggling to release a project better than mediocre. Also, the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has had a downfall in quality since “Avengers: Endgame” in 2019, with only a few standout projects recently. Even with this cinematic universe fatigue holding me back I decided I’d watch “Creature Commandos” as a favor to some friends, and I’m really glad I did.

Front to back this show stays consistently entertaining with interesting characters, flashy animations and a unique soundtrack. This show places a huge emphasis on reeling back all the lore of the DC universe and just giving the audience a fun and enjoyable experience. You could know absolutely nothing about the DC universe and still find yourself having a good time, as long as you embrace the goofiness of it.

The choice to make this show animated I found weird at first, especially since the next project coming to the DCU is Gunn’s live-action “Superman: Legacy.” It’s strange seeing any cinematic universe switch between animated and live-action, but I think it definitely worked in favor of “Creature Commandos.”

The show does a great job of not taking itself too seriously, and the comic-book-like animations perfectly match this approach. From the writing to the character designs, this animation complements every detail of the show, especially the fight scenes. The fight scenes continue this show’s consistent ability to entertain and take it to the absolute max. They take full advantage of every character’s powers and abilities, or sometimes lack thereof, and use them to make fight scenes that are not only entertaining but impressive as well. These fights are only enhanced by the euphonious soundtrack that upped the intensity of each and every fight. It wasn’t the soundtrack I expected, but I thought Gunn did a phenomenal job of picking songs that fit the show thematically. It is exactly what I’ve come to expect, and he did not disappoint.

Now when it comes to the characters this show hits another home run. While the first episode dedicates its entirety to being a big introduction, every episode that follows focuses on one character. While the main story progresses it’ll stop at times to flashback to how the character of that episode became the monster they are, but also showcases the human that hides underneath. These flashbacks can range from somewhat emotional to deeply tragic, but there wasn’t a single one I didn’t love watching. This is by far my favorite element of the show as I slowly started to sympathize with these so-called monsters. By the end I found myself invested in this interesting group of characters that blur the line between monster and human.

Now while these consistent flashbacks do make each episode very formulaic, which some may find stale, I thought it helped me get even more excited for the next episode. Not only was I wondering which character they would focus on next, but also what makes them what they are. It creates a good contrast to the main story, which is taken a lot less seriously.

If you’ve noticed with all the praise I’ve given this show, there is one important thing I left out, and that’s the main story. While it is not necessarily bad, it is by far the weakest link.

The plot is just too simple, once you get past the first episode’s exposition dumps there isn’t much that can’t be explained for the main plot in less than two minutes. By the time I reached the last episode, I didn’t care an awful lot about the story, but more about what the flashbacks would be. By the end, it felt clear that a lot more effort was put into making these flashbacks the most interesting, while the main plot got pushed to the side. This becomes even more apparent when you see how the flashbacks transition into the main story.

There were times when the flashbacks were smoothly woven into the story through direct ties to the main plot, but most of them felt like they were just thrown in at somewhat random. There were also episodes where the plot would go out of its way to try and make the flashbacks relevant, which felt extremely forced. Having these great flashbacks of showing monsters with humanity comes at the cost of an interesting, forward-moving plot. The story stops for these moments instead of interweaving them appropriately, allowing for there to be sections of the show that feel weirdly thrown together.

There is one episode in particular, I won’t say which one, that is almost completely filler. Besides a scene here and there, everything that happens in the episode has little to nothing to do with the plot. Like every episode, it does contain very interesting flashbacks for one of the main characters, but that shouldn’t be the main focus of the episode. It felt like a huge pause in the story, as I kept asking myself how these scenes would have any impact on the plot, and I was left disappointed. 

For many shows, an episode here and there that’s more focused on character-building than the plot I wouldn’t mind. But in a seven-episode season, there is no time for that. Every episode has to be used to its extent to tell an engaging story, especially if there aren’t that many episodes. If the show was longer, then an episode with some filler in it could have flown under the radar, but when it comes to “Creature Commandos” it sticks out like a sore thumb.

With all the bad I’ve just said about this show, I felt the ending did a solid job of setting up for the next season, and it has already been renewed on Max. I am definitely excited to see this next season, especially with the release of any DCU projects that release in between seasons. There is much room for improvement, but I have enough trust in Gunn and Safran to say I think they’ll learn from their mistakes.

Overall “Creature Commandos” reminds us that even monsters can be human, no matter how much they may look the part. I went into “Creature Commandos” with pretty low expectations, and found myself impressed throughout the majority of my time watching. Is it one of the best shows I’ve ever watched? No, I wouldn’t even say it’s close, but it was definitely a great time. While it never fails to be incredibly entertaining, it does fail to reach a level of quality with the main plot to fully keep my interest. The show is a solid start to James Gunn and Peter Safran’s DCU, but I’m hoping that down the line the next projects will have more substance to them. 

6/10 

 


Samuel J. Beadle is a first-year English major. SB1033446@wcupa.edu 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *