Thu. Nov 19th, 2026

This week Democratic leaders Harry Reed and Nancy Pelosi postponed a vote on any potential bailouts for the automotive industry till the second weekend in December saying that nothing would pass until the big three present them with a plan on how they will use the money to make their companies more profitable in the future. They also recommended the CEO’s for GM, Chrysler and Ford fly coach the next time they come by Washington instead of using their private jets. Seems when you are begging for money having personal jets flying you around the country doesn’t give the best impression to senators.The CEO’s seemed determined to get the message across that they are completely not at fault for their companies being in trouble. The reason their companies are in trouble is 100 percent the fault of the current economy. While I understand times are tough this seems a little na’ve. Actually it seems to be the exact reason these companies are in this position in the first place. They refuse to accept reality and refuse to fix their problems.

First GM, Chrysler and Ford had the opportunity to restructure their companies towards higher quality, better gas mileage and lower emissions vehicles for the last …ohh … 25 years. They not only did not make these changes they actively fought them by spending their money on lobbyist, and campaign contributions to try and prevent higher standards from passing in congress. They succeeded. To celebrate the defeat of higher emission standards and better gas mileage requirements GM not only stopped their electric car program, they destroyed every prototype they had already built. Way to think ahead Detroit!

This exact same problem appeared in the late 70’s and early 80’s when gas shortages and sky rocketing fuel prices put a premium on fuel efficient cars. Instead of doing just that our American automotive industry built more SUVs. In fact they still rely on big expensive SUV vehicles as a major portion of their profits. Meanwhile companies like Toyota and Honda took the 80’s and 90’s to build higher quality more fuel efficient cars like the Camry and the accord. As a result they have grown to dominate the auto market. If not for the economic slow down Toyota was poised to take over from GM as the largest auto company in the U.S. this year. Instead it will happen next year most likely.

Plus Honda and Toyota built plants here in the U.S. and brought new jobs to the country for American auto workers. Meanwhile the big three have steadily been shipping American jobs overseas and across the border. In all likelihood by the end of the next decade given current trends the majority of manufacturing jobs for the big three will be in other countries. Meanwhile through deals with foreign owned auto makers like Kia, Hyundai, and the previously mentioned Toyota and Honda, more manufacturing jobs will be created for Americans with these companies.

Now this isn’t to say if one, two or possibly all three of the American auto companies fail jobs will not be lost. They will, a large number of them. Currently, roughly 750,000 people work for the big three auto companies, and roughly another 750,000 work for companies that get their business almost solely from the big three. That means close to 1.5 million people will lose their job if those companies fail.sort of.

In reality a lot of people will lose their job but that is going to happen anyway. It has been apparent even before the financial crisis that the big three just weren’t selling enough cars to keep three major auto makers in business. At least one was bound to fail at some point. However, this will be a good thing for the other two. With less selection this will boost sales amongst the other two companies. This will increase the other two company’s sales numbers and make them more viable business.

Plus as I said before other companies are building manufacturing plants in the United States and they will need workers. While this will most likely mean relocating a lot of people who currently reside in Michigan, these workers will be very attractive as experienced factory workers and would be worth hiring on as such or for possible management positions.

Essentially what I am saying is it is time we stop trying to delay the inevitable and allow at least one of Detroit’s big three to die. If congress refuses to bailout these failing companies and forces them into bankruptcy to restructure and allows the free market we hear so much about to work it will strengthen the remaining companies and create a stronger future.

We would be better suited using $25 billion dollars to help develop solar and wind energy companies that will also create well paying manufacturing jobs now, and in the future. The Detroit auto companies are not a good investment and haven’t been for a long time. Our tax dollars are better invested in companies that have shown the vision and business sense to grow and be profitable in the future while creating new and valuable jobs here in America.

Edward Trevorrow is a student at West Chester University. He can be reached at ET666499@wcupa.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *