Thu. Nov 19th, 2026

When Gregory Maguire published “Wicked” in 1995, it became a smash hit. Not only was the novel itself successful, but a musical based on the book became a Broadway sensation. We thought the story was over when Dorothy defeated Elphaba, but surprisingly, no. Questions began arising: who was Liir, the little boy traveling with the Wicked Witch of the West? Was he truly her son? “Son of a Witch,” the sequel to “Wicked,” was Maguire’s attempt to answer those nagging thoughts. Published in October 2005, the sequel tells the story of the minor character from “Wicked,” Liir, who supposedly appeared out of nowhere by Elphaba’s side. The story begins when the Superior Maunt, Oatsie, discovers the mangled body of a mysterious boy lying in the middle of a field. She takes him to the Mauntery, similar to a convent, where he lies in a coma for months. Candle, a young girl taken in by the Sisters, attempts to bring the boy back to life by playing music.

Maguire uses the above plot point as a base, but the rest of the story weaves in and out of flashbacks, which are meant to bring Liir back to the present. He introduces Liir as a less-than-loveable character: a boy with no recollection of his past, and no true ambition to find a future. Of course, he joins the military of the Emerald City, attempting to settle disputes among the different tribes throughout Oz. He also takes on the task of finding a young girl he knew as a child, Nor. She was the daughter of Elphaba’s lover, Fiyero, and was kidnapped along with her mother, Sarima. Liir gets so close to discovering her whereabouts, when he seems to just lose interest entirely.

Other events thrown into the mix include a council of talking birds, who ask for Liir’s assistance in defeating deadly dragons. This is yet another task which he reluctantly takes on, still very unsure of himself and his talents. One would think that to call the sequel to “Wicked,” “Son of a Witch, would tell how Liir discovered his true roots and attempted to follow in Elphaba’s footsteps. This, unfortunately, is not the case at all. Even towards the end of the novel, Liir is still uncertain of his heritage, though he eventually adopts the last name Thropp in Elphaba’s honor. The only real clue given to readers about the clarification of the title, if you could even call it that is the final line, relating to Liir and Candle’s child: “He took her to the doorway and held her up in the warm rain. She cleaned up green.”

The novel, while brilliantly detailed, lacks a true, interesting plot. One might become lost in the almost consistent changes of view point, which occur every couple of chapters. This makes it difficult to follow one particular story. Of course, the issue of Ozian politics and religion weighed heavily amongst the tale as well.

The sequel to “Wicked” was certainly not needed. Maguire could have easily tied loose ends as he finished the first novel, and was clearly just playing on his success with “Wicked” when he wrote “Son of a Witch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *